Like a lot of protection jobs, we only recognize when the job isn't being done right. So the occasional failure is evidence that they have "failed many times" (which is strictly correct, but not nearly as bad as it sounds).
Do you really think that having an "FDA" somehow alleviates all concern about the content/quality/integrity of the food you buy and eat?!????? C'mon, man...
I, for one, can't see why anybody assigns any particularly special level of trust to a government agency. Government agencies have been shown to be corrupt, incompetent, ineffective, and/or some combination of "any or all of the above" time and time again.
There are plenty of good reasons to get rid of the FDA, and "I just plain don't trust them" certainly belongs pretty high on the list.
I do, if FDA worked better. I certainly do not subscribed to the idea of abolishing it because it is broken. I subscribe to the idea of fixing it. Closing the revolving door as much as possible, making it stronger.
I have lived for many years in a country with an effectively missing FDA. It was there de-facto but it was a joke. So anyone could sell you anything. The joke about baby formula and chalk mixed with water was not a joke, it has happened. Other foodstuff is just like that.
"Organic" farmers live there too. You know what they do, the spray the shit of their produce with pesticides and put those in a different garden plot from the real organic food they grow for themselves. I have seen it myself (a relatives' neighbor does it). "Organic" there is a joke.
The best eggs and produce we got was a from a relative out f the "growing for yourself" lot not from the "growing for selling lot". Otherwise we just kind of guessed in the dark.
The alternative without the FDA is many many times more scary and only those who have no idea what it looks like would advocate for it.
This is not science fiction. You can buy a plane ticket and be within a day in a such a place in the world.
Your argument is broken as well. There's no way that the FDA can guarantee everything, because they would need 1000 times more inspectors if they wanted to do a reasonable job at it. Currently as long as a site is visited ONCE by the FDA and considered safe, it won't be years before that site is visited again by the same body. Everything that happens in between is basically completely out of the FDA loop, so anyway you have to trust in the products you buy.
Food traceability is a myth. You still don't know, more than 50 years ago, what's inside the products you buy, and whether these ingredients are consistent in concentration or not from one batch to another. You don't know what your animals eat before they become meat in your supermarket. You don't know what fertilizers were used to grow the crops you consume. You know virtually nothing about the food you buy, and guess what, the food has never been safer to consume than now, EVEN in countries where there's no FDA - Don't worry, Communist China also had issues with chemicals in the baby milk powder, except that people did NOT know or hear about it before. And China actually has a pretty strong FDA-like body and that does not prevent any of these issues from happening.
If tomorrow you got rid of the FDA, suddenly all manufacturers wouldn't put poison in your food, as if they were just waiting for that. Even before the FDA there were industry associations and consumer groups pushing for better quality standards - Health supervision was not born with the FDA.
You said in your OP "Trusting FDA to police the industry is like trusting the industry to police itself at this point."
Maybe it's something else that keeps companies from selling poison chalk milk as babyfood other than the FDA?
I don't see how the presence of the FDA alleviates any of the problems you just listed off. But, again, I plain don't trust them. If $MEGACORP wants an FDA rubber-stamp on something, I'm sure they have enough money to buy it.
Seriously, where do you people come up with this shit?
In countries with reasonably effective/trustworthy government agencies, it does a pretty decent job. Can't speak for the US FDA though.
I'm still not convinced that such a thing exists. Of course, my direct experience is limited to the USA, but human nature being what it is, I'm skeptical that "government" in any place is much better than "government" in another place.
Actually, no. If you bothered to actually try and understand what I'm saying, you'd realize that's not the case. What I'm saying is, we know the "first principles" (eg, human nature being what it is) and we can reason from first principles using deductive logic. So you can call that "talking out your ass" if you want, but I don't think that's accurate at all.
And the data and evidence point to the fact that governments with strong and healthy regulatory bodies do a far better job at public safety than any commercial enterprise by itself. Even the very reason why commercial verification and safety inspections by companies like UL and reinsurers work is because there's a strong legal process behind that and government institutions that are willing to put the foot down given enough public pressure.
Also, please, do me a favor and find me a social scientist who thinks that our "first principles" are anything but a crude and profoundly erroneous way to think about institutions and that those principles will do anything even remotely decent to approximate social reality.
I stick to the facts of food safety, and from my empirical experience of what few places me and my loved ones have been to in the world, I'd rather eat food certified as safe by an EU state any day over, say, a commercial institution in Namibia, massive warts and all.
I would suggest that you take the following view:
Libertarians in US would like to reduce federal government regulation. This means regulatory function just like general economic and political power has to be split across states, local government, and free consortiums'.
Where the job of a federal government is to enforce contracts between free entities and referee disputes http://www.catb.org/esr/faqs/libertarianism.html#A9
While not clearly articulated (and and indication that Libertarian party platform is far from fully developed), I think the Libertarian platform must include a position about 'normalized contract language' for common contracts.
Otherwise this is where lawyers working for larger corporations -- always win the disputes and this would cause a completely unfair system.
Are there federal government regulations that must remain? -- yes of course.
