It's all wrong.
On the general "over-diagnosis" of ADHD, my problematic social-darwinist opinion: I believe that especially in the US there might really be more people with ADHD brains (in the end leaving your continent to settle on a new one is still perceived as something bold to do in 2014 - think of how much more risky this must have felt over the first couple of centuries after the discovery of America).
I can also think of many reasons why people are willing to take medication these days - all of them probably boil down to being profoundly desperate. I remember my grandfather who died last year at age 90, he clearly had all the traits of severe ADHD but he also had a secretary (cue "Mad Men" generation) and so didn't need to manage all the minutiae himself and was very successful at his job at a big company fully capitalizing his creative/impulsive side. This is a luxury most people with ADHD don't have any more as we are expected to do a lot more different, often detail oriented little jobs in-between - so to be able to do a somewhat acceptable job with those kinds of tasks it drives people towards drugs like Adderall, Ritalin etc (I'm constantly abusing caffeine myself, it doesn't help much but again I'm desperate). I can't tell you how devastating it feels when people who don't understand our different wiring shout at you to "simply just fucking do it" when you are really, really trying hard to do just that. It's terrible and drives a lot of people towards alcohol and heavy drug addictions. I've read somewhere that a very high percentage of the jail population actually has ADHD.
I believe that especially in the US there might really be
more people with ADHD brains (in the end leaving your
continent to settle on a new one is still perceived as
something bold to do in 2014 - think of how much more
risky this must have felt over the first couple of
centuries after the discovery of America)
I'd never thought of that before. Another possible reason for increased prevalence in the US is that we work more hours and have less vacation time than a lot of European countries, increasing the demands on our focus.Also, just for solidarity's sake: I was also diagnosed in my 30s, and was called "lazy" (etc.) a lot when young. Bet we went through a lot of the same things.
[^1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Georgia_%28U.S...
And its not only non-Europeans who came here other than as a result of boldly choosing.
I think that's more up to the individual than the institution. My own story is a typical "I didn't know I had ADHD until it was too late," and I do wonder if I would have a better life if I just went straight into the workforce instead of spending a couple extra years trying to finish college and not realizing why its so hard for me. I even had a decent IT job in college, but thought it so shameful not to have a college degree that I quit to continue my studies and, of course, get deeper into debt. Maybe some personality types just don't work well in those environments. Insert typical "higher education isn't for everyone" debate here.
>Not to mention the "hunter-gatherer vs farmer" dichotomy doesn't explain the rise of ADHD diagnoses in the last 20 years
Maybe because society has reached a point where we can discuss these things without the idea of punishment and without applying morality to it? ADHD kids in the past were beaten, called losers, call sinful, called stupid, etc. Society hit them as hard as it could, yet it didn't fix anything. We've moved away from that mode of thinking and realized that some kids just aren't going to grow out of it and its not their fault. The same way that Alzheimers has been part of the human condition for god knows how long yet we only "discovered" it 1906. Before that, we just thought it was part of getting old and didn't realize its actually separate from aging the same way ADHD is separate from being an energetic child.
> Certainly it's less addictive than caffeine.
Getting off caffeine is trivial. Adderal withdrawal can be very serious for many people. I consider most ADHD meds to be pretty serious drugs. I don't think that's very controversial.
Getting off caffeine is trivial. Adderal withdrawal can
be very serious for many people.
This is obviously anecdotal, but I've discontinued Adderall (by tapering my dosage to zero over the course of 3-4 days) on numerous occasions with zero withdrawal or side effects.Quitting caffeine by the same method is quite a bit more difficult for me.
Caffeine withdrawal is no joke either. Getting off caffeine is not trivial, and "can be very serious for many people" as well.
Whether or not your statement is controversial, your implication is not pharmacologically correct, in the sense that caffeine and amphetamines are both comparably serious drugs. It is not very meaningful to compare the addictive potential of two substances, but to the extent that we can, the two are roughly the same[0].
Contrary to public perception, it is not correct to say that amphetamines are inherently "more serious" than caffeine; the means of ingestion, dosage, and (most importantly) the individual's personal biochemistry vary enough that you cannot compare those two drugs directly.
[0] The reason it is not a meaningful comparison is that the actual chemical compound is only one small factor that influence substance abuse and/or dependence. The means of ingestion alone is far more significant than the actual compound being ingested, which often surprises people to learn.
> It's fine to say "change the environment" but that's not always an option. ^ good point.
Speaking as someone who has ADHD and benefits from
Adderall, I don't experience it as "crack". Nor have I
found it remotely addictive. Certainly it's less
addictive than caffeine.
Similar experiences. Adderall is definitely not pleasurable in the sense that something like cocaine or meth (I don't have experiences with them) seems to be pleasurable.I find Adderall addictive in the sense that I'm severely "lagged" and sleepy if I discontinue it cold turkey. But, if I taper the dose to zero over 3-4 days, there is no problem.
A few specific quibbles:
The article says it's not a "disorder", but a "disorder" in psychiatry-speak means "Any pattern of psychological or behavioral symptoms that causes an individual significant distress, impairs their ability to function in life, and/or significantly increases their risk of death, pain, disability, or loss of freedom." ADHD symptoms may not represent a disorder for every individual in every situation. It's fine to say "change the environment" but that's not always an option.
Not to mention the "hunter-gatherer vs farmer" dichotomy doesn't explain the rise of ADHD diagnoses in the last 20 years mostly in the US vs other western countries, which are just as rich and just as regimented.
The other issue I have is with Thom Hartmann's description of ADHD which focuses on distractability and hyperactivity, but those are just two of the most common of the many symptoms that make up ADHD.
Finally, the woman apparently is familiar with abusing Adderall herself. Speaking as someone who has ADHD and benefits from Adderall, I don't experience it as "crack". Nor have I found it remotely addictive. Certainly it's less addictive than caffeine.
The general points are fine (schools and workplaces in the US have issues of their own that encourage ADHD-like symptoms), but the details are wildly wrong.