News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by free2rhyme214 on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @06:53PM (#7775694)
Why buy in SF when you can rent? I don't see the point and honestly it depends on the size of the property.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by yid on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @06:57PM (#7775710)
Renting in SF comes with its own set of strings and scams/opportunism, for example a lot of condos set out an attractive initial rent, but then either (a) tack on ridiculous extras like paying for water, and/or (b) raise your rent by a ridiculous amount after your first year.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by eshvk on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:23PM (#7775798)
> (a) tack on ridiculous extras like paying for water

Umm..If your lease says you don't pay for water, you don't. We had a lease that said we didn't pay for it.

> b) raise your rent by a ridiculous amount after your first year.

An overwhelming majority of the apartments in San Francisco have stringent rules on how high the rent can go up every year for a tenant who is renewing their lease. Mine was 4% or so IIRC.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by pdx6 on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:25PM (#7775809)
Renting in SF is a strong value if you plan to live here for a while, but the property needs to be protected by rent control, otherwise you'll get wiped out during the booms and busts this city has.

Owning is also a strong value over the long term, but it is more complicated between taxes, mortgages, and city ordinances; it also comes with a lot more risk and way more upfront costs.

For people just moving to the city and haven't established any roots, don't rent or own: be a roommate. It is the best deal possible and you'll be own your way to making this place your home, if you want it to be.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by htormey on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:04PM (#7775947)
"For people just moving to the city and haven't established any roots, don't rent or own: be a roommate. It is the best deal possible and you'll be own your way to making this place your home, if you want it to be."

Solid advise. I have been living in SF for the past six years and this is what I did initially. I now live in a rent controlled aparment and I have no intention of moving.

If you are going to be working in SF another viable option to consider is getting a place near a BART station in Oakland/Berkeley. Both are much cheaper places to live in than SF or the South Bay.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by mikeryan on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @06:59PM (#7775717)
Why rent if you can buy?

Buying in SF is currently cheaper then Renting[1] not to mention its one of the best investments out there (better then apple stock over the past 2 years) [2]

[1] http://www.trulia.com/trends/category/rent-vs-buy-index/ [2] http://www.businessinsider.com/apple-stock-gold-or-bay-area-...

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by r00fus on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:03PM (#7775727)
> better then apple stock over the past 2 years)

That's extrapolating based on current conditions. It's a bet that a) nothing meaningful is done about housing supply, b) the overall market doesn't turn south and c) the US cheap-dollar policy of low prime rates doesn't change.

I'd be suspicious about 2&3, though I'd probably agree about (1) - never underestimate municipal incompetence when that incompetence means tax coffers fill faster.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by the_watcher on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:23PM (#7775800)
Coming from Austin (high property tax, no state income tax), a decent number of very successful people I spoke to there told me they planned on possibly moving to CA to retire simply because of the flipped property/income tax ratio (and them wanting CA weather over the other low property tax states).
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by bicknergseng on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @06:59PM (#7775716)
I don't really think throwing away $3k+/month for a small 1 bedroom is a better option. At least have that money go towards a mortgage and get the tax deductions on interest...
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by winterchil on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:24PM (#7775802)
If you're buying something comparable it's not $3k/month, it's $5k/month + $900/month in property taxes + all maintenance and expenses + the lost opportunity cost of investing all that money in diversified assets.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by mikeryan on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @12:23AM (#7776691)
I have to call bullshit on that. You're not renting in SF what's equivalent to a $1.5M home (which is roughly what 6k a month in mortgage + taxes + etc will get you) for 3k a month.

This excess for investing doesn't exist. Its in fact cheaper to buy in SF every month then it is to rent.

Trulia has a really cool tool where you can mess with the numbers yourself

http://www.trulia.com/rent_vs_buy/

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by winterchil on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @02:32PM (#7779912)
You're welcome to call bullshit but it's not and here's why.

First $6k/month will not get you a $1.5MM home unless you had a down payment of $500k and even then it would not cover your taxes and other expenses. A general rule of thumb for someone with good credit is a monthly payment of $3k will let you borrow $500k on a 30-year fixed mortgage. You can check this yourself here: http://www.mortgagecalculator.org/ (or use Trulia's).

The problem with Trulia's "really cool tool" is unless you use the advanced version all the inputs are wrong. For example, its tax assumptions are less than half of real cost for SF. A more sophisticated tool is available from the NY Times (http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/business/buy-rent-calcula...).

Of course getting an apples to apples comparison is pretty hard unless you're talking about buying a condo vs. renting a condo in the same building. Yes, it would be cheaper to buy a 1 bedroom in Bayview then rent a 3 bedroom in Pacific Heights. If you're looking at starter homes in a decent area, say, Noe Valley and compare those costs to renting something similar in the same area renting is generally cheaper.

