Most consumers and small businesses in the US can buy ISP services only from a duopoly, the cable company or the phone company, who therefore are in a position to dictate terms to customers. In other words, there's no functioning "free market" for consumer and small-business ISP services.
On the other hand, there are many payment processors in the US.[1] Say what you will about their service quality (most suck -- Stripe is an exception), but at least customers have multiple choices. No payment processor is in a position to dictate terms. In other words, there's a functioning market for payment processing services.
--
[1] http://www.quora.com/How-many-payment-card-merchants-are-in-...
Federal "net neutrality" regulations freeze into national law a particular formula for access, based on an idealized model that's never quite existed before. (To the extent the net has often been 'neutral', it's not because the FCC demanded it, but customers and businesses. And the legions of de facto exceptions have been practical, and evolving quickly, not waiting for telecom-lawyer mandarins in DC to design us a better internet.)
Even if new utility-style regulation prevents certain abuses, it equally prevents valuable experiments from incumbents or new entrants. The history of regulated utilities – electric, water, classic phones – is one of stagnation, and plenty of subtle abuses from those incumbents whose margins get effectively written into law.
Without opening up infrastructure to competing ISP services, the current system guarantees there will be no new entrants (and, via mergers, an ever decreasing number of competitors). Infrastructure is a natural monopoly, but the services provided over that infrastructure are not. Locking infrastructure customers to a single ISP is effectively giving the monopolies a gift-wrapped invitation to abuse their market power.
So I'm not sure this is a 'natural monopoly' at all. There's been too little time to observe, and things are still changing fast.
Let abusive incumbents try to collect monopoly rents. That would attract lots of new solutions from very savvy and deep-pocketed challengers, like Google, Apple, and other strategic investors.
To be clear, by 'infrastructure' I mean physical lines going to the premises. There's still hope for wireless, but competition in the physical connection space is effectively dead, and getting deader with every merger.
But also: why are the physical lines a separate market from wireless? They are very, very close substitutes – bits are bits. And advancing tech or clever to-the-curb (but not to-the-premises) buildouts could make wireless broadband fully competitive with the wired networks.
If the wired incumbents get fat and happy on a position of temporary advantage – for example for bulk video delivery – then those potential wireless advances will see more investment.
These are different market. You may think the buck stops somewhere, but after 720p video streaming, you get 1080. Then you get gaming, at sixty FPS, not 30. Then you get VR streaming, up to 10 times the pixel rate, and nearly twice the frame rate to have perfect presence. And never mind the latency requirements. Then you can get more sci-fi, with direct neural interfaces, and, eventually whole brain emulation over the network —though at that point, the economy would have changed so much that the fibre vs wireless debate will be quite moot.
That's effectively what I'm advocating--by removing their monopoly power to be the only ISP available to the customer on the other end of their lines. Breaking them up into regionalized monopolies doesn't give consumers a choice, but opening the lines to competition does.
And if it doesn't? How long do we wait?
For example, what if ISPs roll out traffic-preferences-for-pay... but the base bandwidth available to customers, and sites that don't opt to pay for preference, also keeps improving, on a price/performance basis? Would that still be an emergency requiring novel nationwide regulation?
And wouldn't we learn something if some local markets showed abuse or lagging price/performance, while others thrived? Couldn't we, and especially the lagging jurisdictions, then do the minimal targeted reforms to improve results based on actual history, rather than a theoretical "neutral net" ideal?
Note that unlike the shared broadcast airwaves, the economic case for wires being a 'commons' needing public management is weak. There's already at least 3 sets of wires running to most structures – electricity, phones, and cable – and more could be added if those aren't satisfying the customers. And even electricity – far more foundational than internet – is regulated in a diverse manner locally, not nationally.
Wait and see and let localities and businesses experiment is just fine - it's what got us to this point, after all, and the internet is doing just fine – albeit prone to occasional panic attacks: "Death of the Internet Predicted, Film At 11".
Specific measurable abuses and the court rulings in the specific attempt to deal with them in the Comcast FCC action and subsequent litigation in 2007-2010 was one of the things which spurred the FCC to move network neutrality from a set of generalized objectives that it was seeking to preserve in it its other actions to a specific focus of dedicated, generally-applicable regulation.
So been there, done that.
