News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by duckingtest on Thursday May 15, 2014 @04:15PM (#7751952)
I'm not sure about all cats. My cat ignores mirrors - even previously unseen ones - altogether, at the same time he reacts to youtube videos with cats. However, when he has seen himself in the mirror for the first time in his life he behaved like it was another cat, for two minutes or so.

Divide an almost identical uniform background with a piece of glass, block smell and sound if possible. Put two cats on the opposite sides of the glass and observe their reactions. Put mirror in the place of glass and observe reactions. I can bet the reactions would be drastically different, and not just for cats.

Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by ecdavis on Thursday May 15, 2014 @05:53PM (#7752474)
My cat ignores mirrors. He also ignores screens and isn't bothered by audio of dogs or cats. At the same time, he's very alert and will generally spring to attention if he hears a dog or cat outside. A few years ago he was introduced to another cat, separated by glass, and his reaction was completely different compared to looking at a mirror. I don't remember the first time he saw a mirror.

I think that cats have a pretty decent idea of what is and isn't real. While a reflection may be interesting in that it looks like another cat, it lacks the accompanying sound and smell of an intruder and is therefore safe to ignore.

On a related note, many years ago my family lived in a house with a lot of bird life in the back yard. There was a family of magpies, a number of chickens and a solitary male guineafowl. While moving in we leaned an old mirror against a fence in the yard and it ended up staying there for years.

Initially, the magpies attempted to fight their reflections but they quickly learned that there was no point. After that they ignored the mirror. The chickens never seemed to notice it in the first place. The guineafowl, though, was most interesting. This is a species that forms flocks in the wild. This particular guineafowl, though, had been separated from its flock for years and was completely alone. To begin with it had the same reaction as the magpies and attempted to fight itself in the mirror. Over time, however, this behavior stopped. Instead of fighting, it would simply stand in front of the mirror for hours on end.

Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by aetherson on Thursday May 15, 2014 @06:03PM (#7752524)
My cat also totally ignores mirrors, screens, etc. And she completely flips out when she sees another cat through the window, fifty feet away.

I'm pretty confused by this. I don't think that her sense of smell or hearing is so acute that she can smell or hear the other cat through glass from so far away. She doesn't have binocular vision at that distance, I would assume. Parallax? How does she determine that that's a real cat while cats in mirrors and screens aren't?

Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by mblakele on Thursday May 15, 2014 @06:22PM (#7752611)
Cats have much better long-range vision than short-range. Long range they are probably better than you think. Short of about a foot they don't really focus at all, and rely on their whiskers. Like most predators they key in on movement. Taken together I think these features explain the behavior you've seen.
Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by ecdavis on Thursday May 15, 2014 @06:47PM (#7752706)
Again, I can only offer anecdotes.

My cat will react to unusual movement outside a nearby window even when he's curled up with his eyes closed. I remember one instance in particular where I was playing music fairly loudly. He had his eyes closed and was lying down facing away from the window when a dog walked past. His ears perked up and he immediately got up and looked around. I can only assume it was the sound that tipped him off.

It's not necessarily that their hearing/smell/vision is so much better than ours, but rather that it's more specifically evolved for their role as predators (as another poster pointed out).

Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by sliverstorm on Thursday May 15, 2014 @06:05PM (#7752532)
- it would simply stand in front of the mirror for hours on end -

"I'm so alone..."

Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by gwern on Thursday May 15, 2014 @09:46PM (#7753322)
_Ringworld_, anyone?
Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by georgemcbay on Thursday May 15, 2014 @07:03PM (#7752790)
I'm fairly certain my cat recognizes me through mirrors as I have a large 3-pane sliding closet-covering mirror in one room and when she sees me "in" it and I do the slow-blink, she responds just like she does sans mirror (she slow-blinks in return).

I never saw her first experience with a mirror though and have no specific indication that she recognizes herself but she is very skittish around other cats and has no negative reaction when around said large mirror, so if she notices the image of herself at all in the mirror she must associate it in a very different way than she does other cats.

Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by bobbles on Friday May 16, 2014 @12:09AM (#7753681)
My cat does the same, if I am laying on the bed and she walks through the room, the mirror allows her to see me.

When she sees me in the mirror she jumps up onto the bed for pats

Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by User9821 on Thursday May 15, 2014 @07:06PM (#7752806)
My dog never saw a mirror in his life, he lived outdoors, and aside from a puddle, he would never have an opportunity to see his own reflection. One day I had a fullsize mirror outside. I walked my dog infront of it, pointed to it, tried to hold his head to look into the mirror, and there was absolutely no reaction. It's like my dog was looking into an empty wall. It wouldn't make eye contact with the reflection, it was simply like it didn't exist.

