All too often devs get blinders on and don't realize that most people don't have their domain knowledge and therefore it's not quite so easy for them to see the forest for the giant stacked trees that are lying across the path.
If you can't avoid that morass, the new version better offer something so compelling you can't possibly skip it.
In my experience it was far more flexible than NIS which was both a good thing and a bad thing. The one big advantage it had for me was its support for SecureRPC. In time it was killed by LDAP.
Too many hours spent troubleshooting automounter / NFS failures through NIS and LDAP.
To say that it surprised Ed would be an understatement, and it set off a series of events that left me feeling pretty unsatisfied. The first thing it did was bring attention to the next version of the ONC product which was going to include NFS V3 and NIS+ and nominally just ship to customers. Except that now NIS+ was "valuable" SunSoft (the sub-company in Sun responsible for Solaris) didn't want to just _give_ it away (original plan) they could charge big bucks for it. So they rechristened it to ONC+ and wrapped some egregious license terms around this "new" product. That lead to a ferocious debate inside of the company, fractured relationships with long term ONC licensees (like SGI and HP), and an edict to not ship it on SunOS 4.1 to "encourage" adoption of Solaris 2.0. I would have left Sun at that point if James Gosling hadn't recruited me to come work on project Green, aka Java.
The evolution of BIND had very similar sorts of challenges it seems. Earlier version worked new version was all different. So different that their customers (the system administrators) seem to have revolted. Ouch.
When you are building a part of the infrastructure that lots of people have to manage to keep the infrastructure running, its a special kind of challenge. Both in deployment, change management, and service evolution. Even after going through the process with NIS+ I'm not sure if I could even chart a path for a replacement BIND.