News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by joostdevries on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:25AM (#7782418)
"Searching for “most amazing woman ever” on Bing will give you MetaFilter’s helpful “Who is the most amazing woman who ever lived” as the third result. (Answers, by the way, included British spy and French Resistance leader Nancy Wake, world’s first programmer Ada Lovelace, slave rescuer and activist Harriet Tubman, and Chinese pirate Ching Shih.) Google puts it at the bottom of the second page of results, in 19th place. Google’s top result? A list of “the 100 most beautiful women ever.” "

That made me wonder whether Google has shifted its products from being the kind of thing that their own employee corps would enjoy to things for the general public. I personally f.i. enjoyed the from: to: keywords in Google Maps search. That feature disappeared and probably the majority of users wouldn't use those anyway. Personally I scorn at a search result of the '100 most beautiful women'. But in the large population it will probably lead to a much higher click through. So I wonder if Google Search was oriented towards the smart crowd niche and that they changed focus towards the common and the populous. To put it differently: a shift from an emphasis in information as high value search result towards including entertainment, gossip etc. High brow to low brow.

Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by tedivm on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:37AM (#7782445)
This is by far the best reason I've heard for the decline in quality of Google search results. There's no doubt that when I first started using Google it was for technical things, and I feel like most of the people online during their first few years of life were doing the same. I'm guessing we're no longer their target market, although I wouldn't be surprised if an algorithm made that decision instead of a person.

At the same time, they are trying to do targeted search and I feel like that should be able to help far more than it is.

Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by madcaptenor on Thursday May 22, 2014 @09:41AM (#7783772)
Seconding targeted search. If google knows so much about me, why do they send me to stuff they should know I'd never want to read?
Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by gabemart on Thursday May 22, 2014 @03:58AM (#7782641)
> I personally f.i. enjoyed the from: to: keywords in Google Maps search. That feature disappeared and probably the majority of users wouldn't use those anyway.

I still use that feature every day. I have a smart keyword setup so that I just type:

  maps from LAX to San Francisco
into the URL bar and get taken straight to a Google Maps page showing me that route [1]. Forgive me if I've misunderstood you and you're talking about something else, but this feature still exists. AFAIK I'm using the latest version of Google maps.

[1] https://www.google.co.uk/maps/preview?q=from+lax+to+san+fran...

Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by michaelt on Thursday May 22, 2014 @05:10AM (#7782846)
In classic Google Maps you could find a multi-leg route by searching with the syntax "from:san francisco to:los angeles to:new york" [1] whereas in new Google Maps the same query just shows you San Francisco [2].

The new Google Maps will do multi-point routes [3], but by default when you enter San Francisco to Los Angeles it chooses flights, and hides the option to enter a multi-point route. You have to switch to car directions to get the option to enter more than one point, and enter them one at a time not use the nice from-to-to syntax.

Pretty crap for power users - but I guess ad-supported products make their money by being mass market, and catering to power users isn't very important.

[1] https://maps.google.co.uk/maps?q=from:san+francisco+to:los+a... [2] https://www.google.co.uk/maps/search/from:san+francisco+to:l... [3] https://www.google.co.uk/maps/dir/San+Francisco,+CA,+USA/Los...

Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by gabemart on Thursday May 22, 2014 @05:27AM (#7782908)
Thanks for the clarification.

It also bugs me that there's no way to enter the mode of transportation as part of the URL query string. I'd love to be able to use smart keyword syntax like:

  from London to Cambridge by bike
  
  from Glasgow to Manchester by bus
Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by joostdevries on Thursday May 22, 2014 @05:12AM (#7782853)
Another example would be how google did sunset Google Reader. That also struck me as a product that was aimed at people who are rather similar to Google employees.
Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by DanBC on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:59AM (#7782494)
I get for "most amazing woman ever" (including quotes) images, then tumblr, pinterest, Facebook, Twitter, Twitter, then MetaFilter.

Sub-optimal, but not terrible.

Removing the quotes gives me similar reaults to you. But there are a few results about interesting women based on achievement not appearance.

Google is trained by the crowd, and the crowd is stupid. See for example the numbers of searches using + operator correctly.

Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by joostdevries on Thursday May 22, 2014 @03:05AM (#7782514)
I was quoting the article...