In my limited experience with kids from elite boarding schools (which tend to draw from already wealthy communities), graduates of these programs seem to tend more towards the culture of the school than that of their hometown. I think this effect would be even more pronounced in your proposed system.
To which the answer is "Of course."
Obviously its not "of course" enough to change policy in this country.
Why are they "actual constraints"?
Are you sure they're "actual constraints", or are they ways of looking at things that need to be updated for progress to happen?
1.) Land costs. If you are building inside a major city land costs are huge, and you need acres of land. Outside of cities can be less expensive, but it's still a steep cost.
2.) Permitting/regulations/etc. I have no idea what it would cost to get the land you just built zoned to allow you to build a school, but I'm sure it isn't cheap or easy.
3.) Infrastructure costs. You have to build each of these new schools. The private boarding school that I went to[1] just built two new dorms after receiving a gift of $10m to house 98 students. They are probably really nice dorms, but it's not cheap to build. And that's just the dorms. You also need an academic center, library, gym, and possibly support buildings (like faculty housing, student centers, etc.). You also need to build roads, sewers, electricity, etc.
4.) You need to find and hire administrators and teachers. If you go with the chicago stats cited above then you'll need to pay each teacher ~$70k. One of the best things about private schools is the high teacher to student ratio. My biggest class was 14 students and most were in the 6-8 range. It's complicated to figure out the exact number of faculty off the top of my head, but you'll need at least 10 teachers. My high school had around 380 students and they have more than 60 faculty. So, for 100ish students you'd need 15ish faculty. That's $1m a year in funding. Chicago spends roughly $12k per student, which would cover faculty costs, but...
5.) You also have to pay administrators, janitors, lawn care, and a ton of other providers for service. Chicago administrators make roughly $120k a year. That difference has to come from somewhere.
6.) Oh, and you have to get accredited somehow so your students would be able to get into college.
There's probably plenty more constraints that we could come up with. But the biggest one is cost. Who is paying for this? A billionaire could do it, for sure. But it doesn't seem like people are upset enough about the current situation to pay more taxes to support the schools we do have. I'm not sure how you could convince people to pay to create a private school from scratch...especially if their kids aren't going to be the ones eligible to go.
[1] Westminster School, Simsbury Connecticut - Amazing experience! [2] http://chicagoist.com/2013/06/19/crains_chicago_business_and...
Look at your list. Can you think of alternative approaches that reduce or eliminate each item on the list?
You won't have created any kind of scalable / repeatable model that would work at the regional or national level; nobody is going to raise taxes enough to fund that and most people aren't going to sign up to send their kids off to boarding school for K-12.
If we spend that money on institutions that actually WORK, we could do a lot. If we need to build those institutions outside the city, to get them away from the clutches of the political machines in those cities ... then we do THAT.
Do you see how people cling to those fucking administrative jobs, while screwing over kids, like those jobs are the last life preserver on a sinking ship.
Every school district has teacher's unions that are a pain in the ass ... but only in Newark do you see an utterly corrupt organization defended tooth and nail by entire neighborhoods, without regard for how the children are effected.
Its ridiculous. People treat the firing of clerks like its a genocide of a colonized people.
My kids' time in a public school without these unions have had mixed results. The teachers seem good, but the administration seems utterly incompetent. Which is kind of the failure mode I would expect. Bad teachers cannot continue to hide, but what can I do about an administration that takes 3 years to conduct an IEP?
(The answer to that last question is one of "fight to fix the system" or "use legal recourse." Option 1 is incredibly irrational: these insiders know the game better than me and have a lot more invested in it than me. Option 2 is what my spouse and I are doing now, but it doesn't feel at all like it's improving the situation for anyone but our immediate child for the immediate time frame.)
I have to admit I am channeling some childhood angst about a different school system altogether ... not Newark.
http://nusd.ca.schoolloop.com/file/1229222807370/12292234020...
Newark, CA --> Newark Unified School District
Newark, NJ --> Newark Public Schools
It depends on what that teacher's other opportunities were.
Based on how some of these teachers taught school some twenty years ago, when I was a student, I'm willing to bet some of them would never be employed in any other career, if they were to lose their jobs.
Teaching is a tough job, but if you see how teaching is done, you can see its not actually being done in the "difficult" way. People are just warming their seat cushions.
Don't muddy the waters with your romantic notions of some hard working hero toiling against the system.
