DoD approved for more than a year:
http://www.ocio.usda.gov/products-services/end-user-services...
In the case of the IRS, they are _still_ using windows XP, and they are paying Microsoft for support!
http://www.engadget.com/2014/04/13/irs-pays-microsoft-for-wi...
I'm quite certain most people would agree with that statement.
If MS provided a group policy toggle to essentially say 'force Windows Classic mode', enterprises would have a lot less reluctance (beyond the normal reluctance that IT has to anything new, which is to get the enterprise's infrastructure into a state of balance and then not touch it for ten years).
It doesn't matter how awesome the changes under the hood are if it's painful to use. And I'd argue that the unwarranted attempt to shoehorn a (mediocre by itself) touch UI into a desktop, poorly, ranks as "painful", never mind the knock-on effects with certain configurations (laptop touchpads interpreting normal mouse movement as swipe gestures for example).
I think a majority of the complaints come from "this is different!" not "this is worse!".
Interestingly i have a touchscreen laptop but on my main OS (Linux) i went the complete opposite direction lately, with a much more keyboard-driven setup, no fancy animations. Basically a distraction-free work machine, and not the colorful, animation-loaded distraction "beast" Windows has become.
And Ubuntu has similarly turned into an example of what not to do. This fad of cramming a touch UI down the throat of mouse users and acting like it's all perfectly natural is obscene.
Ubuntu's UI has its own issues, but that's not the point.
Microsoft is living a lot of money on the table.
It's not really relevant to a "force windows classic" mode because the listed bugs are mostly interactions with new features.
The claim that they would have had to sacrifice significant other features is a strawman.
And they're doing the work anyway for the next service pack, apparently...
There were a lot of reasons the old start menu was removed. I listed some technical reasons why "just leave it in as an option" isn't as easy as it sounds.
It is not a straw man to say that investing in one area means you have to sacrifice in others. This is what we call software development.
Features are not added in service packs, and I don't even think service packs exist anymore (service packs are just collections of security and reliability updates, created and packaged together by a special "sustained engineering" team, not the product team).
The product team is building a new start menu option for a future version of Windows. It's a significant undertaking, not something they're throwing together willy nilly. They don't have a time machine, so they can't go back to 2012 and ship it then.
Security Center
Popup Blocking in IE
Image Blocking in OE
DEP
Some others I can't remember
IIRC those were features introduced with Service Pack 2 of Windows XP.
1) It's likely that the ban on Windows 8 has nothing to do with "power-saving". To me power-saving is just a buzzword in the title of the notice.
2) This notice is concerned with a specific round of bid. So it's not an administrative order, but rather a requirement list for the bidders. If I understand correctly this only applies to computers to be purchased during the bid. I'm not sure about how large the scale of the bid is, though; it may affect 1% of the government computer installations, or 99%. Either is possible without further information.
3) This notice doesn't say anything about Windows 7. What this means that bidders are allowed to provide computers pre-installed with Windows 7 and IMO this is pretty likely. Yes there are conspiracy advocates who would rather stick with Windows XP (I have never been able to understand their reasoning...), but I believe the computer vendors are more sensible. After all it's they who have to provide customer service.
4) This notice is also only concerned with the pre-installed OS. It's totally possible that the government officials may replace the OS with anything they like (which are, unfortunately, most likely pirate copies). I don't know about the central government, but it's common practice in local governments. The central government has very weak executive power when it comes to such detailed things. (Why bother enforcing such regulations after all?)