Re:2+2=What? Parents rail against Common Core math
by DanBC on Thursday May 15, 2014 @09:58AM
(#7749419)
You're kind of missing the point.
Rote memorization of times tables doesn't lead to understanding. So, early in the learning process, you give children techniques that give correct answers, boost confidence and increase understanding of what is actually happening.
Thus when they see 4x = 2y they'll know that 4x means 4 xs and 2y means 2 ys.
Re:2+2=What? Parents rail against Common Core math
by kasey_junk on Thursday May 15, 2014 @09:53AM
(#7749388)
Actually, I think that for most students they hit a wall in Algebra regardless of how they learned basic mathematical operations. This wall has to do with abstraction of principles not with mechanical operation speed.
If what we are trying to teach is this abstraction, then the rote table method is arbitrary* and a time sync. The students will still learn basic sums over time, it just won't be the focus of the practice.
*For instance, my education with the tables went up to 12s. Why in the world did we choose 12? 16 would have certainly helped me out more.
Re:2+2=What? Parents rail against Common Core math
by sitkack on Thursday May 15, 2014 @10:58AM
(#7749785)
I have 0x65 problems and knowing 12*11 from memory doesn't solve any of them.
Re:2+2=What? Parents rail against Common Core math
by sitkack on Thursday May 15, 2014 @10:56AM
(#7749770)
Rote solves everything and nothing. Faster time to correct answer, yet no understanding of solution. I'd rather have people who can reason and fumble through a problem than can rattle off memorized facts.
"Motivation" at a higher sense is something that's sorely lacking in US public school (free government school) math. Especially prior to real algebra, the teachers tend to be generalists who don't know to tell you "you need to learn X so you can learn Y which will allow you to solve problems like Z" and of course get you to understand why Z is neat and important. But that's a different sort of problem that just not making sure all students capable have the foundation they need.