I'm happy to pay more taxes to give new teachers $100,000 a year in pay ... but not these low-quality morons that they stuffed in my school when I was growing up. And certainly not for these armies of unnecessary administrative drones.
Tenure is a stupid f'in concept. I'm not guarded for life in my job. I don't see why a teacher should be.
I'm willing to bet that your job isn't at the mercy and whim of whatever political viewpoint is in vogue at the moment, overly vocal minority groups (meaning small in size, not minority in the ethnicity sense), or just random pissed off parents with access to the school board. Some amount of protection is necessary when one loud person can ruin your career.
Remember that people get very, very irrational when it comes to their children.
Administrators still want good people even if there isn't a union backing them.
Public sector unions have no constraints against them until system collapse. At least private sector unions have some constraints in the sense that their place of work will go out of business if they are completely ridiculous. Public sector unions do whatever they want till the taxpayer base literally flees to another place.
http://www.glassdoor.com/Salary/National-Education-Associati...
And no, it's not an orphanage. These kids are a burden for their poor parents who try to provide for them, and fail, and have their heart torn apart failing that. And the kids see their parents' misery, and have their heart torn apart, too.
It's a convolution of sadness with itself.
I had this exact same plan, starting at the youngest possible age, so they grow with you. The school teaches them everything, so they become normal human beings and not ghetto people. I don't think there's a single parent who'd like his child to grow up in misery, and if there's a way to shield that child from this shit-hole, I think any parent would be willing to do almost anything.
Who decides what 'normal' is? What makes your upbringing better than 'ghetto people'? You're walking a very, very fine line between what is best for children, and what is just cultural indoctrination. Do you see how easy it is to slip between the two?
What you're operating under is called cultural relativism. Melville Herskovits said it best, "Judgements are based on experience, and experience is interpreted by each individual in terms of his own enculturation." In other words, while you may believe that a 'ghetto' upbringing is worse than what you had, you came to that conclusion under a biased observation. Yes, there is a higher crime rate in 'ghetto' areas, but that has less to do with culture, and more to do with opportunity. When you have 0 opportunity, you tend to become hopeless. So, we'll educate the kids, make sure they conform to our standards, then release them back into hopeless areas. What outcome is that looking for?
And yes, there are parents who would prefer that their children not simply be 'white washed' into cultural conformity based on someone else's standards.
>Who decides what 'normal' is?
Common sense. Saying "I don't know nobody" isn't normal. Imagine you lived in a ghetto with your kid, and there's a billionaire who proposes to offer him a good education, wouldn't you want your kid to get out of that place ASAP.
The most probable outcome for a child who grew up in a ghetto isn't that bright, and refusing to acknowledge the benefit of the above plans just for the sake of political correctness and free choice isn't
>What makes your upbringing better than 'ghetto people'?
Everything. Growing up in a ghetto, you start in life with a handicap:
- They are stereotyped (for good reasons, because they probably fit that stereotype). - They have to deal with things children don't have to deal with. - They are, most probably, less educated than children who grew up in normal neighborhoods. Again, let's leave political correctness aside for a minute, this is a fact.
{ You're walking a very, very fine line between what is best for children, and what is just cultural indoctrination. Do you see how easy it is to slip between the two? }
The line is so thick, it's not even funny. It's not cultural indoctrination, these are facts. There's a reason why ghettos suck, and why no one in his right mind would make a conscious choice of living there. Let alone with a kid.
{ What you're operating under is called cultural relativism. Melville Herskovits said it best, "Judgements are based on experience, and experience is interpreted by each individual in terms of his own enculturation." }
Oh really, where did he live? And where did his children grow up and study? I bet he didn't send them to a slum just to be philosophical.
Try telling this to people living in those places. Anyone who says he lives there and is "proud" is full of shit. The minute they make it, they get out there. Only mobsters choose to keep living there because they'd be a nobody if they ever left.
Ghettos suck. This sentence would get an "Amen" from China to South Africa, and it doesn't even need to be translated.
>In other words, while you may believe that a 'ghetto' upbringing is worse than what you had, you came to that conclusion under a >biased observation.
Biased by numbers, yes. Criminality, illiteracy rate, rate of single moms, murder, poverty, health. Ghettos suck. If they didn't, we'd have no problems actively making a choice of moving there with our families. But we don't. Nobody who can afford to live elsewhere makes an active decision to live in a ghetto.
