News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We picked the wrong lawyers for our first startup by opendais on Thursday May 29, 2014 @02:50PM (#7817887)
I live in a state, lets say, California. From what I understand there is alot of people there. ;)

http://www.sos.ca.gov/business/be/faqs.htm#form-question7 If I do business with anyone in California, as an employee who lives and works in California, I'm engaging in intrastate commerce on behalf of the company.

I'm also "doing business in California" as I'm paying over $50k in wages for tax purposes [since Engineers are going to be at least that anyway].

So, now I have to:

1) Incorporate in Delaware, Register as a Foreign Business Entity in California.

2) I need to pay for a registered agent in both states.

3) I need a lawyer familiar with laws in both states or 2 different lawyers.

4) If I do business in Delaware [since incorporation in Delaware makes it intrastate business], I now have a tax nexus in two states which complicates my tax situation.

5) There is no tax or legal obligation to do this, so why shouldn't a person wait until they have to add this complexity?

That is two sets of fees, tax structures, and potentially legal counsel I now require. If I've got 7 figures in funding, sure, this is not a big deal. If I'm bootstrapping with the $20k I have in my savings account, suddenly doubling these costs is not insignificant and may potentially sink me and/or cause me to fail a tax audit with the associated expenses.

I'm uncertain why you think it is 'always' a good idea to do this from the start. Please explain how my reasoning is incorrect as I am not a lawyer.

Thank you.

Re:We picked the wrong lawyers for our first startup by opendais on Thursday May 29, 2014 @04:24PM (#7818399)
I'm slightly amused that my parent post is being downvoted yet no one is willing to respond to the reasoning I've presented.

I think HN really needs to track downvotes if only because it is intellectual cowardice to try to bury a dissenting voice without explaining why.

Re:We picked the wrong lawyers for our first startup by Iftheshoefits on Thursday May 29, 2014 @05:27PM (#7818695)
There isn't really a counter to your argument. I wonder if some of the downvotes are from people who might feel a tad guilty about having conducted what is effectively tax evasion.
Re:We picked the wrong lawyers for our first startup by opendais on Thursday May 29, 2014 @05:38PM (#7818747)
Well, I hope that isn't the reason. I'd like to think people don't intentionally engage in tax evasion.
Re:We picked the wrong lawyers for our first startup by jesusmichael on Thursday May 29, 2014 @03:54PM (#7818243)
^this