News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by ansimionescu on Saturday May 10, 2014 @09:37AM (#7725339)
This kind of public shaming needs to happen more often. Someone should build an anonymous (to avoid lawsuits) public index of assholes like these.
Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by hnnewguy on Saturday May 10, 2014 @09:50AM (#7725376)
>public index of assholes like these.

It's hard for me to upset with these specific individuals, because I don't know their plans or agenda. In reality, if it wasn't them, at this point, it would be someone else at some other point. From that perspective, companies are almost forced to do this to protect themselves. What would happen if they were beat to the patent?

All you can do is hope the the patent holder is the most benign option. The real idiots are the regulators. This system is broken.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by lotsofmangos on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:12AM (#7725456)
What would happen if they were beat to the patent?

In this case there is no "Beat to the patent." to consider. This is basic photography.

Knocking out a background nicely with backlighting and an infinity curve so that the back is brighter than your foreground highlights, so you can then tune the camera to get the back all white and just chop out your subject easily is a technique that predates digital photography.

You may note that the advance they describe is that this technique negates the need for computer processing. There is a very good reason for that, and that is because when this technique was developed, computer processing was done on hand cranked adding machines.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by hnnewguy on Sunday May 11, 2014 @03:59PM (#7729741)
>In this case there is no "Beat to the patent."

The fact that they were issued a patent says otherwise.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by lotsofmangos on Sunday May 11, 2014 @05:56PM (#7730175)
No it doesn't. It just means that money has been spent needlessly on something that should it ever actually end up in court will just be a colossal waste of time and money for everyone concerned. Merely being issued a patent doesn't prove if the patent is worth a damn, there was a patent issued for a method of swinging on a swing http://www.google.co.uk/patents/US6368227
Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by hnnewguy on Tuesday May 13, 2014 @12:26PM (#7738965)
>No it doesn't.

Yes, it does. They got a patent for the process, meaning had they not, someone else might have. Hence them "beating" others to the patent.

I'm not arguing about the validity of the patent, or really, the system in general. I'm saying, it's better to have the patent yourself then be sued by a troll holding a patent for a ridiculous process you're using, resulting in a "colossal waste of time and money for everyone concerned."

Unfortunately, this is the state of the world; some players filing over-arching, stupid patents, others filing defensive patents for leverage and protection. Until they sue someone for this, it's impossible to know the intent. Regardless, it corrupts the system.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by id on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:08AM (#7725437)
This kind of public shaming shouldn't happen at all. Maybe it was only patented to be able to defend against patent trolls.

The patent system is the problem, not the companies using it to their advantage. Because that's what companies in capitalism do, using everything to their advantage.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by bullseye on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:32AM (#7725523)
>> Maybe it was only patented to be able to defend against patent trolls.

It seems like this has been the standard rationale given by companies when they are awarded these kinds of patents. A few years later, we see lawsuits "defending" these ludicrous patents.

The system is certainly broken, but a broken lock does not justify a burglar's actions.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by zo1 on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:50AM (#7725805)
"The system is certainly broken, but a broken lock does not justify a burglar's actions."

Wow, that's such a loaded analogy.

You're basically saying that they must willingly sacrifice themselves on the alter of the competition just because you don't agree that this is how the system is to be used. The system isn't "broken" in the conventional sense that it doesn't do what it was built to do. It's doing it perfectly, it's just that you didn't consider the implications of someone taking your laws and systems to their logical conclusion.

All the "moral" companies that agree with your usage of the patent system have not taken advantage of the patent system. The ones you do see are the ones that don't agree with your usage. And for all we know, the former is struggling because it wasn't using all the potential advantages at its disposal like the "immoral" companies did.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by bullseye on Saturday May 10, 2014 @05:24PM (#7726895)
In the context of the conversation, we've been talking about Amazon. You're right... I don't agree with their usage. This isn't some small little guy bravely trying to fight off the wolves with a few patents they got their hands on. I don't see many examples of them using patent system to do "what it was built to do".

I don't care if you want to call it moral vs. immoral. Software at the high level has become a game of who can get a patent and sue everyone else. I think it sucks, and yes, I think it is broken.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by gillianseed on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:16AM (#7725673)
>The patent system is the problem, not the companies using it to their advantage.

How do you think the patent system ended up granting basically everything in the first place?

Like with practically everything benefiting huge companies in the US, it's the result of intense corporate bri... lobbying.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by zo1 on Saturday May 10, 2014 @11:43AM (#7725785)
"How do you think the patent system ended up granting basically everything in the first place? Like with practically everything benefiting huge companies in the US, it's the result of intense corporate bri... lobbying."

Well, this is the effect of the democracy that you people have created and nurtured over the years. Why do you want to blame the companies that have stepped in to take advantage of the rules you have set forth? And yes, that includes giving them the power to affect the rules.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by gillianseed on Monday May 12, 2014 @10:15AM (#7732773)
>Well, this is the effect of the democracy that you people have created and nurtured over the years. Why do you want to blame the companies that have stepped in to take advantage of the rules you have set forth?

