News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by mbillie1 on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:11PM (#7775760)
I feel bad for the people who grew up in the area and feel connected because of family or whatnot. As a software engineer NOT from SF, it's probably the last place in the country I'd move to - we have such a relative abundance of remote opportunities compared to other professions. I don't really see why I'd be willing to pay maybe up to 4x+ my housing cost for perhaps a 15% increase in pay. It's a nice place and all, but geez.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by downandout on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:24PM (#7775805)
>I feel bad for the people who grew up in the area

The people who grew up there (whose parents owned homes) are doing quite well (at least their parents are) because of the vast appreciation of their homes. Among some of my wealthy friends that have paid ridiculous prices for real estate in SF, I have heard the rather condescending term "thousand dollar millionaires" used to refer to these long-term homeowners that did nothing to create a $1M+ net worth other than pay their mortgage and live in the same place for decades.

Anyway, it's not the people who grew up there that you should feel bad for. It's the people that need to be there for one reason or another and can't afford a living wage with the incredibly inflated prices and taxes associated with living in SF and California in general.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by muyuu on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:16PM (#7775994)
Asset rich, when your asset is your home, is the worst kind of rich. Unless you have something else very very compelling to back it up.

If you sell, then say goodbye to your city. If you don't sell, then you don't have this capital, and you still live in a very expensive place.

You can mortgage it for a lot of capital, but this is a poisoned chalice.

Other means to actually realise any of that wealth is to try your luck and speculate downwards, which is extremely risky if that's your only big asset.

Lots of people are "feeling rich" without being realistically able to realise any of this wealth, since they cannot really move away from their city. This is fictitious wealth that constitutes a massive burden to the city and endangers its competitive place in the future.

It will pop sooner or later and its likely to cause massive social problems. It's causing them already even before that happened.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by bellcurvetopper on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:46PM (#7776103)
This is an excellent point.

I work as a real estate analyst in Shanghai, and this same situation is playing out here. Like San Francisco, buying a 2 BR 1,000 sqft apartment in the city proper can cost upwards of US$1M (RMB 6M), though here the GDP per capita is only US$6,000 vs ~$42k in the US. Also, many Chinese feel to own a home before marriage, which is usually accomplished by pooling the savings of parents and grandparents, and assuming one will be in debt until the end of time.

Those that have apartments probably bought them 10-15 years ago, when the price was 10X less. They are, as you mentioned, asset rich, but it doesn't translate into any greater quality of life.

The good news is that the rental market is relatively cheap here. In real estate terms, the cap rate (annual rent / sales price) for buying an apartment is around 1.5-2%, compared to 5%+ even in places like SF.

The market here in China, and the general obsession with real estate, is a deep an interesting topic. The best summary I've found so far is the corresponding section in the book "In Line Behind a Billion People". It's expensive by ebook standards but well worth the time/money for those curious about China.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by tibbon on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @11:23PM (#7776542)
In fact, it can be even worse with rising property tax valuations. The home you've owned forever might cost you more in taxes a year than a mortgage would be in many places.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by patrickyeon on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @11:33PM (#7776557)
My understanding of property tax in SF is that it is based on the price the house was purchased at. This means that the home you've owned forever has had a predictable tax based on that price, and only new owners you sell it to will be paying the higher cost tied to higher property value.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by bjt on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @02:06AM (#7776912)
That's all of California, thanks to Prop 13.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_13_(1978...

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by Balgair on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @02:51AM (#7776994)
Really, the article left out that HUGE issue. If you grew up in the Bay, you are very very familiar with this. I am surprised how many commenters here claim to live in the Bay, yet don't understand property taxes in California. It's a major issue in the state, not quite as big as water rights, but still major.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by tibbon on Thursday May 22, 2014 @02:24PM (#7785384)
A good point. To be fair, I've only been to CA 3x and live in Boston.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by thecage411 on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:34PM (#7776064)
I'd rather be asset rich than straight up poor!
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by aeturnum on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @10:17PM (#7776375)
This is an interesting perspective. I'm from Marin County (the "classic" cloister of the rich in the bay area). While I was growing up (1985 - 2004), there was already a cultural gulf in the community between the older population (families that had purchased houses before the prices spiked) and yuppies who were buying housing at hugely increased prices. On paper, many people in Marin are very wealthy, but in practice this isn't as common as the stats suggest (An ex-girlfriend's parents weren't well off enough to help her attend college, but her parents were considered too rich due to their house for financial aid).

I've been lucky enough to have parents who could afford to help me with school, and have an interest in a lucrative field (computer science). However, many of my highschool classmates did not have one (or both) of those advantages. They are also squeezed between a high cost of living and the lack of jobs that provide a realistic living wage. However, unlike migrants from other areas, the less fortunate locals do not have another home to go back to. I know families that moved their entire family out of the state while their kids were still in school because it became financially untenable to live in the area.

