News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by zdw on Friday May 16, 2014 @05:13PM (#7757945)
The fundamental problem here is that in most places we've arbitrarily decided that certain things like:

    - Roads
    - Water/Trash/Sewer
    - Police/Fire service
Are a part of municipal government, whereas:

    - Electrical
    - Telephone
    - Cable TV
Are frequently not, but are regulated. Frequently, one of these last 3 will own the poles (usually the Electrical company, but sometimes the municipality) and the Phone/Cable companies lease the poles to put up their lines.

So, what do you do? Make the Electric company put up New Companies A-Z's lines for free? That doesn't work and would quickly lead to companies covering the lucrative part of town (read: "rich") and widening the digital divide.

It comes back to the bad decision that didn't force Cable to be a common carrier. Had that happened, we'd end up with a situation like DSL where there are multiple vendors, except the lines would have the same speed capabilities as Cable.

So, in short, it comes back to a bad FCC decision. Requiring a bunch of new physical infrastructure isn't needed when the existing could just be broken up and leased out as dumb pipes.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by nostromo on Friday May 16, 2014 @05:42PM (#7758093)
The problem is that eliminates the incentive for companies to build faster, better internet. We'd be stuck with what we have now for a very long time.

I do think it's fair to blame municipalities. Look at something that is much easier to build out: wireless networks. Cell coverage has dramatically improved over the past 10 years. In part, that's because multiple carriers are competing for customers and municipalities have largely stayed out of their way.

One could even argue that we're reliant on cable providers because there were no incentives for the highly regulated phone line providers to improve their networks.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by bduerst on Friday May 16, 2014 @07:16PM (#7758458)
Nope.

Regional competition for services which require expensive infrastructure is non-existent once the first player has entered the market.

Any competitor trying to enter would need to build out the expensive infrastructure, only to be undercut in the following price war and lose because of recent costs. It's textbook game theory.

This lack of competition leads to a deterioration of quality of the service as the sole market holder doesn't need to continue to invest in infrastructure. Instead they can invest in lobbying which helps further cement their hold on their market, or invest in advertising to take customers away from shittier service alternatives, like DSL.

Quality is the exact reason why something like transportation is handled by local governments, as opposed to letting private toll roads dominate the market, which have no incentive to patch pot holes when it's the only option available.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by pdonis on Friday May 16, 2014 @09:33PM (#7758912)
> Regional competition for services which require expensive infrastructure is non-existent once the first player has entered the market.

This is just as true when the first player is a local (or State) government as when it's a private company.

> Quality is the exact reason why something like transportation is handled by local governments, as opposed to letting private toll roads dominate the market, which have no incentive to patch pot holes when it's the only option available.

Local governments often don't do a good job of patching potholes either. (Nor do State governments, which often own major highways.)

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by bduerst on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @10:59AM (#7772864)
Not so. Public sector monopolies are not aligned with profit-hungry shareholders, board of investors, executives looking for bonuses, etc. Instead public sector monopolies are aligned with quality, and making enough revenue to break even.

And don't cherry pick some individual poorer counties for road performance, even though on a whole they are better. I could cherry pick Somalia as an example of privately maintained transportation monopolies.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by nostromo on Friday May 16, 2014 @07:53PM (#7758615)
That's a great argument for a monopoly on roads but a poor argument for a monopoly on communications infrastructure.

You only have a single road leading to your house. But you already have at least two communications lines, perhaps more.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by bduerst on Tuesday May 20, 2014 @10:56AM (#7772841)
I don't, and many people in the U.S. don't either.

DSL is an inferior good, not the same service, for what can be considered high speed internet. It's not a duopoly when you need high speed internet.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by kumbasha on Friday May 16, 2014 @06:15PM (#7758241)
How can you eliminate competition that does not exist? By definition, what the cable companies are doing now is eliminating competition, because there is none. Any change is an improvement.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by bluthru on Friday May 16, 2014 @08:15PM (#7758705)
>We'd be stuck with what we have now for a very long time.

Being stuck at the speed of light sounds ok to me.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by crazy1van on Saturday May 17, 2014 @01:42AM (#7759316)
Someone probably said the same thing about our power grid fifty years ago. And here we are...basically the exact same dumb power grid decades later.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by saraid216 on Friday May 16, 2014 @05:48PM (#7758126)
I honestly don't understand why we don't just consider them utilities and incorporate them into the municipal government. Including internet.

These are essentially utilities (excepting Cable TV, but I'm pretty sure there's not a meaningful infrastructure difference there).

