News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by chasing on Thursday May 22, 2014 @12:42AM (#7782148)
Metafilter's founder mathowie takes a much more measured tone about Google's role: "A year and a half ago, we woke up one day to see a 40% decrease in revenue and traffic to Ask MetaFilter, likely the result of ongoing Google index updates." (http://metatalk.metafilter.com/23245/State-of-MetaFilter)

Google changes. The web itself changes. As seminal as Metafilter has been, it doesn't "deserve" the top slots any more than any other content.

So I find it a little irritating that David Auerbach at Slate has attempted to overdramatize this into something it's really not.

Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by Lagged2Death on Thursday May 22, 2014 @01:11AM (#7782223)
...it doesn't "deserve" the top slots any more than any other content.

I thought the whole deal with inventing Page Rank and all these smart indexing algorithms - the whole raison d'être for Google - was exactly because some content was more deserving than other content.

When I do the search for "maybe there is a god," MeFi doesn't show up until page 8 now. The first two pages of results are virtually all videos and lyrics related to a single 12-year-old Christian pop song.

Which is available for sale on Google Play. Hmm.

Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by Lagged2Death on Thursday May 22, 2014 @05:12PM (#7786586)
One thing I wanted to mention earlier, didn't have time:

The pop song that comprises the first two pages of results for the "maybe there is a god" search is actually called "Mabye There's A Loving God." That's close to the search text, but it's not an exact match.

The MeFi page mentioned in the article contains the exact phrase "maybe there is a god" in the title. And it shows up on page eight of my search results. That is ridiculous.

You can argue that MeFi wasn't singled out on purpose, that algorithms change and there are bigger benefits elsewhere that I'm not seeing in this case and blah blah blah, and I don't know about any of that. No opinion.

But I think you're going to have a hard time arguing that these search results are in any way more accurate, more relevant, or better than the older results were.

And that is very much of a piece with recent, more general criticism of Google's search: That it's simply not as good, not as useful, as it used to be.

Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by SoftwareMaven on Thursday May 22, 2014 @12:50AM (#7782169)
I think Auerbach laid out some cogent reasons why this should be questioned. A gradual decrease over time? Sure, expected. A sudden drop? That's an algorithmic hit, and when a site with good content (that is ranked well by other search engines) is hit negatively by the algorithm, it should be questioned.

And, unfortunately, the only way to get Google to consider such a question is if enough people start echoing it.

Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by pbreit on Thursday May 22, 2014 @01:05AM (#7782211)
What do you mean it doesn't "deserve the top slot any more than any other content"? That doesn't make any sense at all. Obviously if it is the "best" answer to the search, then of course it "deserves" a high result. The author lists out some examples where this doesn't seem to be the case.

I didn't find the article overdramatizing at all. In fact it was quite measured and completely reasonable. And the timing is obviously consistent with Metafilter's recent announcement.

That a high quality site gets chopped in half doesn't bother you at all? And that Google's results seem off? Really, this doesn't deserve a mention?

Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by TTPrograms on Thursday May 22, 2014 @01:13AM (#7782228)
What's the justification that metafilter is in fact the best result for some wide range of queries? The content these days doesn't look drastically superior to Reddit / Stack Overflow etc. The author mainly argues the value of the content by citing threads from 2004 to 2009.

In order to make the point that Google has done something wrong here you need to demonstrate that there's actively superior content over there compared to the more mainstream communities, and the author doesn't persuade me.

Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by rhizome on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:19AM (#7782401)
The content these days doesn't look drastically superior to Reddit / Stack Overflow etc.

There is zero spam, zero meme threads, an engaged and involved membership and, perhaps a glaringly-missing signal on Google's part, consistency over a long time.

But even more than that, why would Ask Metafilter threads about e.g. renovating a kitchen rank lower than the 12 effectively-identical content-farm "howtos" from About, WikiHow, et al, that don't involve real people describing real experiences and knowledge? It's really a matter of prioritization, of what Google considers "superior," and I think there are some positive qualities that Google doesn't account for. Metafilter is certainly no worse for the Internet in general than Stack Exchange, doityourself.com, rottentomatoes, or other commonly high-ranked sites.

Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by TTPrograms on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:31AM (#7782432)
>There is zero spam, zero meme threads, an engaged and involved membership and, perhaps a glaringly-missing signal on Google's part, consistency over a long time.

I don't think this is drastically different from any of their competitors except the Reddit defaults, which are pretty much irrelevant for these purposes anyways (excluding consistency, which I don't really think is relevant when you're searching for something on Google).

>But even more than that, why would Ask Metafilter threads about e.g. renovating a kitchen rank lower than the 12 effectively-identical content-farm "howtos" from About, WikiHow, et al, that don't involve real people describing real experiences and knowledge?

I think About and WikiHow could lack the depth that Metafilter has, but they're going to win out on accessibility. I think a dedicated subreddit would win out on both fronts. If Google finds that people prefer accessibility, then that's what Google will deliver. I don't think there's anything wrong with that.

Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by ericd on Thursday May 22, 2014 @06:46AM (#7783119)
The issue is that it's ranking below extremely low quality sites in many cases, not that it's ranking below SO or Reddit (and in my experience, Metafilter results are almost always higher quality than Reddit threads, less so for SO, but those are only technical whereas Metafilter represents many more topics)
Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by dredmorbius on Thursday May 22, 2014 @12:47AM (#7782160)
Even if the prior position were unearned, the point that, perhaps, small changes in Google's algorithms can have dramatic influences over site rankings, with all the concomitant disruption that can entail, argues for conservatism on Google's part. Otherwise you're in the position of the philanthropist who, out of the goodness of his heart, supports some cause unreservedly ... until he doesn't. Suddenly withdrawn support has very real impacts.

If there _was_ a specific strike against Metafilter, Google really ought explain. Actually, even if there wasn't.

And it argues again against digital sharecropping, though that's harder and harder to avoid.

Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by mbrubeck on Thursday May 22, 2014 @07:39PM (#7787252)
But this isn't just about MetaFilter dropping out of the top slots. Google is actively accusing other sites of spamming because MetaFilter users linked to them. Google has clearly miscategorized MetaFilter as a spam farm, and is penalizing it and others because of this algorithmic error.
Re:Why Has Google Forsaken MetaFilter? by gojomo on Thursday May 22, 2014 @01:03AM (#7782205)
Maybe webmasters have to take a "measured tone", lest they anger the "black box" further.