News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by zanny on Saturday May 10, 2014 @06:09PM (#7727000)
How about just not selling your soul to soul sucking distributors like Apple or Valve?

The real question is do you want fame and industry class "success" (ie, your game sells millions) or do you want to be creative. Terrible example, yada yada, but Minecraft is still being sold from the Mojang site where the company (and originally Notch) gets 100% of proceeds.

If you want to see millions of people play your games, with millions of copies sold, with front page storefront ads, then yeah, you sell your soul to the entrenched interests. But you don't have to play their game - you just need:

1. An Audience who likes your content. 2. A way to eat as a result of that content.

Really, the obvious answer is the audience plays patron as the article denoted funder. That, in the long term, is the macroscopic way this is all trending anyway.

And I'm not talking kickstarter style get-a-bunch-of-money-at-once-and-blow-it-all. I mean you have an (open) product, put it out there, advertise it however you want (personally or outsourced) and hope that those that experience it think its worth continued funding.

Also, metaconsoles is kind of a misnomer - you have a platform spectrum, from open accessible platforms to walled gardens with padlocks. On one side, you have the wild west of self-hosted downloads for free platforms like Android (without the play store, think fdroid) or desktop Linux, and you progress from there through Windows, the Play Store, OSX, and finally the iOS / old console locked down ecosystem where you need a developers license, development tools from the source, etc.

Yeah, Steam is barely better than a console - they act as gatekeeper and takes a huge cut - but on the platforms Steam supports, you at least have the option to use other platforms as well, like gog, the humble store, desura, or self hosting. When there is whole stack lock down like on the traditional consoles and iOS, you are literally praying at the alter of the corporate owner that they give you a blessing.

Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by jlees on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:56PM (#7727540)
I mean you have an (open) product, put it out there, advertise it however you want (personally or outsourced) and hope that those that experience it think its worth continued funding.

It sounds so easy in theory, doesn't it?

Getting a game in front of people who enjoy it enough to give you money is hard. Very hard. Raph's ideas from 2006 around direct relationships and celebrity are still very much on target today -- that's how most successful creators seem to manage it, beyond the randomness of viral outbreaks. (I count entering/winning the IGF as a form of celebrity.)

Beyond that, advertising it is a spray-and-pray that will likely suck up more of your money than you'll ever make, and net you a bunch of high-churn players who don't give a toss about what you've created. Not every game has an obvious niche audience to go after, not every creator welcomes or invites celebrity, and sometimes the weirdest, most un-game-like things hit a nerve nobody was expecting.

My mind keeps circling back to the 'people who bought x also liked..' problem, as mentioned by Greg Costikyan [1]. Discovery is broken, and so on, but it's not discovery - as in players actively seeking out games - I open any store on any platform and I'm inundated with choices. It's being discovered that's broken, being discovered by an audience who will truly appreciate what you've created.

The hard part is slicing the gaming landscape, and individuals' different experiences of the same game, to such depth that a Pandora-like algorithm could work effectively -- or relying on independent curation and journalism to step in and highlight the gems among a sea of overwhelming noise.

(If anyone wants to hack on the recommendations side of things, let me know!)

[1] http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/GregCostikyan/20140324/213784...

Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by waterlesscloud on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:18PM (#7727620)
Google Play Store does do "people who bought this also bought...". It's useful to me in discovering things I want.

I'm a little skeptical of that rant you linked. Anyone blaming the audience's "lack of taste" is going to have a hard time of it, in games or music or books or movies or whatever. You just don't get to do that. You have to make things that satisfy you and the audience both. If you don't, that's your failure, not anyone else's.

Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by kevingadd on Sunday May 11, 2014 @05:27AM (#7728233)
It is true that the audience has no taste, though. We haven't made any concerted effort, as an industry, to help them cultivate taste. Games are still too new and too generally mediocre/same-y for the typical player to develop anything resembling taste - they very rarely encounter an example of a game that's truly worthy of respect or enthusiasm.

