News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Online Communities Decay Over Time by probably_wrong on Friday May 23, 2014 @05:19PM (#7791400)
> The real problem with online communities is that the people who are upvoted the most are the ones who spend the most time commenting.

I remember a claim of a similar but opposed problem: that low quality short content is much more rewarding that long, thoughtful responses. See a funny cat pic? I chuckled, upvote. See a long answer that doesn't quite fit your opinion? Downvote, or ignore at best. Short and funny trumps long and thoughtful.

This is not a problem in HN thanks to moderation, but it happens a lot in other communities.

Re:Why Online Communities Decay Over Time by butmaybeifly on Saturday May 24, 2014 @02:46AM (#7792788)
Too black and white. Why not be funny, short AND thoughtful? Why does everyone here have such tunnel vision?
Re:Why Online Communities Decay Over Time by Mithaldu on Saturday May 24, 2014 @05:17AM (#7792988)
Because often points cannot be made in a short manner and still be understood. Just like in this very post some points need some explanation of their context and the thought chain leading to them, or people will not understand how the poster arrived there and simply voice their disagreement, instead of sitting down for a while and thinking about the post and trying to recreate that chain of thought on their own.