News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by cortesoft on Friday May 16, 2014 @05:55PM (#7758160)
Your arguments make sense in many ways, but I do think ensuring that everyone has access to broadband internet is something that is worth worrying about. If we just allow market forces to determine who gets access to the new broadband, a lot of (poorer) people will not get access. I think just saying "well it sucks to be them" is not a satisfactory answer.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by criley2 on Friday May 16, 2014 @06:04PM (#7758200)
Now I agree that everyone should have access to broadband but this raises many questions for me.

Why can't the rich get access to gigabit while the poor has access to a few megabit?

Just like ten years ago, when the rich had access to megabit and the poor used kilobit access.

Or ten years before that, when the richest could pay for high kilobit access while the poor were stuck to dialup low kilobit access.

I don't understand what's wrong with a long term rollout plan that finances the future scale with large costs to those willing to pay them.

Is it wrong because it's a utility? Why aren't we up in arms about the non-megabit (or barely megabit) non-low-latency access that so much of rural america is already stuck with?

I just don't get this. Fiber will get cheaper, but only if we train tens thousands about it in smaller rollouts while building up the supply side with increasingly larger rollouts.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by wmf on Friday May 16, 2014 @06:30PM (#7758298)
Why can't the rich get access to gigabit while the poor has access to a few megabit?

We may want to avoid a scenario where fiber is unregulated, then incumbent ISPs also get deregulated out of fairness (Austin is currently at this step), then incumbent ISPs stop maintaining/installing service in poor areas, so rich people get gigabit and poor people get no bits at all.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by bdisraeli on Friday May 16, 2014 @06:31PM (#7758300)
Why can't the rich have express-ways and make the poor drive dirt roads?
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by bennyg on Friday May 16, 2014 @06:37PM (#7758319)
It's already like this. The rich fly in private jets that take a fraction of the time that driving does.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by jamesbritt on Friday May 16, 2014 @07:13PM (#7758446)
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by smsm42 on Saturday May 17, 2014 @04:24PM (#7760945)
Very small number of people are rich enough to build their own roads (with all rights of way issues, etc.). And each road would only connect very small number of points. Helicopter probably would be way, way cheaper at this point.

Paid roads with less traffic, etc. or paid lanes are a commonplace, OTOH, but one doesn't have to be exactly rich to use them.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by MBlume on Friday May 16, 2014 @06:39PM (#7758326)
Is this supposed to be a reductio?
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by sliverstorm on Friday May 16, 2014 @06:04PM (#7758201)
It's important everyone has access, but just about every technology in the history of technology has gone through a cycle of early adopter => general use => commodity. If wealthy neighborhoods are never allowed to adopt fiber, fiber will never be cheap enough to deploy in Nowhere, USA.

There's always a fixed labor cost for laying the pipes, but the endpoint hardware for fiber is currently pretty pricey. Compare to cable, whose modems used to be hundreds of dollars, and can now be had for $30.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by rayiner on Friday May 16, 2014 @06:06PM (#7758209)
The question isn't whether you subsidize access for the poor, it's how. Build-out requirements and forcing ISP's to discount services for the poor is an attempt to shift the burden from taxpayers to ISP's, and has the unintended consequence of making it so that only the de-facto monopolies find it worthwhile to build in most cities.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by naturalethic on Friday May 16, 2014 @06:08PM (#7758212)
They should all get free Netflix accounts too.