So, what's going on here? My dog would go crazy if another dog was anywhere within view, but nothing happened. Did my dog just understand without doubt that's a reflection, that dog is me, that human is you, there's no point in even looking at it for a second? Or did my dog just recognize it as a 2D surface, and think anything in the mirror doesn't exist, it's just a bunch of shapes moving around. Kind of like holding out a printed photo of a dog, where it would just see a blob of color on the paper, recognize there's no dog here, nothing physically present, no depth, no smell, no noise, etc.

Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by TwoBit on Thursday May 15, 2014 @09:01PM (#7753208)
I have this theory that some animals (e.g. cats and dogs) do in fact recognize that mirrors are reflections, but they just don't care about what's in the reflection. We are fascinated by the idea that we are watching ourselves, but that's a somewhat meta concept and animals just don't care. Just because an animal doesn't care about reflections doesn't mean it necessarily feels like it needs to rub red paint off its reflected self or even really make that connection.
Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by simonster on Thursday May 15, 2014 @11:48PM (#7753636)
This seems right. I work with monkeys, and some of our monkeys have mirrors attached to their cages. They don't use the mirrors to inspect themselves, but they do seem to use the mirrors to surreptitiously spy on other monkeys. It's likely that a monkey can quickly figure out that the thing in the mirror isn't another animal and when they move, the thing in the mirror moves, but drawing the connection that they are the thing in the mirror seems quite a bit harder.
Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by ripter on Thursday May 15, 2014 @05:31PM (#7752375)
If you never saw your reflection before, then suddenly someone places a mirror in front of you. It would probably take a few minutes for you to realize that it's you in the mirror and not another human.
Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by TwoBit on Thursday May 15, 2014 @08:57PM (#7753198)
One of my cats clearly recognizes me in the mirror and understands that the mirror is a reflection of me. I've done tests where I put the cat in front of the mirror and I stand behind the cat. The cat looks at me in the mirror. I pull out a treat and the cat turns around to get it from me.

My other cat clear recognizes itself in the mirror because whenever I force it to look at itself in the mirror, it strains to look away from its disgusting recognition that it is a cat and not a human. I'm serious about how it reacts, though it's only my interpretation as to why it acts that way.

Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by ThrustVectoring on Friday May 16, 2014 @07:34PM (#7758520)
>I've done tests where I put the cat in front of the mirror and I stand behind the cat. The cat looks at me in the mirror. I pull out a treat and the cat turns around to get it from me.

Have you done the same thing with a piece of cardboard instead of a mirror? Your cat may be hearing you pull out the treat.

Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by zoba on Thursday May 15, 2014 @05:09PM (#7752264)
I always wondered what screens look like to animals. Whats to say the screen's refresh rate makes sense to some animal's eyes?
Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by georgemcbay on Thursday May 15, 2014 @05:25PM (#7752346)
Anecdotally, I know that some cats will follow a mouse pointer on the screen and can determine both its movement and location (since some of them will directly attack it if you move it around, particularly if you try to mimic the rough movement behavior of bugs, which is what I assume they think they are attacking).

And FWIW, I've observed this behavior on old 30hz CRTs as well as modern 240hz LCDs and various things in between.

Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by jpindar on Saturday May 17, 2014 @07:33AM (#7759869)
There are computer games made for cats, and of course many videos of them playing them.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mxW_qPU4KVQ

This one is interesting because the cat tries to reach underneath the tablet to get the mouse, which to me implies that it perceives it as an object rather than just showing a "swat at any movement" reflex.

Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by User9821 on Thursday May 15, 2014 @07:27PM (#7752904)
Apparently you can trick an octopus if you use high definition video, so the display is obviously visible to them.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zmzfxFF5vDI

Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by spingsprong on Friday May 16, 2014 @02:57AM (#7754104)
I saw a video on television about a decade ago, a fly had landed on a computer monitor, and was following the mouse pointer around the screen.
Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by chc on Thursday May 15, 2014 @06:03PM (#7752522)
I'd bet it probably looks jumpy to a cat, but cats seem to find sudden jumpy movements interesting.
Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by trhway on Thursday May 15, 2014 @05:01PM (#7752215)
the same about my dog - as a puppy he initially reacted to his mirror image like it was another dog there. Since that, passing by the mirror, he sometimes quickly glances into it like humans do. He does usually react to dogs on TV.
Re:What Do Animals See in a Mirror? by hnriot on Friday May 16, 2014 @02:50AM (#7754081)
look what you've started :)

ultimately, every social network (hn included now) devolves to discussing cats. Humans make such good pets.