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by epistasis on Friday May 16, 2014 @05:27PM (#7758016)
I believe that to be an eminently reasonable interpretation of the history and current situation.

What was the history that led to a the non-common carrier ruling? Was it thought that cable companies would upgrade infrastructure more quickly if they didn't have to sell access to their lines?

Here's what the NCTA has to say about it now: https://www.ncta.com/platform/public-policy/why-its-a-good-t... Given the success of broadband in areas where the lines are sold like they would be in a common carrier situation, it's hard to believe anything they say.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by tbrownaw on Saturday May 17, 2014 @12:33AM (#7759233)
The version I learned is that it's a historical artifact from dial-up Internet.

You had the phone lines from the phone company (natural monopoly, common carrier), and completely separately you had an ISP with a modem bank hooked up to an Internet uplink (competitive, information service).

Then you had the Telecommunications Act of 1996 (I turned twelve that year!), where the phone company had to allow the ISPs to use the phone lines at wholesale rates. So you get ISDN and later DSL with that same split between who controls the wires and who controls the Internet uplink.

Then you get cable Internet. Which does not use common-carrier wires (I assume this is related to not-so-modern TV being entirely one-way). And which end up classified the same way as potentially-unbundled Internet that runs over the phone company's wires, despite being controlled by the same people as the wires it runs on.

Then for whatever reason all the independent DSL providers disappeared (or at least shrunk to where they can't afford noticeable advertising campaigns). I don't know if the phone companies found a way around having to share their lines, or put less effort into maintaining lines used by independent ISPs to discourage people using them (I know I heard this suggested back when it was new, no idea if it was reasonable or just a conspiracy theory), or just out-competed them based on there being a single bill and a single point-of-contact (and no finger-pointing) for problems. I guess it can't be the first option, since I've heard that a few parts of the country actually have more than 2 choices (cable company & phone company) for Internet service.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by dnautics on Friday May 16, 2014 @05:56PM (#7758165)
Would shifting these responsibilities to the government necessarily solve the problem? After all, the police (and the fire department, in SoCal, anyways) don't do a job of equitably serving the poor relative to the rich, either.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by rayiner on Friday May 16, 2014 @05:39PM (#7758077)
> Had that happened, we'd end up with a situation like DSL

A situation where nobody wants to invest in DSL and everyone is looking to get out of the wireline telephone business?

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by chc on Friday May 16, 2014 @05:44PM (#7758111)
Isn't that because of dwindling demand rather than companies finding DSL onerous?
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by rayiner on Friday May 16, 2014 @05:53PM (#7758149)
Dwindling demand for what? Broadband? There was a natural upgrade path for DSL: push the fiber network closer and closer to the premises, eventually building FTTN with VDSL2 to the premises. That'd support 100 megabit service. Nobody did it, because who wants to spend billions building infrastructure for your competitors?
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by vertex-four on Friday May 16, 2014 @07:17PM (#7758463)
Of course, here in the UK, in a lot of places, we have just that - FTTC with VDSL to the home, which a number of companies share. Less common in rural places, of course, but in cities and even a number of towns it can be hard to find places that don't have it now.

We have a single company (BT Openreach) that's highly regulated by Ofcom which lays said cables and owns the relevant last mile infrastructure. This company then sells access to said infrastructure to retail ISPs.

Ofcom has enough teeth to force this company to perform upgrades, through both Government-based power, and the fact that because if the company didn't, the retail ISPs could reasonably band together and lay their own cables (at significant cost and likely regulatory nightmares, but they could certainly tear into Openreach's margins). There's a couple of companies which already do that on their own; Virgin is one, I believe, and it's trying to follow the US "media company" model.

So basically: we have a model in which we've managed to allow for a single company to exist without competition because that's the most efficient way to manage national physical infrastructure, but there's enough regulations and threats floating about that it more-or-less does what its customers (the retail ISPs) want, which in turn more-or-less do what their customers (Internet users) want due to competition. That is, we've built a system in which there's enough money floating around to potentially replace Openreach if we really, really had to.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by rayiner on Friday May 16, 2014 @07:23PM (#7758484)
The difference is that BT was a government owned corporation, and when it was privatized, the government: 1) gave notice to Investors who bought the stock; 2) created a cost recovery and profit scheme for the company; 3) wrote that scheme into the prospectus for the share sales.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by arethuza on Saturday May 17, 2014 @05:13AM (#7759665)
A slight nitpick: BT was privatised in 1984 - what they did get was a strong regulator in the form of Oftel (now Ofcom) - it was Oftel who made BT offer Local Loop Unbundling (in general policy in 1999 and specifically as part of BT's license in 2000):

http://www.ofcom.org.uk/static/archive/oftel/publications/br...

