Providing more detailed background and better numbers on phishing sounds like a good idea. However, this is an experiment that is not on track to ship in any version of Chrome, so I wouldn't consider it a gating criteria for continuing to experiment.
> Chrome removed the protocol for no reason and Firefox felt obliged to do the same, and now we're removing the whole url just to help folks who can't be bothered to read it?
The decision to not display the HTTP scheme was not related to security (and it wasn't to my personal liking). However, it was done in such a way that it was effectively security neutral.
> Another comment suggests "source code highlighting" for the url, where the actual domain would be emphasized while still showing the whole url: what are your thoughts on this?
As I commented elsewhere, Chrome has been highlighting the origin since its inception. However, phishing is still a serious problem, so the team that's working on this is investigating clearer indicators like the ones in this experiment.
So, through obscurity you will achieve security.
Edit: or you expect users to notice phishing attempts more clearly by only displaying the domain name?
It's all just GUI change, nothing is really obscured (as in not accessible). It's just more radically highlighted.
The intent isn't to hide the URL from technical people like scammers... Its to hide it from nontechnical people. It's easier to train your grandparents to look at a shortened URL containing just the domain name, and having them verify that is what they expect - as all the distracting bits of the URL are gone...
(Also - "crackers" refers to a very different group of people....)
Dear John Doe,
An automatic payment has been made from your checking account:
04-May-2014 $125.00 to Big Energy Utility Corp
For more details, please log on to your online banking account and click the "Recent Transactions" tab.
There is no need for hyperlinks in any of that.
To verify your email, please login at SiteYouHaveJustRegisteredAt
and enter the following information:
User ID: 1234
Verification code: 12345678This is already the case in Firefox. I don't know how long they've been doing it, but I think it's the perfect compromise.
Is it? What are the numbers?
So many annoying things are done in the name of "security" without much justification (both online and in real life); Chrome removed the protocol for no reason and Firefox felt obliged to do the same, and now we're removing the whole url just to help folks who can't be bothered to read it?
Another comment suggests "source code highlighting" for the url, where the actual domain would be emphasized while still showing the whole url: what are your thoughts on this?
(Disclaimer: I have not tried the Chrome version in question so I very well may not know what I'm complaining about.)