News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by rayiner on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @05:19PM (#7775269)
> The government effectively killed his business the second they first coerced him into undermining his clients.

The problem is, in the U.S. and I'd imagine most other countries, your business cannot be built on refusing to follow court orders to protect your clients. Specifically, refusing to furnish relevant information despite being able to do so without excessive burden.

We're not talking about some new erosion of civil rights. The power of courts to compel witnesses to provide relevant evidence and testimony dates back to the origins of jury trials in the middle ages: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subpoena_ad_testificandum.

Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by SilasX on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @09:24PM (#7776247)
>The problem is, in the U.S. and I'd imagine most other countries, your business cannot be built on refusing to follow court orders to protect your clients.

What about churches offering confessional services? I know, that's a case where the law specifically protects the (priest/penitent) relationship. (Nor are they "businesses" in the conventional sense of the term.) Nevertheless, they are open about how they're willing to violate a court order asking them to (in their judgment) break the confessional seal.

Third caveat: if all you meant was that the "confession protector" can still expect to go to jail for this, that's still not a counterexample to what you said. But the point is that, unlike with Lavabit, the court would not shut down the entire church when priests violate such court orders, no matter how systematically they do it.

Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by rayiner on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @09:08AM (#7777973)
A church isn't a business, nor is it built on refusing to follow court orders. A clergyman doesn't have to violate a court order to protect someone's confidences: he can invoke a legal privilege that's creates an exception to the general subpoena power. The same is true of a lawyer or a spouse. They don't have to violate the court order--they are protected by special exceptions to the rule. They simply need to invoke the exception in a motion to quash.

In general, however, a business will not be protected by any evidentiary privilege. In order to avoid complying with a court order, they will have to violate it.

Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by SilasX on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @11:13AM (#7778644)
Did you see the "in their judgment" bit? (Or the "not technically a business" bit, for that matter?) A court can still order testimony if the judge feels it doesn't qualify for the immunity, even as the priest feels that his duty is to protect it.

You can't dismiss the scenario by acting like a priest will never protect a confessional in violation of a court order.

Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by danielweber on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @10:56PM (#7776477)
There are a number of explicitly allowed privileges, like with lawyers. Society sees value in letting people be able to discuss very personal matters with people, and the conversations would not be happening without the explicitly granted privilege. Can't be compelled to testify against your spouse, for that matter (that's by Constitution, not by statute).

(Even then, priests and lawyers have rules about when to break confidentiality. If someone said they committed a murder, nope. If someone said they are going to commit a murder tonight, then yes.)

If you want a new kind of privilege, you should lobby your legislators, not try to start a for-profit business.

Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by SilasX on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @12:18AM (#7776677)
I was showing how rayiner's claim about "promise to break the law" businesses was wrong, not claiming a particular defense for Lavabit.
Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by danielweber on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @08:38AM (#7777866)
The fundamental rule is that the government is entitled to evidence.

If a church, for some insane reason, kept written records about what was said in the confessional, and a court order was somehow granted to order the church to turn over their records (ignoring privilege), they would need to turn those over.

If someone destroyed them, the DOJ would not need to shut down the church. They would charge the person who destroyed them with the appropriate crime, and then everyone would move on.

If they refused to turn them over, but the DOJ believed they were still on premises, eventually the DOJ would get the local sheriff to physically enter the building and take the records. There would be no need to shut down the church.

In that situation, ideally the records are all in individual files, and the constable only needs to take one. If the head priest said "nyah nyah, we mixed them all up, ha ha!", then all would be seized, and someone would need to go through and find the relevant information.

By keeping all the secrets of their "clients" written down, the church has put them all at risk. If one priest knew the secret only in his head, the government could compel him to testify, and that still wouldn't require shutting down the church.

The nature of computers is that they are simultaneously typewriter, gold bars, and file cabinet -- they are needed for work, they are valuable, they contain lots of information. When the government needs to seize evidence, they cannot slice out the "file cabinet" component from the other components. The fundamental rule is that the government is entitled to evidence.

EDIT, and maybe this is what I should have said instead of all the stuff above: Lavabit's only defense against seizure of its keys if a court order demanded them was to refuse to provide them. I.e., break the law. I don't know how else that can be read except as a promise to break the law on behalf of their clients.

Second edit: And fundamentally an unkeepable promise. I could, in theory, promise to not repeat the secret you told me and that I hold only in my brain, no matter how long I sit in jail. I cannot promise that the DOJ cannot seize my written record of that conversation, because they can bust down the door to get it.

Re:Why I was forced to shut down Lavabit by SilasX on Wednesday May 21, 2014 @11:14AM (#7778654)
Those are great points, but I don't see how they're applicable as a reply to anything I said.