Er, no it doesn't "freeze" anything. FCC regulations of other regulated industries are very frequently updated. And regulations, while given force of law by the laws authorizing regulation, are not the same as law particularly with regard to being "frozen", as they can be changed by either changing the law on which they are based, or by change through regulatory process. They are, therefore, strictly less "frozen" than law.
In fact, it will make it easier to add similar regulations, as has been shown throughout the history of our country's particular style of governance.
Plus, to be a fair comparison, it would mean regulation so that payment processors couldn't actively make it HARDER for you unless you pay them. Which again, they should be in support of.
It's more like the DMV throwing down nails and tacks in your driveway and telling you that you can have them removed if you pay them more.
While you may be able to obtain DSL service from multiple "providers", they're almost always using the same resources. Kind of in the same way that there are many mobile providers, but they all rely on the major networks.
Companies like Stripe on the other hand, are equivalent to the front end of that system. Nearly anybody can provide the same service that Stripe does. Which makes it a competition to see who can provide the best service vs price (or whatever choices you're basing your decision on).
If you only have access to the internet through your cable lines or phone lines, having the entities that control those finite resources legally able to charge more for different types of content over their lines or content from different locations, etc. is a pretty huge deal.
Even when you use some "local ISP", if the company that controls the end point at which your phone lines are connected to the internet decides to start filtering, rate limiting, etc. the data you're receiving, there's not much you can do about it.
Heck, even wireless internet providers are working with finite resources. You can't just decide one day that you want to start a business doing wireless networking over large distances without getting the FCC involved. It's to the point that you could basically consider wireless networks with enough broadcast strength to cover a city to have virtual hard lines. They essentially own those frequencies, so they may as well be considered the same type of finite resource.
As a broadband customer, I pay for access to "the Internet". Over the last couple of decades, "the Internet" has meant access with something akin to net neutrality in place.
What my ISP wants to sell me is not "the Internet", but something new, which they have yet to define. But from what their lobbyists have put into the FCC proposal, the "Internet" they want to sell me is one where both sender and receiver of data pay them for data. This is not a wholly unreasonable payment model, but it would represent a profound shift in how the Internet is paid for in the U.S.
Further, under their proposal, my speeds to any particular website are dependent on how much I pay and how much the other side pays to my ISP (not theirs). Crucially, half of this is wholly outside my control. Of course, I still pay for the full pipe regardless.
Note that in particular the source server has not been a customer of my ISP, but the FCC thinks they should become a customer of my ISP so that I can have the speeds I have been sold as of today. This is not how the Internet has worked, and is a new service offering being marketed as "the" Internet.
So a better Stripe analogy would be that Stripe offers would be if they 1) first became as big as Chase, Bank of America, Wells Fargo, and American Express combined (that would give them approximately the market heft of the American broadband ISPs); 2) required cardholders to buy a Stripe Consumer subscription before processing their cards for merchants. I'm fairly certain that even our lax banking regulators would have something to say about this.
Just because the internet would work differently it needs to be absolutely abolished? Consider the following:
If the funds ISPs get from service providers begins to completely overshadow the monthly fees from consumers, you may end up with really interesting incentives: namely, it may be in an ISPs best interest to provide as many people with as cheap as internet as possible. Doing so would mean more people using Netflix, which means Netflix paying them more. We could end up in a situation where the services providers do all the paying, and internet becomes free for consumers, since every additional free consumer is cheap for ISPs, and every additional byte delivered by Netflix to the consumer is a huge win for them. I'm not saying this WILL happen, but I think its silly to assume that everything in the world will fall apart with this model, just because its different.
The internet itself was basically built on equality. Look at any of the articles and blog posts being written by the actual internet backbone providers. They've been keeping the equality stable through the years with their peering agreements.
We would basically be giving the rights to providers like Comcast to say "We've decided that Wikipedia should pay extra if they want consumers of their information to continue to receive it in a timely manner." "Oh, we're also starting up a new service called Xfinipedia that provides a similar service, but one where we moderate the content."
Call it paranoid, but this is exactly what they're intending to do with video streaming services. They want to provide on demand video streaming to their online customers, while making it more expensive for competitive services to operate. What prevents them (or other providers) from doing the same with any service?
If you look at the deliberation involved in the rollout of IPv6 and compare to this, which is about as fundamental on the business side, there's no comparison. The FCC is moving in a haphazard fashion without addressing what a fundamental change this is.