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by nullsmack on Friday May 16, 2014 @07:24PM (#7758485)
Which is precisely why we need infrastructure companies and service provider companies and never the twain shall they meet. Frankly local governments should contract out to a company to lay fiber all over the place to each house and then provide a local hosting center where service companies can put their equipment and connect to the fiber. Comcast wants to connect to x number of people? Fine. Verizon wants to connect to xx number of people? Okay. Mom and Pop Internet Co. has a couple dozen customers? Open Access! Fiber's tiny, you could lay enough strands to each house that each provider could connect to one. Infrastructure company not living up to their end of the bargain? Not being responsive to outages and such? Kick them out on their asses and get a new one. Other than setting up the relationships and policing for abuse the local government can just stay out of it.

We had a time when a company spent billions of dollars building infrastructure for their competitors. We've never had as good competition since that time, the dial-up days.

Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by harryh on Friday May 16, 2014 @08:12PM (#7758693)
If you want to go that route then you're going to have to find billions of dollars in cash to pay the contractors laying the fiber. Good luck with that.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by jsz0 on Saturday May 17, 2014 @12:27AM (#7759226)
Voters love tax increases and municipal debt so raising the money should be easy compared to finding enough qualified contractors for a large scale project like this.
Re:Don’t Blame Big Cable. It’s Local Governments That Choke ... by nullsmack on Saturday May 17, 2014 @11:40PM (#7762076)
That's ridiculous. Who's going to do the work? Not government workers. Who's going to provide the services? Not the government. The funds would be raised the same way as any other corporate project. The only difference is separation of the infrastructure providers from the service providers. Service providers will pay the infrastructure providers for access to the connections to their customers. That's how it will be paid for. Startup fees could be in the form of bonds that could be paid back over time. Hell, some companies would probably buy in just for an equal chance to compete with Comcast or Verizon in a given area.

Look, we own the roads. Not Ford, not Chevrolet, not Toyota. In some places the roads are not in great shape because the money isn't being spent where it should to keep it up. That is a government problem but it's mostly a lazy voter problem. There are people that argue less government is the solution to our problems when they're too lazy to hold the government accountable for misappropriating money and giving kickbacks to their corporate friends and future employers. Despite the problems, it's still better than having all of the roads owned by Ford and then anyone who wants to drive a Toyota on those roads has to pay a huge "wrong car" tax.. I mean fee.. or drive at half the speed or something else ridiculous. (you could call it road neutrality) I'm not even suggesting we should own the network. I'm not even saying we should "own" the dark fiber to each house. I'm suggesting we should make it so competition can flourish instead of being choked off.

You're not going to have it by making companies build out brand new infrastructure for every company. Completely eliminate all other barriers other than buying the lines and putting them up. That's still tons of money, even for a small area. In the old days a mom & pop ISP could start up by ordering a T1 and a few phone lines from the phone company. The phone company was the infrastructure. If there are 30 companies that want to offer service to a city do you propose all 30 build out some sort of cabling all over town? Don't be ridiculous. Can you imagine? Then most of them go out of business because there's not enough of a market to sustain that and billions of dollars sit rotting on the poles instead of being used for a good purpose.

I'm telling you. Fiber to the home with a colocation facility or facilities that they all run to. Put several strands so if someone wants to buy Fiber TV from Comcast, Fiber phone from Verizon and Fiber Internet from whoever else each company can have their own lines. Or hell, if they want all 3 from Comcast then they can just use 1 fiber line. If you get Internet from Mom & pop co and they go out of business then you can switch providers by subscribing to a new one and they will do what they need to in the colocation to move your fiber over to their system.

The only role in the government is, as the representative of the customers who are requesting the service, to set up relationships and take action when there's abuse such as price fixing or if the infrastructure company turns out to be a bunch of deadbeats.

Nobody is going to voluntarily build an infrastructure only company. It's a chicken and egg scenario, what use is it if no one is offering a service over it? What use is a service without the infrastructure to support it?

As an aside, If your only concern as a voter is how low your taxes are then you're part of the problem, not the solution. You should be concerned about what value your taxes are bringing you. You could be paying less taxes but much much more in other areas as a result. You'll never be able to pay as low taxes as the guy who can afford to make sure he's paying the lowest taxes.