News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by IgorPartola on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @11:36AM (#7778804)
I believe you are correct and the grandparent is not. The fifth protects you from being coerced into saying "I did the crime", but not from cooperating with court orders. By you uttering your passphrase, you are not incriminating itself (a wise guy in the crowd will as "What if my password is 'IDidIt!'?" In that case, as I understand it, the jury would be told to disregard the actual phrasing of the passphrase and look only at what the passphrase (really the decryption key) unlock.

In other words, yes this is exactly like refusing to open a safe. The only difference is that with a safe, if you no longer have the key, the law enforcement agencies can attempt other methods of opening the safe. If you lose your encryption key, nobody can prove that you actually lost it and are not just trying to hide it. In this case, it seems the judge will simply say that you are in contempt of court and will lock you up until your memory improves (as in indefinitely).

Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by mikecb on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @02:41PM (#7779965)
Like I said somewhere else, some courts have agreed with this analysis, and others differed. Obviously each case is fact intensive, but I imagine we'll have many more discussions as more cases come forward, a circuit split emerges, and it is eventually considered by the Supreme Court.