It is indeed interesting to wonder how the incentives change if the funds ISPs get from service providers (SPs) overshadow the fees from consumers. In an unregulated market, that would possibly lead ISPs to acquire those SPs (a la Comcast-NBC) and make it harder to access content not owned by the ISP. So we could circle back to an AOL-like environment. The FCC is so far pretending that this is not possible.
Also note that under your scenario it's possible that the Netflix business would not be possible, because the ISPs would make the connection fees high enough to destroy the business model, instead shunting their customers onto their proprietary platforms. In fact, any time an SP becomes popular, it would be shareholder-friendly for the ISP to make a bad clone of that SP and then make connection fees to the original unbearably high. The FCC is again ignoring this likely outcome.
To say nothing of the likelihood that fewer SPs will get started in the first place. Given free reign, why wouldn't large ISPs charge a baseline connection fee for every SP? And why would we expect that fee to accessible to businesses without institutional funding? It would be "commercially reasonable" for e.g. Comcast to charge $10k annually for access to it's tens of millions of subscribers. It would be "commercially reasonable" for AT&T, Verizon, T-Mobile, etc. to do the same. Don't forget that any web operator that wants to be accessible nationally/globally (if other countries follow suit) will need to pay that connection fee many times. The FCC is silent on this issue.
The point is there's a lot here that's not being addressed by the FCC.
Moreover, you're doing nothing to address the lack of competition among ISPs, meaning ISPs have an incentive to raise prices above the market clearing equilibrium in order to extract greater rents.
Tangentially, I don't understand why anyone is talking about fairness here. Corporations don't care about fairness; they care about profit. If corporations were individuals they'd be psychopaths; they are a necessary evil to aid the price mechanism in efficiently allocating resources, nothing more. The goal is to get them to perform this function while minimizing market distortions and rent extraction. If this entails being "unfair" to a corporation, who cares?
I also don't understand the problem in principle with regulation. Of course it can be abused, but so can a complete lack of regulation. The only economists who believe that the solution to all our woes is completely unregulated markets are a few wingnut Austrain economists and people who fundamentally misunderstand the Coase theorem.
How are you not describing exactly the model we 'benefit' from now with cable TV? And in what version of the future does the ISP not choose to continue to charge the customer the same exact way companies do now with cable TV?
I'm just struggling to understand how your version is anything but wishful thinking.
What Stripe does is the same as any other payment gateway. Not only did they fully create their own platform, but there are dozens of competitors with no barrier to entry, and mind you, even if they did have some kind of monopoly to something they themselves built, it still wouldn't fall into the same category as the Internet.
Even suggesting this comparison is to frame the debate in favorable terms for the telecoms, and they definitely don't deserve the support.
"As we’ve written before, we believe in the power of impartial platforms. We’re building a platform ourselves, and we work hard to ensure that Stripe treats businesses of all size neutrally. Mr. Wheeler’s plan would push the internet in the opposite direction. It would give larger players a distinct advantage, hurt new companies, and dampen the rapid innovation that has thus far defined the internet economy."
Unless you believe mentioning themselves and how they stay neutral was one big typo, or some sort of strange and irrelevant digression, it seems pretty clear that they are comparing their neutral intentions with the importance of keeping net neutrality. Their argument basically goes:
1. We believe in impartial platforms as a general tenant.
2. For example, our platform, as a subset of "platforms", should remain neutral which we strive to do.
3. The internet, another platform, should also be neutral, if not these bad things will happen: blah blah blah.
If stripe started to charge two different companies based on which brand of jeans they were selling you had a point but that is not what Stripe do.
They treat everyone the same regardless of what they sell but not how much they pay. Thats the difference.
The problem of network neutrality is much more subtle in that it introduces the idea of censorship with the type of content that is considered acceptable.
If Stripe started asking porn companies to pay more than lets say a church group for the same service you could start to talk about an analogy but thats not the case.
The point to me is that you might treat people differently based on what they pay you, but you don't treat them differently based on what they are selling.
ISPs already do that all the time with in-network CDNs, dedicated ports and the like. And nobody cares because it does not make things worse.
Since they set up the comparison themselves, I wonder if Stripe would be in favor of legislation that forced them to forever treat all their customers neutrally vs. us just trusting them to "work hard to ensure" that end. Perhaps making it illegal to offer sweetheart deals to bigger clients for example? Arguably payments is the next most fundamental piece to a functioning internet after bandwidth, so its not unreasonable to request. If MegaCorp A received much lower rates on credit card processing than little Startup B, how could we have fair competition after all?