A FDA related discussion (albeit subjective) is here
http://www.dailypaul.com/257985/do-libertarians-want-to-elim...
Reporter: So in that particular case would the reasonable alternative being
no FDA?
Ron Paul: I think so because, I don't think, I think they've done more harm
than good because sometimes it might take them 25 years to allow a good drug
to come onto the marketplace and the rules and regulations inhibits the
options of the physician to use drugs for anything other than not approved
by the FDA, which means it slows up research and the cost goes up and then
when it's approved by the FDA, guess what happens? If you're on the inside
track of that- I'm the FDA- today I approve this drug, tomorrow, their drug
company's value, their stock goes up fifty fold. Just because a bureaucrat
made this decision. So, it's a protection of the corporation is basically
what it is. People weren't dying from bad drugs before we had the FDA. I
mean, it just didn't happen. There'd be other agencies that would do this.
There'd be no reason to assume that all of a sudden, the drug companies have
it in their interest to give you a bad drug.
http://www.naturalnews.com/035519_Ron_Paul_FDA_Big_Pharma.ht...Wow. I refuse to believe that Ron Paul of all people has never heard of "snake oil".
The FDA was formed precisely in response to "people dying from bad drugs": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pure_Food_and_Drug_Act#History_...
How do we let politicians get away with this sort of thing?
Surely, there are people that care about the quality of what goes in their body (certainly you and I do, at least). Those people would be willing to pay a small price to ensure that what they eat is not poison. Without the FDA, there would probably be numerous entities that evaluate food products and place their mark of approval on those products that pass a rigorous set of tests. Consumers that care about food quality will be willing to spend more to buy food with that mark of approval. If the company approves too many bad products, they lose reputation and go out of business.
In fact, there are already organizations that test the quality of products, like Consumer Reports. Personally, I find Amazon reviews to be very helpful when purchasing things, and if I bought my food from Amazon (I hope so one day!) I would read the reviews before buying food I don't know about.
> FDA and the supposed agencies entrusted by public to protect the public from poisons in the food have deemed to have failed many times.
I agree. Let's get rid of the FDA, we don't need.
--------
... You would be willing to trust what you put into your body to Consumer Reports? A magazine where, for a small fee, you can buy a positive review?
Your argument would be sound if, and only if, we could assume that the public would or could be fully informed as to the validity / accuracy of the various services that would pop up to replace the FDA.
Instead what would happen is the various services would simply find it more profitable to pend good reviews most of the time, just enough to be seen as good or slightly better than their peers for their particular advertising demographic. All of their peers, of course, would also take money to buy good reviews, so no single agency, or group of agencies could be trust worthy for any real amount of the time.
And while the FDA may fall into some similar traps as the above, the biggest difference would be that the FDA, by being seperate from the marketplace, has only its reputation and fear of its wrath to keep its value and budget. By contrast, the free market agencies that would pop up would have as a primary tool the ability to use advertising and marketing to ensure that even if their service is completely illegitimate, a portion of the marketplace would be convinced of its validity, because customers are not 100% knowledgeable on every matter.
And the best part, why would any of these agencies ever spend research money on their products? Sure, enough for the marketing to sound legitimate, perhaps, but not enough to thoroughly test their products, that could only shrink out number of corporate clients. So you can say goodbye to any science that might have come from agencies like the FDA actually conducting investigations.
So in short, all you would have created is a group of competing standards, non of which would have their customer's health as a primary concern, all actively advertising potential poisons to consumers, while simultaneously hurting agricultural research.
Do you have a source for the claim (which I'm pretty sure is an extraordinary claim) that one can buy a favorable review in Consumer Reports magazine, published by the nonprofit organization Consumers Union? I did the expected Google search before replying here, and I can't find any evidence for that claim, much less the extraordinary evidence I would need to believe that claim as a long-time (occasional) reader of Consumer Reports.
>You would be willing to trust what you put into your body to Consumer Reports? A magazine where, for a small fee, you can buy a positive review?
> All of their peers, of course, would also take money to buy good reviews, so no single agency, or group of agencies could be trust worthy for any real amount of the time.
Oh, so kind of how corporations spend money to lobby the FDA in their favor? Or large pharma companies bribe FDA regulators to approve only their drugs so they can have a monopoly on the market?
> has only its reputation and fear of its wrath to keep its value and budget
In what world is a government agency's reputation more important than a real business' bottom line? If the government doesn't do their job, they still take your money, everyone keeps their jobs, and the only recourse you have is to vote another representative in office who might try and change things. With a business, you stop giving them money, and they see the effect immediately.
> even if their service is completely illegitimate, a portion of the marketplace would be convinced of its validity,
Kind of like how the FDA uses the force of law to convince people that they actually look out for the consumer.
> And the best part, why would any of these agencies ever spend research money on their products?
If they didn't they would probably endorse bad products and go out of business.
Almost all of your criticisms could be applied to the FDA, but you think that they just need "reform." I don't need the government to tell me what to put in my body.