>Yes, there is a higher crime rate in 'ghetto' areas, but that has less to do with culture, and more to do with opportunity.
Isn't opportunity closely tied with culture?
How many startups have been started by a guy named Maleeek (with 3 'e' s) who grew up in a ghetto? If not none, then very few. Why? Because they didn't have the opportunity to drop out of MIT, Harvard, or Stanford or to get there in the first place for that matter.
Yeah, there are few people who "hustle". A very few. And these apples don't fall really far from the Hip-Hop tree. There are of course outliers, but they're that: Outliers. We need something consistent. Something we can see on a graph and say "Holy shit, the correlation!".
>And yes, there are parents who would prefer that their children not simply be 'white washed' into cultural conformity based on someone >else's standards.
Maybe. But I also think that most parents would prefer that to the most likely outcome of their kid. Any parent can choose to ignore the realities of the world just to make a point, or make the best out of the situation he's in.
That view was extremely popular in the 40's and 50's, and is also extremely ineffective. It's a true story.
What is effective, instead of indoctrinating 'ghetto people' to your "better" way of life, is providing them with opportunity. Look at areas, schools or neighborhoods than have been effective and successful, regardless of being in a 'ghetto'. There is one common theme; internal hope and prosperity. It doesn't take white culture to fix 'ghetto people'. It takes hope, opportunity, community investment and old fashioned work from those people living there. Without it, all you'll do is drain the youth from these communities, and allow real estate brokers access to swaths of uninhabited city centers.
Your argument is fundamentally wrong, and is incredibly ignorant of education and community development in failing areas. You are arguing that 'those ghetto people' are broken, their culture is broken, and only removing them from their surroundings and supplanting their culture can fix their problems. You're wrong, you're just wrong is all there is to it. That's been proven by history and research - I'm not at home and don't have access to a database, but you're wrong.
I'm not saying that ghettos need to remain for the sake of themselves, that the individuals living there love it, or that the people living in there start even close to the same footing as the rest of the world. I'm saying that the way to fix the issues associated with these areas isn't a white knight swooping in to save the poor colored kids; that.does.not.work. It's for these areas to be empowered through community investment to fix it for themselves.
Do you know the best way to empower a community? Education focused INSIDE of it.
And for Melville: I'm not certain that his upbringing is really all that important. Your argument here is really, really weak (and is an outstanding example of Ad Hominem; what does it matter where he's from?). You're arguing that, unless you are from a ghetto, you're not allowed to have an opinion on them. Where did you grow up?
But look at what you said "It doesn't take white culture to fix 'ghetto people'"..
This means your presupposition is that ghettos are predominantly non white, which means that you subconsciously think white folks don't have that problem, which in turns contradicts what you said about not needing white culture to fix ghetto people.. Which is not what I said.
It says a lot: If you can do feature exctraction on a social problem that easily, it means something is really screwd.
I also think there's an impedance mismatch here between what you say and what I understand, and vice versa. I agree on the fact that people living in ghettos must be empowered, and a way to do that in my mind was to get their children a better education, easing the financial burden on the parents, and shielding the children from their toxic environment.
If I went overboard, it's because it's too important to let ourselves dwell on rhetorics. My reasoning was: We may not be able to help the parents (they had their lives), but the children still have a chance. The parents played their turn, now it's the children's turn at life.
But I agree on your point about draining the youth from these communities. I haven't seen it that way.
{ I'm saying that the way to fix the issues associated with these areas isn't a white knight swooping in to save the poor colored kids; that.does.not.work. It's for these areas to be empowered through community investment to fix it for themselves. }
Which would be easier if they had a better education, education which would be easier to obtain if they didn't have to hustle to eat, or have to choose which child to send to school, or chose if the child is going to eat or get an education.
>Do you know the best way to empower a community? Education >focused INSIDE of it.
I'd say education no matter where. As I said, my rationale is that children are too precious to waste on a social experiment of community stuff. They need education and be able to be children. { And for Melville: I'm not certain that his upbringing is really all that important. Your argument here is really, really weak (and is an outstanding example of Ad Hominem; what does it matter where he's from?). You're arguing that, unless you are from a ghetto, you're not allowed to have an opinion on them. Where did you grow up? }
I didn't attack him, Loughla. I even agree with him. And I didn't even say you're not allowed to have an opinion unless you live there (I didn't say that). But the issue at hand has nothing to do with opinion. Living in a ghetto just sucks and nobody needs research or a PhD to know that. It's just reality, man. Not "perception" and not "endoctrination".
