* Should you get renters insurance? [1]
* The Splitwise Furniture Calculator [2]
* The Splitwise Guest Calculator [3]
* The Loud Sex (and other night-time noises) Calculator [4]
* The Splitwise Travel Calculator [5]
[0] https://www.splitwise.com/calculators
[1] https://www.splitwise.com/calculators/renters
[2] https://www.splitwise.com/calculators/furniture
[3] https://www.splitwise.com/calculators/guest
I see this kind of brokenness all the time. Is there a well known way to fix it on my end? Is this just bad web design?
I think if you have complex or specific preferences about rent splitting (ie I don't want to live next to the kitchen) and live with a bunch of fellow nerds, an implicit fair division system may work well. The NYT calc is a great new implementation the Francis Su paper - the old Java one was broken.
If you have non-nerd roommates, couples living together, or are already assigned to rooms by fate or immutable preference, that's what the Splitwise calculator is for. The price are based on square-footage, survey data, and common sense. Not everyone is willing to change from the room they like, or sit for an auction.
Rationale: http://blog.splitwise.com/rent-calculator-faq/ Survey: http://blog.splitwise.com/2011/02/20/survey-results-split-th... Follow up: http://blog.splitwise.com/2011/03/01/does-it-really-work-fee... My Quora answer: https://www.quora.com/Whats-the-fairest-way-to-assign-rooms-...
Happy to answer questions at jon at splitwise dot com
I suppose the insight is that (some or many) people are more ready to accept an unfair situation dictated by a dispassionate external authority (even if that authority is just some JavaScript!) than a fair situation reached by negotiation.
It seems rather unfair of you to incorporate that information into the bidding system and bid up the price of the small room (a sort of strategic bidding). But it also seems unfair that if we both answer honestly the system has a good chance of making the smaller room priced the same (or more than) the big room.
With any other roommate, especially one who didn't know about my pathological fear, I could expect to pay less for the smaller room. These "external authorities" might reflect such widespread notions, as well as avoid the risk of strategic bidding that can occur after roommate selection is fixed.
This even allows you to do the "Two people sharing a single room in a two-bedroom" calculation, unlike the NYTimes calculator.