News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Truthcoin: Trustless, Decentralized Bitcoin Prediction Ma... by tg3 on Saturday May 03, 2014 @03:27PM (#7692069)
The same thing that prevents dishonest bitcoin miners from rigging the blockchain to say that coin X went from A->M instead of A->B.

As long as there are more nodes who would not benefit from this particular rigging as there are nodes who would, everyone can act in their own self-interest and the outcome would be correct.

Re:Truthcoin: Trustless, Decentralized Bitcoin Prediction Ma... by maaku on Saturday May 03, 2014 @08:20PM (#7692838)
> The same thing that prevents dishonest bitcoin miners from rigging the blockchain to say that coin X went from A->M instead of A->B.

Oh, so it has a built-in mining subsidy that miners are rewarded with? Because without that bitcoin suffers from an even worse version of the exact same problem and is not incentive compatible.

> As long as there are more nodes who would not benefit from this particular rigging as there are nodes who would, everyone can act in their own self-interest and the outcome would be correct.

What counts as a node? Can I spin up a million or a billion nodes on AWS and influence the vote that way?

Re:Truthcoin: Trustless, Decentralized Bitcoin Prediction Ma... by vbuterin on Sunday May 04, 2014 @06:54AM (#7693865)
> What counts as a node? Can I spin up a million or a billion nodes on AWS and influence the vote that way?

Proof of work? Proof of stake? It's not exactly an unsolved problem.

Re:Truthcoin: Trustless, Decentralized Bitcoin Prediction Ma... by pigeons on Tuesday May 13, 2014 @06:33PM (#7741053)
proof of stake seems to be hardly an answer to the problem. And maaku seems to be pointing out that proof-of-work WITH SUBSIDY so far has worked, but without subsidy the dynamics are quite different.
Re:Truthcoin: Trustless, Decentralized Bitcoin Prediction Ma... by foxhedgehog on Sunday May 04, 2014 @02:57AM (#7693578)
I think that falsifying proof-of-work in Bitcoin is probably much harder than affecting a voting outcome, which is reliant on human inputs.