It's a toxic environment that would influence the most immune systems. And I didn't say it needs a "white knight", I didn't even mention a white dude saving the day (you did). You assumed that when I said "billionaire", the guy would be white.. Which again, says a frigging lot about the reality you are trying to polish. In other words: you are contradicting yourself because, deep down, in your guts, you don't feel that way about the issue.
Mentalist out (I'm not half as good looking as he is. Oh, well..).
If you're idea is done in the context of replacing foster homes for kids who are removed from their parents by social services, I suppose it can work.
There are many successful societies where boarding schools are the norm for the most wealthy and successful people. I don't just mean China and India, where it is extremely common. I mean also England, where it had been more common, and has now become less common; Wealthy WASPS in the North East of America have a few institutions where they send their kids; there is at least one public boarding magnate school that is highly regarded in the American South ... I don't remember its name, but a quick Google will provide I'm sure. There are many other examples.
The idea that a child is best served at the bosom of his parents might be right in the best of circumstances. It is certainly NOT right in an American inner city neighborhood.
Now if your goal is to say, I refuse the best solution, because I hold out for the dream of solving all inner city problems at once, and turning these neighborhoods into pleasant neighborhoods ... then I say, cheers.
You are precisely the reason why we need a billionaire for this venture ... public money will never come to support something so radically different.
Give admission based on a lottery ... not on the basis
of an examination ... so no one can accuse you of taking
only the best kids.
It's better than that: if you admit based on lottery you're providing the randomization for a randomized controlled trial. Either you or someone else can measure the difference later in life between applicants that are and aren't admitted.It's not, but you can randomly choose an equally-sized comparison group from the population who apply and are not selected.
> And also charter schools are notorious for rejecting students for various reasons that public schools are not allowed to use, including rejecting special ed students, all in the name of making their test scores look better: http://nepc.colorado.edu/newsletter/2013/05/tcr-dirty-dozen
Now you are changing the stated starting conditions. The plan is based on admission by lottery. Period. What other, selective private and charter schools do in admissions is irrelevant.
For example: Summit Public Schools in California, FirstLine Schools in New Orleans, Excel Academy in Boston - just to name a few I've seen first hand.
Given that there is evidence of very successful schools run by governments outside the USA (Finland is often used as an example, but it is certainly not alone), despite the fact that they have bureaucracy and unions, why do you believe this?
Let anyone run them.
A billionaire is necessary only because the current political system brooks no competition. The teachers will not allow it. Their cushy incompetence would be put in sharp relief if something like this were to succeed.
Kids would be sent home for holidays, and weekends even (if the parents want to pick them up).
I think some parents would leap at the chance to have the week free, so they can work. Childcare is a big problem in the inner city.
People I know would be taken care of by grandparents, old neighbors, trusted older kids, etc., while their mothers would work (in the case when father was absent).
Might as well trust an institution.
That doesn't fully counter the "creaming effect" argument unless you assume the applicant pool is a representative sample of the population.
That's why reforming a school is a shit show. Its the place where everyone is feeding at the teat.
Here is one possible solution for a billionaire to try. It won't work for anything but a tiny minority of students at the moment, but it will shine a light on how our education problems are a problem of the education bureaucracy, and not of the students.
Set up a magnate boarding school, outside of the city (perhaps even outside the state). Run it EXACTLY the way you want to run it. Let anyone apply. Give admission based on a lottery ... not on the basis of an examination ... so no one can accuse you of taking only the best kids.
Offer free room/board/education.
Start only with first graders. Then add a grade, every year, as your first class ages. In 12 years you will graduate your first class of students.
Hire the best teachers. Spend a lot on infrastructure. Teach programming/science/technology. Make partnerships with the best universities. Get internships for your students in start ups and companies, using your connections. Maybe your own company can hire some of them.
Show the world what kids from an inner city failed neighborhood can do, without the interference of these teachers and their unions.
When your kids succeed, however spectacularly, or modestly, that will be a beacon.
Encourage your graduates to give back to the school. You will still hemorrhage cash every year, it may never be sustainable without your continued involvement ... but it would be the kind of experiment that would leave an impact for decades ... and if you succeeded in making it sustainable, maybe for centuries.