If the only games you've ever played are shitty clones at the top of the free list on iOS, how would you possibly know enough to spot a high quality game at a glance? It's not a failing of the players, it's a failing of the industry.

Companies operating storefronts have a responsibility to do better, by offering more useful data that's less vulnerable to these issues. For example, instead of basing recommendations on the masses, prioritize recommendations from what your friends play, so that people can benefit from each others' experiences with the few less-popular games they play. Prioritize games with overall low sales that have high average ratings, are played by a large number of your friends, or are in the same genre as many of the games you play. Randomly show them games that don't match in any sense (or only match in one or two categories), and gather that data to identify 'hidden gems' that you can push up the rankings.

These are all random ideas that might help bring low-ranking games up towards the top, increasing variety in the top lists and increasing engagement (not to mention revenue). It's embarassing that all 3 major store operators (Apple, Google, and Valve) have an utterly lazy approach to discovery, where they literally just do a sort based on one or two values and dump a list onto your screen.

Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by TimJRobinson on Sunday May 11, 2014 @07:16AM (#7728398)
Is there any system for discovering games in a specific niche? I agree that a large issue is games are placed in one of 10 - 20 categories and there are no ways to niche down to find types that you'll enjoy.

In say music you can go into say the metal genre and find all kinds of super specific niches like death metal, viking metal, black metal etc each with their own hardcore fan bases who you can appeal to and target on sites specific to them.

Gaming doesn't have the same niching and with the explosion of indie and mobile games it really needs it. I for example love multiplayer sim games (anno series) and multiplayer tower defense games (tower wars, sol survivor) and instantly buy any games in these genres that I hear of (I bought a 4 back of sol survivor and 3 pack of tower wars as soon as I heard of them).

Now that I'm developing my own multiplayer tower defense game (http://www.towerstorm.com) I'd like to reach others like me who enjoy this genre but am finding it very hard to do so. I either have to market it to the masses or reach out to specific people via social media.

Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by RKoster on Saturday May 10, 2014 @07:42PM (#7727198)
Other storefronts... That would be nice if people could make money on those other distribution channels. Unfortunately, they can't, by and large. Most people don't find the effort worth it to even sign up with Amazon, which has a huge addressable market. I have never even seen a sales report with money from fdroid. For devs who are trying to make a living just from games, anything other than Steam, iOS, and for some people, Google Play, is basically irrelevant. Unless you land in a Humble Bundle.

As far as the loyal audience, yes, I agree with you on that, even mentioned it in the article. But that's not a living wage for most, and the latest research says that sort of environment is more susceptible to a hit-driven winner-takes-all market. That leads to an ugly place as regards the income levels for the typical dev.

Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by jib on Sunday May 11, 2014 @09:50AM (#7728703)
Isn't this the same problem that music has though? The vast majority of musicians don't make a huge living from creating their own music. You either do it for the joy of it with the hope of possibly being discovered. Struggling artist etc. With the main difference being that software developers skills are also hugely wanted in other markets, which musician skills normally aren't.

On some level, its a question of how you both eat the cookie and have it, right? What independent game developers want is some guarantee of a base income, but also with the option to cash in big if they do make it big.

Maybe there is an opportunity there - I'm not sure if a credits organisation is what you're looking for. But maybe something like a self-organised fund that will buy stakes in individual projects, where the stakes are paid out more in a salary style?

Semi-organised group of indie-game developers that guarantee a (lowish) living income to all in the group in exchange for a relatively large chunk of any large windfalls to support the future. If games are actually sustainable then something like that feels like it could stand a reasonable chance, right? Assuming you get past a critical size and have some name recognition. Could also move into the same benefit areas that unions do.

Essentially something like your own very light-weight union/co-op.

Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by eloisant on Sunday May 11, 2014 @05:22AM (#7728224)
Considering what Steam or Apple provide, I don't think 30% is a rip-off.

You get hosting for both your page and downloads, update mechanism, statistics, a DRM that users don't hate, payment mechanism that users trust and already have their credit card registered...

All that costs money if you want to do it own your own, and you also get some exposure.

Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by speeder on Saturday May 10, 2014 @09:05PM (#7727348)
"How about just not selling your soul to soul sucking distributors like Apple"

Alright, I have a mobile game company, currently very unprofitable.

Also we have our stuff on iTunes, because that is the only way we know to distribute on iPhone and iPad.

Tell me sir, a way to distribute to our end users easily, and I will PROMPTLY figure how to do it.

(by the way, we are already on Google Play too, and almost any random android store you can think, even ones that net us 1 download per month, even carrier stores at the other side of the planet too).

Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by dmpk2k on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:03PM (#7727419)
Just a few years ago Valve was being lauded for giving developers a viable new channel that took a very small slice of the pie (~30%) compared to what had come before (>90%). Plus the indies that have managed to get on have consistently noted that the before & after revenue is like night and day.

Not soul-sucking. There are other things to complain about Valve, but 30% for their services is not one of them.

Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by kevingadd on Sunday May 11, 2014 @05:30AM (#7728239)
Valve's cut was never smaller compared to competitors. There's a reason why they insisted on all the terms of their deals (and sales numbers) being secret; they are still really brutal about not being able to share contract terms or revenue numbers.

Hell, I shipped a fucking game on Steam and I don't know what the % we gave them was (though I could probably figure it out by doing enough math on the sales numbers...)

One thing I do know (second-hand information, but from an expert) is that they even demand a huge cut from F2P games, despite the fact that F2P games have their own download, patching and payment infrastructure. They literally charge as much as they can possibly get away with, even when they offer near-zero service.

The quality of the services Valve offers for your money is also fairly low. The Steam API breaks constantly (usually because they are haphazard about changes and have near-zero automated or manual testing), is poorly documented, and is infrequently maintained. Valve can and will ship a Steamworks update that breaks a core part of your game, and leave it broken for weeks no matter how often you complain - unless you happen to have the phone number of someone at the company, or send them numerous emails. The APIs that do work are slow and limited. It's better than nothing, certainly, but not so magnificent that it's worth 30%, especially if you compare it with something like GAE or EC2.

Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by dsirijus on Sunday May 11, 2014 @06:13AM (#7728300)
That is fully my perception of it too. I really don't know why Valve is frequently so lauded as game-changer. They're just another store. With particulary shitty terms.

Discovery on Steam is a bit better than on mobile stores, I give them that.

I held greenlighting thing in high regard, but these days a lot of crap gets greenlighted so, meh.

Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by dmpk2k on Monday May 12, 2014 @07:26AM (#7732088)
> Valve's cut was never smaller compared to competitors.

Compared to the traditional brick & mortar channels which came before it? Yes, it sure was!

Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by kevingadd on Monday May 12, 2014 @06:54PM (#7735873)
GameStop is not a competitor to Valve unless you consider 'sells products to customers' a single market. Their competitors are services like Direct2Drive, Impulse, Humble Store, etc.

If someone actually wants to go out and pick up a box, they're not going to do that on Steam.

It's true that digital distribution in general offers lower costs than brick & mortar, but that's not specific to Valve. At most they were leading the charge on digital distribution with Steam, but even when they did that they were still selling copies at retail.

Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by angersock on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:15PM (#7727612)
One hardly pines for the days where you'd cut a gold master and hope (hope!) that you could convince users to patch things if there was a bug or try to figure out with how to get a massive number of physical units shipped.

Steam has provided a tremendously better experience in all aspects to the old methods of selling and maintaining games.

Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by nemothekid on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:41PM (#7727493)
Can you give another example other than Minecraft? Saying Minecraft was successful because it was self-distributed is about as useful as saying Zuckerberg is successful because he dropped out of school.
Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by TillE on Sunday May 11, 2014 @04:19AM (#7728120)
Mount&Blade. Exact same model (reduced price beta, all sales direct), before Minecraft.

As with most types of entrepreneurship, the answer is to look for niches rather than chasing massive pop culture success.

Re:The Financial Future of Game Developers by BystanderX on Sunday May 11, 2014 @07:05PM (#7730398)
It's almost like people here don't actually play anything but AAA games..