The "excess for investing" DOES exist, at a minimum in the form of the down payment you did not spend. The good news for home buyers is that you get leverage on that return if the market keeps going up. The bad news is that it's illiquid and we don't know whether that's a better investment than the stock market or one of the companies we see on the front page everyday. In short, if you're never moving again buying is likely cheaper. Otherwise, it's complicated.

TLDR: It's complicated, and most calculations downplay other buyer costs and ignore other renter opportunities.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by malyk on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @03:29PM (#7780226)
Rent for my loft at 11th and Folsom was raised in 2012 to $2650. My wife and I moved across the bay to Oakland and now pay $2725 a month all for a house. The loft was then rented for $3300 after we moved out.

1000 sqft loft: $3300 1150 sqft house w/ 40x50 yard and 1 car garage: $2725

But, that isn't in san francisco, but it is within a similar commute distance.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by winterchil on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @04:17PM (#7780527)
This totally explains why everyone is moving to Oakland but, as you say, not a fair comparison.

Out of curiosity, how much would you estimate it costs to buy the house? Some quick math will let us figure out the rent vs. buy for your neighborhood.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by malyk on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @05:38PM (#7780923)
Yeah, that's the kicker for buying. You have to have something for a down payment.

My place was $470k and we paid about $72k in closing costs. Our loan is 3.625% for $417k.

You can still find nice places at that price point, but rates have gone up. So that's another reason why it isn't a fair comparison. But it's an option, and it isn't far away like other east bay places. And like I said, commute times are similar (35 minutes for me).

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by winterchil on Thursday May 22, 2014 @12:51PM (#7784785)
Sounds like you got in at just the right time, congratulations!
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by ohsnapman on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:25PM (#7775810)
Questionable - remember that interest over the life of a 30 year loan often dwarfs the principal itself. Depending on how long you live at a place, whether the price goes up or not if you sell and various sales costs, your tax "savings" from deducting mortgage interest might only be a small discount on getting screwed in general.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by jonnathanson on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @11:54PM (#7776618)
Correct.

I'll happily take out a mortgage on an income-generating property, deduct interest from my taxes, and essentially lease-to-own a building on leverage while generating some modest cash flow as part of the deal. That's when a large mortgage makes sense.

On the other hand, taking out an expensive mortgage to buy a residence I couldn't otherwise afford? Much more dicey, even after accounting for the tax deduction, appreciation, etc.

Call me old fashioned, but I only like debt when it works for me, not when I work for it.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by mrb on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:01PM (#7775940)
The problem of buying in SF is that it is a high-risk earthquake area. If a big earthquake occur, not only you may lose your house, but you STILL have to continue to pay the mortgage... on a house that does not exist anymore.

Even if you have earthquake insurance, insurers typically go out of their way to avoid/reduce claims they have to pay (this is exactly what happened to numerous Hurricane Katrina victims: http://rt.com/usa/katrina-state-farm-insurance-fraud-596/ )

On the other hand, if you are renting and your house gets destroyed, you move to a new house and you don't have the financial liabilities a homeowner would have.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by aetherson on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:12PM (#7775980)
That is not "the problem with buying in SF." Earthquakes big enough to damage houses are very rare, and much of the value of the property is in the land, not the structure.
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by mrb on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @10:33PM (#7776423)
Earthquakes in SF are definitely not rare:

"There is a 63% probability of at least one magnitude 6.7 or greater quake, capable of causing widespread damage, striking somewhere in the San Francisco Bay region in the next 30 years." Source: http://www.earthquakesafety.com/earthquake-faults.html

And I would say it is not true that most of the value is in the land. Even if it is 50/50 between land/house, losing 50% of your investment when the house is destroyed is still a terrible prospect...

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by ceejayoz on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:56PM (#7776144)
> Earthquakes big enough to damage houses are very rare

The 20th Century was "abnormally stable" in SF, and they've got a long history of fairly regular ones. http://www.mercurynews.com/science/ci_25793975/quake-cluster...

> and much of the value of the property is in the land, not the structure

In a normal "selling my house" situation, sure. In a "good portion of the city got leveled" situation, not necessarily.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by aaronblohowiak on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @06:59PM (#7775714)
Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by fallinghawks on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @08:29PM (#7776044)
When renting is about the same as mortgage payments, why rent?

The question to me is why anyone feels they have to live in SF.

Re:To Get a Home in San Francisco, First Get a $200,000-a-Ye... by justizin on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @07:08PM (#7775745)
what depends on the size of the property? right now rent in SF averages about $2k per bedroom for units available on the market.