Re:NASA, CNES Warn SpaceX of Challenges in Flying Reusable F...
by api on Wednesday May 07, 2014 @03:26PM
(#7712167)
Hydrogen rockets sound like a classic case of narrow over-optimization for one or a few dimensions of performance at the expense of the overall picture.
The methane direction SpaceX is taking going forward strikes me as almost a no-brainer. It gives you a higher isp than kerosene, is about as easy to handle as LOX, and is super-abundant and cheap. In addition to being basically 95% of natural gas it can also be made electrochemically/thermochemically from water and CO2 or trivially obtained from biomass digestion. The latter options are all possible on Mars. It's also a renewable fuel if you get it from non-fossil sources on Earth.
Re:NASA, CNES Warn SpaceX of Challenges in Flying Reusable F...
by Crito on Wednesday May 07, 2014 @05:14PM
(#7712693)
Hydrogen can make sense, but not really as the Shuttle used it. The second and third stages of the Saturn V used hydrogen, which was in part responsible for the much greater mass to TLI than the N-1 would have had (despite having a first stage with more thrust).
Another consequence of the LH2 choice for the Shuttle is that it didn't have enough thrust at sea level to get off the pad, so it needed high-thrust, low-cost boosters as a 0th stage. Solid rockets being the obvious go-to solution, those got used.
In a very real way the choice to use LH2 resulted not just in much of the cost and complexity of the Shuttle system but also the death of 2 crews and the loss of 2 orbiters.