Another consequence of the LH2 choice for the Shuttle is that it didn't have enough thrust at sea level to get off the pad, so it needed high-thrust, low-cost boosters as a 0th stage. Solid rockets being the obvious go-to solution, those got used.
In a very real way the choice to use LH2 resulted not just in much of the cost and complexity of the Shuttle system but also the death of 2 crews and the loss of 2 orbiters.
The methane direction SpaceX is taking going forward strikes me as almost a no-brainer. It gives you a higher isp than kerosene, is about as easy to handle as LOX, and is super-abundant and cheap. In addition to being basically 95% of natural gas it can also be made electrochemically/thermochemically from water and CO2 or trivially obtained from biomass digestion. The latter options are all possible on Mars. It's also a renewable fuel if you get it from non-fossil sources on Earth.
The meat of the 'argument' (and really, I don't believe it's an argument) is that the Shuttle Main Engines (the ones mounted on the tail of the Shuttle, the ones that land like a plane) had similar expectations of reusability, and ended up being absolutely terrible at reusablility. That's the point to address, not the throw away line.