To be fair to banks they don't really try to push that vault myth either, but that is the mental model people still use when interacting with banks.
There's no way you can play this game without a large amount of money and a willingness to jump through the government's regulatory hoops.
See Prosper, incidentally, which had lending peers decide which loans got funded and at what rates. If you think BoA was bad at estimating default risk, wait until you see the average Prosper portfolio.
Reminds me of classic SNL skit The Change Bank. "How do we make money? Volume!"
I can't speak from the borrowing side, but the lending side seemed on par with the risk of the market to me. And for what it's worth, my Prosper portfolio did much better than my 401k.
You give your money to Zopa. Zopa divides it up into chunks and combines it with money from other 'lenders' and gives it to borrowers (which it has performed credit checks on). The borrower pays a fee, a part of which is given back to the lender. Also, if someone defaults Zopa goes after them.
How is this not a bank?