Re:What Happens When a Neurosurgeon Removes Your Hippocampus
by Dylan16807 on Friday May 09, 2014 @02:30PM
(#7722525)
> Lots of people would have a problem with that.
Lots of people don't.
If he was the type of person to object to that sort of thing, he would say so. They can do that to my brain, I don't care, I don't need to 'think about it for a while'.
And it's easy to verify if he was tricked. Ask him again later. But someone trusted should have been doing the asking in the first place, making this a non-issue. Not that I agree with your patronizing assertion of how easy it would be.
Re:What Happens When a Neurosurgeon Removes Your Hippocampus
by JoeAltmaier on Friday May 09, 2014 @03:11PM
(#7722749)
You could get me to agree, in a joking situation or a moment of contented fugue. But later I can rethink it, become dissatisfied, plumb my feelings and come up with my true feelings. Not as plausible if I can't remember past 20 seconds.
But what they did was, saw his brain out on TV, then slice it into grotesque slides that they preserved on permanent display. Lots of people would have a problem with that.
Its questionable if he could be considered an adult. Certainly not an adult like you and me. Not able to 'think about it for a while' for instance. Perhaps the only answers he could give were impulsive ones. It would be childs-play to get him into a frame of mind where he was anxious to be agreeable, then pop the question.