This situation reminds me of the ongoing situation in SF. There are plenty of stories (anecdotal though they may be) of long-time residents being forced out of communities by the economic climate. It is easy for outsides to look at the Bay Area and see a city made up of tech workers making $100k+ a year, but the reality is very different. The same is true of people who bought their houses in a different economic climate. At least the parents have the "escape value" of their houses, as long as they're willing to sell off 18+ years of their lives.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by sliverstorm on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:51PM (#7775905)
The people who grew up there don't have any extra wealth. So long as their parents continue to live in the same house, it's all just wealth "on paper".

Now, if they live with their parents, that is certainly a leg up in terms of not paying rent (or paying much less rent), but other than that...

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by ben0x539 on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:51PM (#7775908)
Is being a homeowner really the standard situation in SF one generation back?
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by oblique63 on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @10:54PM (#7776471)
Not in SF proper... I'm a native san franciscan that grew up in the mission in the 90's, and virtually every native san franciscan I've ever met has been a renter. I only had like 1 friend in high school whose parents actually owned a duplex in noe valley, but other than that, pretty much everybody was in small apartments. I think this is the reason why a lot of the "if you wanted a stable living situation, you should've bought a home" type arguments aggravate a lot of the anti-gentrification people in SF...
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by argonaut on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:09PM (#7775967)
Many parts of Silicon Valley were (and possibly still are) suburbs in the past: Palo Alto, Mountain View, Menlo Park.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by daemin on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:55PM (#7775919)
That same sort of thing happens in Australia, especially for coastal and beachfront properties. Where property was really cheap because it was far from major centres ended up getting really expensive over time. The only difference here is that those people tend to be squeezed out when they can no longer afford to pay the council rates (local taxes based on the value of the property). So they have to sell up, make a lot, pay a lot in income tax, and move somewhere far cheaper.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by brc on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @11:45PM (#7776586)
There is no tax payable on selling your home in Australia, unless it is a second home or investment property, or you purchased it before 1985 (in the case of investments).

Council rates are assessed on unimproved land value - which usually lags well behind actual land market value, and far below actual house & land value. Most people pay more for electricity than they do for council rates.

I live near several old-lady-millionaires who moved into coastal properties on retirement - husbands have passed away and they are still in the homes 30+ years later. But they have no intention of moving and cashing in, and despite presumably modest incomes, have no problems paying the rates, which add up to about $40-50 per week. I also suspect their children aren't keen on them selling up.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by daemin on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @07:38PM (#7781374)
Yes, no tax for the primary residence, somehow I forgot that.

But as far as council rates forcing people out, it does do that in some areas, especially when land value goes from something like 100,000 to over 1,500,000 in 30 years.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by dwd on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @02:05AM (#7776911)
Sunshine Coast resident here, Demographia's most unaffordable in 2009. The Buderim market was insane during that time. Sold out in 2008 and sat it out until last year.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by mbillie1 on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:33PM (#7775838)
> It's the people that need to be there for one reason or another and can't afford a living wage with the incredibly inflated prices and taxes associated with living in SF and California in general.

This is more along the lines of what I meant, although I'd wager plenty of people grew up renting and have been slowly pushed out of what feels like their home by skyrocketing housing prices as well.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by yzzxy on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:47PM (#7776109)
But if you still live in said house, you're actually LOSING money because of the increased property taxes.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by ben1040 on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:58PM (#7776153)
California law has put caps on the increase of assessed values, and a full re-assessment only happens when the property changes hands.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_13_(1978...

So if you've owned a property since the 70s you're most likely paying less in taxes than someone who'd buy it from you today.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by rdrdss23 on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:34PM (#7776066)
I grew up in the area, and I no longer want to go back; and neither do most of the friends I grew up with. It has not only gotten more expensive, but the culture has changed significantly.

The intransigent "family farm" that is ingrained in the American psyche is being eroded by a practical reality - and on some level everyone feels it. The newer generations are increasingly less attached to their place of birth. The Bay Area is rapidly changing, and I'm happy for all the people that now live there and call it their home.

It's no longer my cup of tea, but I'll find my place somewhere else. Please don't feel sorry for me =)

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by Balgair on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:16PM (#7775992)
Well, that's my family. Grew up in the East Bay and my family has been there for 4 generations. My dad bought the house in '81 for ~60 and now the house next door is in negotiations for about 600. That's a 1000% increase. Compare this to wages, and it's still bad. These are 1 bath, 3 bedroom single story 1.5 acre plots. Basically, Levittown houses. Granted, the elementary is 3 blocks away.

But still, it's insane in the Bay property market again. Anyone from the Bay knows a bubble when we see one by now. When all the hipsters and their credit-cards run out, the market will crash and the locals MIGHT be able to buy something again. There is also the elephant in the room called Prop 13 that is not mentioned here. That, among all other bubble ingredients is the main reason why property in the Bay is the way it is.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by dwd on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @02:21AM (#7776941)
Don't count on it bursting.

