It's certainly not a mathematical function. That being said, to even write 4 = x ^ (x ^ x ^ x ^ ...) is a bit misleading. The function diverges for y not in the range of e^-1 < y < e. I think that's a bit simpler and elegant way to look at it. A proof can be found on page 240: http://www.maa.org/sites/default/files/pdf/upload_library/22... (pdf)
I think your argument is avoiding the real issues. One problem is that the simplification of setting y = x^y introduces new solutions that are not solutions to the original equation. While any solution of the original must also satisfy y = x^y, the reverse is not true.
Even worse, the OP's algebraic manipulations assume there exists a solution to the equation. It's not logically sound to assume something exists and use that fact to prove that it exists.
Re:Two Equals Four (2011)
by voicereasonish on Saturday May 03, 2014 @02:45PM
(#7691910)
Also the big red flag in the reasoning is:
> "But take the square root of each side".
Sorry, but that's not really something you can do without recognising the fact that there are two square roots.
Graphing this using Google plot [0] or Wolfram Alpha [1], or just differentiating, reveals that it has a maximum at x = e, and that x takes the value sqrt(2) at both y = 2 and y = 4.
Therefore the inversion, which is the original equation
is dual-valued, i.e. it is not a mathematical function. For it to be a function, you need to specify whether you are on the upper branch (so that y = 4) or the lower branch (so that y = 2). Deliberately obfuscating the difference between the two branches leads to the conclusion that 2 = 4.The square root function can lead to a similar confusion, since there are two solutions to the equation
and hence the "function" is not really a function unless we specify whether we are on the upper (x > 0) or lower (x < 0) branch. By convention we interpret sqrt(y) to be the upper branch, and write -sqrt(y) for the lower branch, but there's nothing that forces that choice.Obfuscating the difference between the two branches could lead one to conclude that 1 = -1, although the fallacy is more obvious in this case, since everyone is familiar with the fact that the square root function is dual-valued.
[0] https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=y%5E(1%2Fy)
[1] http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=y%5E(1%2Fy)