Don't forget that the burden of maintaining the prison system is on the shoulders of the rest of society.
America has an absolutely amazing number of people in prison at any given time, also the chances of becoming a prisoner in your lifetime border on the medieval compared to the rest of the developed world.
That implies that the imprisoning is arbitrary, which it isn't. If you don't commit major crimes then your chance of being imprisoned is near zero.
You think so ?
Three strikes law ?
Minor drugs infractions ?
stuff like this:
http://www.outsidethebeltway.com/archives/topless_woman_poli...
Think again:
In most first-world countries, you won't be imprisoned for having minor amounts of marijuana; you won't get strip searched at middle school if they suspect you have Midol; you won't be labeled a sex offender for life for having oral sex with a fellow teenager who happens to be 3 months (1 year on paper) younger than you; you certainly won't get arrested and have your children taken away for taking a picture of yourself breastfeeding your baby.
Let's not even talk about the trumped up criminality of not-for-profit copyright infringement.
On the other hand, these things all happen in the US on a seemingly regular basis.
People have gone to jail "forever" for the final crime of stealing a box of candy. You can pound that til it's flat, but that is the truth. The other offenses were not violent.
And the woman who had her kids taken away because of the breastfeeding pic? I don't think that was exaggerated at all.
http://www.dallasobserver.com/2003-04-17/news/1-hour-arrest&...
What I mean is this: there are literally millions of cases, there would have to be in order to have 2 million people in prison. Many more cases will not have made it through the prosecution process, I'm assuming there are still some level-headed judges and juries out there.
But 'woman exonerated for making breast feeding pic' does not make a very good headline, so you'll never hear about it.
Which is ok, because the system already took care of that one.
So, the media is on the right side in this one, but it still distorts the image.
That's not really a glowing followup, don't you think?
You're simply alluding to a vague argument that, if you spell it out, will probably sound very silly. I understand and acknowledge that there are different reasons a penal system could be based on (deterrance vs. vengeance vs. simple separation of criminal from law-abider). But under none of those reasons is this a terribly "throw-the-book" punishment. Are you simply against the idea of a prison system in general? Are you for legalizing harassment of witnesses? What? Spell it out.
I don't think prison is the answer except when we decide that the person in question believes themselves above the law/is too great a risk.
We do need some sort of means of deterrant and stripping one's liberty should be strong enough - to introduce someone into a enclosed society (prison) where rape, violence and drug abuse may as well be decriminalised seems too much for most crimes.
People commit crimes because either a) they don't think they'll be caught, b) they don't care if they get caught or c) they're insane. People that respect the law rarely do so because of the threat of punishment.