Keep in mind that "No immediately noticeable harm" is all they have to go for to stay in business. Long term health of your consumers isn't that important if you want to make some money.
I'd far rather have agencies that aren't motivated by making a quick buck keeping track of my food safety.
Especially since there is nothing preventing these hypothetical more rigorous companies from existing today, right now, if people don't trust the FDA.
I'd trust Consumer Reports at least as much as I trust the FDA. It's not like the FDA isn't a "member in good standing" of the agri/pharma/military/prison/industrial complex. Government Agency / Megacorp? Just two sides of the same coin.
And who decides that those tests are rigorous? What prevents me from creating a more lenient, "anything but blatant toxins" goes certification agency that puts it's seal of approval on things?
For that matter, what prevents these agencies existing today, in parallel with the FDA? We already have things like fair trade coffee, for example.
How many agencies with rotating names do you want to keep up with?
The EU-own certificate is the most lenient (AFAIK it allows of up 0.9% GM food in feed for animals if there is no alternative), the most strict one is the Demeter certificate, a pretty old one based on the slightly crazy teachings of Rudolf Steiner, complete with cosmic energy. Then there's Biokreis, Bioland, Biopark, Ecoland, Ecovin, and more, all of which have different requirements. No-one can keep up with these.
> And who decides that those tests are rigorous?
Really? Who decides those things now? That's the whole point: look at all the disasters the FDA has approved (and the high barrier to entering the marketplace they create, which kills an unknowable number of things that could be tremendously beneficial).
People have to make decisions with the best information that they have. At least with a commercial entity, you can see where the interests are aligned, instead of operating under the delusion that benevolent agents of the state are out there working on your behalf.
Here's a parallel example: the FDIC exists to insure bank deposit holders up to $100k (formerly $250k, but oh well). Now, with the FDIC, you have every incentive to ignore your bank and assume that your deposits are safe. What about without the FDIC? Maybe you're more concerned with how your bank invests your money. Maybe you ask to see their balance sheet. Maybe you see how disastrously over-leveraged they are and take your money elsewhere. If that happens enough times, look at all the financial crisis you SUDDENLY DON'T HAVE.
That's a pretty over-simplified example, so here's a more direct one: there's a program operated by FEMA called the National Flood Insurance Program. The purpose is to provide affordable flood insurance for houses which the market has decided are too flood-prone to be insured, but for a very expensive policy, if at all. Just consider that for a second: FEMA is literally reinforcing their own existence by incentivizing people to live in places where floods might destroy their homes and kill them. I don't think it gets any more perverse than that (though realistically it probably does).
The state can't help you. All it can do is provide concentrated centers of control to attract those with power and influence, and all you get in return is a false sense of security. You're literally walking into a trap and turning your brain off.
On the other hand, recorded history.
> How many agencies with rotating names do you want to keep up with?
Well currently we have one (the FDA), and it is awful. I am willing to try a few more.
Or if you're consistent, then you presumably abolished the USPTO as well, and now we're back to hiring our own personal food tasters...
As for amazon reviews, I'm reminded of the XKCD argument: an ebay seller can ship a live bobcat in place of the expected product one time in ten and still get 90% positive feedback...
* FDA and the supposed agencies entrusted by public to protect the public from poisons in the food have deemed to have failed many times. There is a revolving door between large agribusinesses and FDA. Department heads and CEO/COOs play musical chairs back and forth between. Trusting FDA to police the industry is like trusting the industry to police itself at this point.
* People are not educated enough to understand what is what. They see strange things on the labels and get scared.
* Everyone only has only one life + the life of their children to experiment on. So while a "rational" argument to "we don't know if it will poison us", is let's apply "science" and do an "experiment". Ok who wants to ingest this new formulation to be the guinea pig? Who wants to give to their infant son or daughter to later monitor and find out if they'll get cancer by the time their are 5 or not... Because the thing is, you don't get a do-over like you do with other things. "Oh the program segfaulted. Darn,..., fix bug, recompile and restart".
Those are a few of the reasons. So as the article points out people try to figure out it on their own and kind of feel around in the dark. Facebook groups. Friend of a friend found out about this new superfood item or something. Or I read on Facebook that pickles have lead in them. Whole Foods type place and other "health" food places take advantage of this fear and uncertainty. Others make fun that. Gee so and so is such a hippie eating sprouted beans or thinking GMOs are going to kill you. They don't know science, haha! The other side is making fun of those that don't eat organic hand massaged free range cows and how they are poisoning their kids with pesticides.
There are those who want to live the libertarian dream. Just abolish the FDA and let everyone go shopping with a radiological, chemical and bacteriological assay kit. Gee I would buy this cabbage but my portable DNA sequencer shows its DNA structures has been modified and it has been spliced with a DNA of a frog. I am afraid, I'll have to find another seller. Funny thing is -- these places exist. Just go to any poor country where government regulation is even more non-existent. That is the above dystopia. You want to buy baby formula? Ah well. It could be baby formula or could be chalk mixed with water and poisons chemical that someone packaged in a basement. Who knows, you decide.