An experiment: perhaps microwave cookers. Issue 500 free modified cookers to a suitable target group who might need them, e.g. undergraduates. The modification consists of a simple device that records the settings used each time the microwave is used and uploads the results to a central server each week.
My hypothesis is that the number of programs actually used will be a very small subset of the total available. I know that my microwave oven is mainly used to reheat leftover soup, and occasionally to make porridge in the bowl. Highest power, 3 minutes or 5 minutes, that is that.
The issue is to make the most commonly used settings easily found. Back to UI design again.
Edit: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7674708
Acomjean arrived at a similar place while I wrote this.
1. Everyone always uses max power 2. Everyone cooks in increments of 30s 3. No other functionality ever gets used because no one knows what it does/implies
Thus a simplistic microwave design would consist of a '+30s' button and a 'Start/Stop' button. This would probably make microwaves much less complicated internally, and thus cheaper and more reliable.
That said, I don't think either of those is part of the design goals of most appliance manufacturers.
http://www.aroma-housewares.com/kitchen/appliances/products/...
In terms of whether his cooker will last 25 years, I'm not really sure how good Aroma is as a brand, but most of the Asian people I know (I'm Asian too) buy top end Japanese branded rice cookers like Zojirushi and Panasonic (aka National) -- and these cookers last a really long time. When you eat rice daily or almost daily, spending a little more for reliability is a no-brainer.
Those buttons add some value, but also a lot of potential for failure.
He is saying the added value is not worth the increased risk of failure of the device.
And then he proceeds to show the instruction manual, which, again, is written for people who barely understand concepts like "rice" and "inside".
How is the advent of digital technology to blame for the fact that you have to plug the rice cooker in? For the fact that you need to put the rice in the rice cooker? For the fact that you need to add some water, too? For the fact that you need to close the lid of the cooker? For the fact that you need to put the pot of rice inside the cooker BEFORE you close the lid, but AFTER you wash the rice?
edit: I looked at the post again. He barely says anything at all about the fact that this one might break; he mentions it in the very last sentence as a throwaway. He spends a lot of time complaining about how complicated the rice cooker is, describing it as "inscrutable" and "complicated" and complaining that "[he] never had to consult the manual" for his old rice cooker. So no, he's not complaining that the new one will break; he's complaining that pressing the power button and the white rice button in that order is a byzantine process that he can't be expected to understand.
I don't miss the scrubbing work at all.
The advent of fuzzy logic in rice cookers is pretty great, in my opinion; maybe he doesn't get a lot of benefit out of the ability to cook e.g. brown rice or bread or vegetables in his rice cooker, but if he's trying to complain that this device is so so complicated, he should probably post an actual complication that he has trouble with, instead of whining about pressing two clearly labeled buttons.