It's just as likely to go sideways for a decade or two with devaluation only due to inflation. Japan is the best example but Australia never had a major crash and seems to have rebounded again.

Maybe if there was another DotCom crash it might take the real estate market down with it.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by Balgair on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @02:42AM (#7776976)
Again, prop 13 distorts things a lot here. Mobility is very restricted for people, as the taxes go sky high for older owners when they sell.

Still, until you can reasonably pay a mortgage on 2 incomes, pay for kids, medical, and insurances, then these bubbles will continue. Rent? Sure, but rent also has to make sense. You can float on credit for a long time, but eventually people have to have a future for your market to exist. Otherwise, they'll just move to Tuscon or Denver. Similar people and climate (not lots of snow for months on end).

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by dwd on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @06:12PM (#7781072)
The Australian bubble has been largely blamed on two things:

- Restrictive policies on land release for development which is the simple classic supply/demand explanation

- Low credit costs and negative gearing tax concessions which encourage speculation fueled by debt (Keen, Minsky, et al)

The First Home Owners Grant and other schemes also stimulated demand but any value was quickly absorbed by the rising prices. On top of this spruikers pushing get rich quick on property also inflated the market.

Now, everyone's stuck where they are.

A true correction here will require either a normalisation of interest rates or repeal of negative gearing provisions. Neither of which the current Government are likely to allow.

Most likely it will be a long slide and a lost generation who's best bet will be waiting for an inheritance. That is if their baby boomer parents don't reverse mortgage the house to fund their retirement.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by Balgair on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @06:26PM (#7781121)
Hmph. Well, I see now that my decision to move out of California has precedence. Thank you.

-Supply/demand problem-Check

-Low credit costs & speculation (though in a bubbly way)-Check

-Unlikely repeal of Prop13-Check

-Likelyness of parents selling house & moving to Arizona-Check

Yep, getting out sounds better and better

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by dwd on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @09:04PM (#7781606)
In a bubbly, Ponzi scheme way. Last one in is left holding the empty can.

I used to read this blog back when I was watching for the crash that never was. (Doesn't appear to have happened in Canada either) He had an interesting tax story from a few days ago too about inheriting property.

http://www.greaterfool.ca/2014/05/19/gross-me-up/

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by htormey on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @09:03PM (#7776173)
"But still, it's insane in the Bay property market again. Anyone from the Bay knows a bubble when we see one by now. When all the hipsters and their credit-cards run out, the market will crash and the locals MIGHT be able to buy something again"

Just curious, but what happened to property prices in Oakland/SF during the last crash (2008)?

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by krakensden on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @09:28PM (#7776261)
Not much. Actually, in Oakland prices started to take off in like late 2009 as professional investors moved in, betting on the rental market
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by Balgair on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @02:36AM (#7776969)
The East Bay cratered, out in Pinole and Bay Point was way worse. The house we used to live in lost about 2/3 of value in 6 months.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by nextstep on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @09:32PM (#7776271)
60 to 600 is a 900% increase.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by Balgair on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @02:34AM (#7776961)
True, thanks
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by jlmorton on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:09PM (#7775966)
The pay differential for software engineers in the SF Bay Area is much more than 15%. The average adjustment for all jobs in San Francisco is about 40% higher than the national average.

Looking at BLS data, jobs for Software Developers in San Jose-Santa Clara are actually about 15% higher than the next highest municipal area in the US (Seattle-Bellevue). The average Software Developer job in San Jose-Santa Clara makes $28,000 more than the same job in the New York Metropolitan Area.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by yourapostasy on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @09:01PM (#7776168)
If we go by the parent comment's "4x+" metric, and if we keep with the traditional personal finance advice of 33% maximum budget allocation to shelter with no other debt and that 33% covers PITI+M, that 33% expands to 1.32x of the budget. In other words, for compensating just shelter costs alone, you need a salary bump of 132%.

This doesn't account for the increased cost of living that should be compensated for, as well as any risk premium for moving in the first place. I don't see how people pencil out the numbers to convince themselves to move into either Silicon Valley or the Bay Area, and I'd honestly like to see how the numbers shake out if someone has made it work. Unless one is Fabrice Bellard-level quality, I don't anticipate most average arrivals to SV or BA ever getting a 200-250% salary increase to just stay in a Red Queen's Race personal-finance-wise.

The landowners of Bay Area are the new store owners of this new gold rush, profiting with much lower risk premiums from the majority of "prospectors"/programmers flocking to the new gold fields while the stories of "hits" keep luring in fresh meat each year.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by JOnAgain on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:39PM (#7776081)
>> for perhaps a 15% increase in pay

Where are you working? Total comp in the bay is often much higher than other areas (data-points from Seattle, LA, and New York)