Zed's very no-nonsense. He's spent a lot of time manufacturing an image of himself. He lets himself get carried away and angry and he's been searching for a community he likes, butting heads all the way.
_why, on the other hand, was truly bizarre. I never got into his blog, for instance, because it seemed frequently nonsensical and more than a little rambling. Despite that (or, more likely, because of it), he seemed almost always happy with whatever it was he did. I only ever really got into TryRuby and his Poignant Guide, but they were the only two guides to programming I've played with. There was a giddiness in his work that I haven't found in other coding. It's comparable to the moods of artists in other fields.
Zed's argument against _why is that what he did was impractical and unproductive. That's what made _why as a persona, though: Zed is a hacker, _why was more of an artist, pretenses and unreliability and all. It's left-brained versus right-brained; it's also why there's a definite rift between the people who like _why and the people who think the guy was raving mad and immature.
Namaste
^ Yes, I know the KKK are not technically Nazis.
Leaving personalities out of it, there is a big qualitative difference between ceasing to share something (in the worst case, undirected passive-aggressive behavior) and actively attacking other people (in the worst case, highly directed active-aggressive behavior).
In any case, with or without the statement involving the KKK, I believe that my final statement in that post stands.
It's like if I was mad for some reason (eg my zero karma above) and responded by flaming you vs. simply not answering.
Freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom to abuse and offend.
I'll leave you with this little nugget though. Freedom of speech isn't really true freedom of speech if what you really mean is 'freedom to say only the things that I want to hear.'
I'm all for documenting and educating, not for outlawing stupidity, no matter how long your toes.
I think I'd rather have USA style free speech laws than the make-believe ones that we have here. You can keep the guns though.
?? living in the UK I have yet ot be lynched for calling the royal family pompous.. well.. ;)
Also I think there is some confusion here on the difference between the statments:
"It is my belief that...." and "It is a fact that...."
One is covered in free speech, one is (rightly) restricted by all sorts of law (for example defamation when applicable to statements about people). Think about it - if we had the inherent right to tell people our ideas were fact when this is not established
Your free to think what you want, and tell people that's what you think. But presenting beliefs as fact is a big no no. Right? :)
(holocaust denial being illegal is, I agree, somewhat of an extreme case and I dont agree with it so much)
http://www.trouw.nl/krantenarchief/2007/07/31/2306950/Boete_...
international situation:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L%C3%A8se_majest%C3%A9
In the UK such laws are also still in the books.
Anyway comparing _why's actions to hate speech is just ridiculous.
I find this view of yours very offensive. Shut up.
haha. which one are you talking about?
Why are we programmers, as a group, so negative? When Ernest Lawrence was going on-and-on about the Cyclotron, other physicists got tired of him, but they told him to get off his ass and build it, not that he was an ignorant git and it wouldn't work. Why is it that every interesting idea in programming is met by someone saying it wouldn't work with the supporting logic inversely proportional to the nastiness of the tone?
Therefore, to some programmers, if someone else is likely to do something more brilliant than you, it's motivating to stop them. Especially so, since if you are successful in stopping them, your own perceived merit goes up as the smarter dog in the room.
This game is reinforced by the game of karma on many programmer discussion sites. I have to admit, I succomb, as I want my karma to cross 200 so I can downvote. It's a stupid goal, but my ego is prone to it.
P.S. Please note that science is also prone to this behaviour, and programming and science have the same solution to the problem: actually building a verifiable { experiment / correct theorem / more efficient algorithm }.
cf. Science in Action by Bruno Latour (1987), which I tried to summarize on http://www.usemod.com/cgi-bin/mb.pl?SocialConstructionOfScie...
But then, why are the objections so often brain-dead!?
http://twitter.com/zedshaw/status/3414550229
"Actually, I didn't see a lot of sympathy from _why when I was going through similar tough times. In fact, the inverse."
And: http://twitter.com/zedshaw/status/3414567310
"Totally jealous, I wish I could leave the ghetto as completely. :-)"
What comes off as gruffness, I think, overlies a complex substratum of hurt and ambivalence.
Doesn't change the fact that Zed's cursing out _why and acting like a jerk. He's not just being a jerk, but he is being a jerk.
I love how _why considered code art. I loved it when he wrote out his code by hand and animated the background of the text. It made the code seem magical, which it sometimes is.
Which is what Zed is referring to when he says "the second he's outed."
Curiously, an old Wikipedia edit identifies the same place of employment, three years ago: http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Why_the_lucky_stif...
This post and zed shaw's tweets on the same subject are so stark in contrast.I think I finally understand why zed shaw is so unloved by many. It is because of lack of respect for someone else's choices.
Edit: http://twitter.com/zedshaw/status/3412128128
_why preached "peace & love" and "ruby's nice" and then the second he's outed he rips down gear people depend on. He's a dick.
http://zedshaw.com/blog/2009-07-13.html
"I believe that whatever the author wants to do with his or her works is their right. They wrote it, despite everyone telling them it wouldn’t work. They slaved over it rather than going out with friends. They debugged it, and wrote documentation for it so everyone else could use it. They may have even spent a part of their time promoting it and helping people with it. All for free, and for whatever reason they choose."