Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by cheald on Monday April 28, 2014 @07:13PM
(#7663764)
Gosh, it's almost like Cogent being Netflix's former transit provider to Comcast and Verizon is the common link or something.
I can't wait to see people freak out about and completely misunderstand this one, too, though.
It's interesting that Netflix is continuing to ink these deals while waging a PR war against the people they're contracting with, rather than just backing Cogent's play. If they're really concerned about this kind of thing, then it kinda seems like inking the deal and then complaining about it puts them in a really morally indefensible position, unless they're just counting on public hatred of the telecoms to carry them to an advantageous position.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by 23david on Monday April 28, 2014 @09:43PM
(#7664403)
IMO, Netflix management caving in here, while at the same time RAISING prices, shows just how strong their management feels their market position is. Hello monopoly.
It may be non-intuitive, but this kind of 'tax' is actually to Netflix's benefit. From now on, it'll be much more expensive and difficult for any other competitors to enter the on-demand video market. Regulation/taxes often help solidify the status-quo. Look at the healthcare/finance/education industries...
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by cheald on Monday April 28, 2014 @10:33PM
(#7664562)
It is absolutely to Netflix's benefit. Their negotiated rate per megabyte delivered is almost certainly substantially lower than a competitor would be able to manage on market-rate transit.
This move doesn't raise rates for competitors, but it certainly goes give Netflix an financial advantage that a non-established player wouldn't be able to gain.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by sheetjs on Monday April 28, 2014 @07:40PM
(#7663881)
It seems as if Netflix is more threatened by competitors like HBO Go and Hulu and Amazon Video than by the telecoms, so deals like this give Netflix an edge over other upstarts
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by cheald on Monday April 28, 2014 @07:46PM
(#7663907)
They could purchase transit from someone that isn't Cogent. It would be more expensive than what they're paying the ISPs, but I rather doubt they'd be talking about "tolls" in that case, because everyone that originates traffic on the internet pays for transit.
That's been one of my primary issues with Netflix's behavior in this whole thing. They've presented this false dichotemy of "we pay the ISPs protection money, or we can't deliver our bits to you :(", and it's just...not true.
Here's a list of everyone that peers with Comcast. You might notice that the list is larger than "Cogent and Netflix": http://bgp.he.net/AS7922#_peers
"Some of the largest content providers have, in effect, created networks equivalent to those of Tier-1
ISPs. Google has the most extensive set of peering points, covering every continent, but Microsoft,
Yahoo, Amazon and Facebook also have extensive peering. TeleGeography, citing Arbor Networks,
indicates that “Google has boosted its share of traffic exchanged via peering links from 40 percent in
2008 to 60 percent in 2010.”
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by cheald on Monday April 28, 2014 @08:09PM
(#7663998)
They pay for that 40% of traffic that isn't peered, absolutely. Peered traffic isn't free, though, either - the infrastructure build-out and maintenance costs can be substantial. There are economies of scale at play here, though - once you hit a certain point, it's more cost-effective to build and maintain your own network than to rent someone else's.
If deals like the Netflix/Comcast deal were made illegal, this would only tilt things further in favor of the existing big players, because if you have the kind of scale available that you can build out your own peering networks (like Google), then you can deliver your content for pennies on the dollar as compared to your competition. Transit is expensive. Paid peering allows companies like Netflix - miniscule compared to someone like Google - to achieve effective transit rates that are much closer to what Google can achieve than they could otherwise.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by wmf on Monday April 28, 2014 @08:21PM
(#7664048)
Isn't Netflix the same size as Google or larger?
In general, in a world where the only choices are transit or free peering, smaller players could buy CDN services from CDNs that are large enough to qualify for free peering and multiple competing CDNs would drive prices down. It has already been observed that CDN pricing is about the same as transit pricing even though CDNs add value through locality.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by cheald on Monday April 28, 2014 @08:29PM
(#7664089)
In terms of bandwidth? I actually kind of doubt it. Netflix sees tremendous primetime usage, but Google's bandwidth usage is likely to be substantial throughout the entire day, and it's global, whereas Netflix tends to be much more regional.
In terms of financial resources? Not even close. Google utterly dwarfs them in terms of capability to build out and maintain networks.
