News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Supreme Court reverses patent judges again in 9-0 deci... by rayiner on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @03:26PM (#7675729)
The legal system cannot be considered in isolation. It's part of a broader apparatus for protecting peoples' rights. Other countries have higher bars for getting into court, but they also have other mechanisms for enforcing peoples' rights. For example, European countries generally have more elaborate and burdensome regulatory regimes, and use administrative proceedings to accomplish things that in the U.S. are handled through court proceedings.

A good example is products liability law. The EU products liability directive is implemented in Germany as the Appliances and Product Safety Act. It does not create civil liability to injured consumers, but instead is part of an administrative enforcement regime. Authorities actively monitor the products on the market, and have the power to issue recalls, fines, and even criminal penalties.

For most areas of the law that see significant litigation (products liability, employment, etc) the U.S. either lacks such administrative entities or has undersized ones compared to what is common in Europe. In the American system, more of these issues are, consciously, left to be handled in private litigation. Essentially, in Europe you have more bureaucrats, and in America we have more lawyers.

Also, note that "loser pays" countries aren't usually literally "loser pays." In France, for example, losers pay court fees, but attorney's fees are awarded by a judge in an amount that usually doesn't cover actual amounts spent.

Re:US Supreme Court reverses patent judges again in 9-0 deci... by bediger4000 on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @05:39PM (#7676643)
I think a little disclosure should go along with your opinion. Are you, or have you been, a practicing attorney?
Re:US Supreme Court reverses patent judges again in 9-0 deci... by rayiner on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @07:24PM (#7677179)
I list a Northwestern Law email address in my profile, and post under my real name. I'm not exactly on the DL about it. ;)
Re:US Supreme Court reverses patent judges again in 9-0 deci... by gknoy on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @07:29PM (#7677192)
I'm not able to see your e-mail when I see your profile. You might consider including it in your user profile's "about" info box.
Re:US Supreme Court reverses patent judges again in 9-0 deci... by rayiner on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @07:37PM (#7677233)
That makes my profile comment unintentionally ironic.
Re:US Supreme Court reverses patent judges again in 9-0 deci... by speeder on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @07:29PM (#7677195)
Does it matter?

Being a lawyer does not make you magically more able to read the laws, the laws are written exactly because the intention is that people can read them and see what they do.

What makes a lawyer different is that a lawyer usually knows where to search for laws faster, and has a set of laws on his head that might be immediately useful, also lawyers tend to know some important past court cases that might affect future cases.

But still, being a lawyer does not make you a magical law knower, some countries even allow you to be a lawyer without law school.

Re:US Supreme Court reverses patent judges again in 9-0 deci... by akiselev on Wednesday April 30, 2014 @08:46PM (#7677487)
Lawyers spend the time and effort to actually learn about the law from an accredited institution and to pass the BAR exam, which is a certification that gives them legal responsibilities, and liabilities that nonlawyers do not have. That's what makes them different, not some better legal-Google-fu.