I haven't nurtured this form of democracy at all (lobbying), I'm from Sweden, not the US. Nor do I believe that the actual voters have 'nurtured' this form of paid influence, if it were ever to be subject to a specific vote then I'm certain that the vast majority of american voters would be against this.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by zo1 on Thursday May 15, 2014 @05:57AM (#7748600)
They have nurtured it if they did nothing to stop it. Either way, they set up their form of governance initially and then didn't bother to continuously monitor it and adjust accordingly.

They deserve everything that is happening to them precisely because of their in-action through their crappy voting. It may not be nice, but that's the reality of it. At this stage, only radical things will fix it.

"if it were ever to be subject to a specific vote then I'm certain that the vast majority of american voters would be against this."

Yes, there is the rub. They probably would vote that way, I agree with you. Except they can't. They're divided and powerless to demand any sort of referendum. Heck, one need only look at recent approval polls for congress/president/law to see that the majority are NOT happy. Yet, they plow on and do nothing except whine and vote.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by neom on Saturday May 10, 2014 @09:41AM (#7725351)
It's not supposed to be a shaming, just important to see the people who submitted the patent.

The most troubling thing is that this diagram: http://pdfpiw.uspto.gov/.piw?Docid=08676045&homeurl=http%3A%...

Depicts pretty standard butterfly/paramount lighting (less the lower reflector) that is taught in every college photography program in the world. I also worry that they appear to be photographers outside of their jobs at Amazon, what kind of a competitive advantage is this? I have no clue as I'm not a lawyer.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by cookiecaper on Saturday May 10, 2014 @09:57AM (#7725396)
Ah yes, because nothing's better than a repository of dox for script kiddies to reference on impulse and without a balanced arrangement of facts or even independent confirmation that the listed persons were actually involved. I can't think of a single instance where that's gone horrifically wrong!

We have a concept called "rule of law" to address such grievances. Vigilante "justice" should not be facilitated, especially not against people who got their names slapped on a patent. If the patent is illegitimate, bring suit under all applicable charges, including considerations for the malicious intent you so obviously believe the inventors held.

Let's never build a list like the one you've proposed.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by HarryHirsch on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:38AM (#7725548)
We have a concept called "rule of law" to address such grievances

Unfortunately we don't. There is great asymmetry in favour of the patent holder, a patent is presumed valid until challenged, and that is easily a six-digit sum. Most people and most small companies don't have that kind of money lying around to state their case that Amazon is patenting basic techniques in studio photography.

And there is the problem. This outcome appears unjust because it is. The civilized way of justice through the courts is not available, consequently we are seeing calls for vigilantism. Someone will uphold the law, and if it isn't the Executive and Congress the street will step in to fill the void.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by cookiecaper on Sunday May 11, 2014 @02:41AM (#7727991)
The civilized way is available. If existing patent law makes it prohibitively difficult to remove a bad patent, the civilized solution is to call your local representatives and work with them to author a bill that modifies the system. It is not to release personal information about the people who disagree and say, "Well, the law isn't what we want it to be right now, so we're going to harass, torment, embarrass, and scare you, because you did something legal which I don't think you should've been allowed to do." Again, look up rule of law. If we can't accept that sometimes we have to obey and respect law while simultaneously working to correct it, whether we agree or not, then we have nothing left.
Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by jjoonathan on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:02AM (#7725412)
> We have a concept called "rule of law" to address such grievances.

No it doesn't, and that's the problem. Vigilante justice is a slippery slope and tends to do more harm than good, but let's not pretend the motivation doesn't exist. Because it does. In spades.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by Dylan16807 on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:34AM (#7725530)
The law goes after people that do illegal things.

Public shaming goes after people that do immoral things.

This is not about vigilantism.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by cookiecaper on Sunday May 11, 2014 @02:36AM (#7727978)
There are multiple types of law, but all of it addresses the public's sense of acceptable tolerances of moral behavior. If someone immorally acquired a patent, there are or should be legal functions to provide redress. If the legal structure necessary does not yet exist, that's why you have representatives. Call them.

"Public shaming" is not a good behavior in civilized society. Think about the patent from the perspective of the authors. Consider their motives. It's very unlikely that the motive is "I'm going to sue everyone who takes a picture on a white background." Consider the importance of a defensive patent portfolio and the likelihood that a case that actually did cite this patent would fail. It's entirely plausible that the patent was acquired for purely defensive purposes ("If we don't claim it, a less-good entity will, and they'll use it irresponsibly").

Even after all this, perhaps the authors simply have a different perspective than many on HN. It's not actually objectively evil to have differing or uncommon beliefs on what comprises a valid patent. Does that disagreement really justify the complete obliteration of the person's privacy?

I keep posting about this on HN and people keep ignoring it, but this is just another example of the rapid deterioration of civil society. If people can't even disagree on a matter as blase as intellectual property law without getting doxxed and run out of their homes, we have a very serious problem with major ramifications for the continued existence of free society.

Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by pduszak on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:06AM (#7725425)
Can you be the first asshole on the list? It's not like these people operated without consent of Amazon. If anyone is an asshole here, it's Amazon.
Re:Amazon granted patent for taking photos against a white b... by ronaldx on Saturday May 10, 2014 @10:17AM (#7725468)
Amazon is a company run by people.

People at Amazon are not absolved of making poor ethical decisions, just because they are doing it in the name of a corporation.