I would love some info on CDN vs transit pricing. In particular, it seems somewhat apples-to-oranges, since CDN pricing is generally per GB delivered, whereas transit pricing is generally per Mbit of capacity. You can approximate a conversion between the two, but you'd have to be careful when comparing them that the comparison is valid.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by wmf on Monday April 28, 2014 @07:51PM
(#7663923)
Do you think that would help? I don't. When Netflix was using Tata, the Tata-Comcast links also got congested. Even if Netflix spread their traffic across all the backbones, I suspect Comcast would just refuse to upgrade all those transit connections.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by cheald on Monday April 28, 2014 @07:58PM
(#7663953)
Yes, actually, I do think it would help. Perhaps not in the short term, but let me explain what I mean.
Comcast isn't specifically throttling Netflix, they're just not providing sufficient link capacity for primetime delivery of traffic (including Netflix) via some routes. Netflix could provide traffic across alternate (or multiple alternate) routes; as those saturate (particularly with the emergence of 4k streaming), Comcast's service as a whole would suffer. Anyone who was delivering traffic via Cogent to Comcast could attest to how awful their delivery was during primetime; if that were happening on multiple links, it wouldn't just be Netflix and a few other services that were slow, it would be the entire internet, from the perspective of the Comcast customer. This would serve to exert pressure on Comcast to upgrade those links.
It's not a pretty solution, but the issue isn't "Netflix is throttled", the issue is "Comcast is a shitty ISP", and Netflix peering with them directly does nothing to solve that. Degrading multiple routes will exert more pressure on Comcast to improve than just about anything short of Google Fiber moving in next door.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by cheald on Monday April 28, 2014 @08:11PM
(#7664010)
Why do you say that? If Google Fiber moved in next door, and your customers could get a better value for their money, Comcast's options would be to compete or to have the vast majority of their business stolen from them.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by lern_too_spel on Monday April 28, 2014 @09:01PM
(#7664214)
Nonsense. You're just moving who is paying the protection money to a middle man. That doesn't solve the underlying problem, which is that nobody should be paying that protection money to the racketeers.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by lern_too_spel on Monday April 28, 2014 @09:38PM
(#7664378)
It hasn't. In the past, service providers have paid for transit to the internet at large, not to connect to specific ISPs offering competing services. It used to be up to the ISP to make sure they had sufficient connectivity to the data that their customers wanted.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by mindslight on Monday April 28, 2014 @07:37PM
(#7663872)
> unless they're just counting on public hatred of the telecoms to carry them to an advantageous position.
Pretty much. They've made plain their envisioned future, and now they're haggling over the price. Netflix as a company doesn't actually need or want net neutrality, because free communications based on alternative protocols will undermine their lucrative position as the new hip entertainment provider. If you're giving Netflix money then you are responsible for helping to centralize (and thus destroy) the Internet.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by redorb on Monday April 28, 2014 @08:23PM
(#7664058)
Is stealing - if that is how one might see it.. ever justified besides for survival? There is always the option to not partake in things not available in your region. I mean it's ok to feel justified personally - but I wouldn't.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by cheald on Monday April 28, 2014 @10:31PM
(#7664556)
You're looking at a correlation and presuming a cause because it supports your presuppositions.
Looking at those graphs, I notice two interesting things. First, Comcast, Verizon, and AT&T all experience downward trends starting around Q4 2013...which is right around when Netflix rolled out SuperHD to everyone (which would have increased throughput, and exacerbated saturated links.) Their trends roughly track each other...and the remaining ones tick upward when Netflix started routing directly to Comcast. Now that's curious (anyone care to traceroute Netflix's streaming edges from an ATT uverse connection?)
Second, there are two ISPs on that chart which don't have throughput issues. Cox delivers Netflix via XO, I don't know about Cablevision. Did they just miss the Evil Memo or something? Or perhaps there is a fundamentally different issue at play here other than thugs demanding protection money?
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by drawkbox on Monday April 28, 2014 @08:10PM
(#7664000)
Netflix previous to this had considerable power to stop the tiered internet but they actually are defining the moment it separates. Netflix's history will include fueling the demise of network neutrality.
Fool me once...
At their stage, they are taking advantage of their place in the short term and this benefits them heavily while playing the PR side against it. But in the end they may have figured their own downfall when they don't own their own network and can't compete with comcast, verizon, cox, etc's own streaming networks which will have all the cable channels as well as other content.
They could have changed law with only lobbying the consumer, now it will cost them and everyone. It might be hard to imagine but the moment someone streams live sports and hbo the game changes dramatically. Would have been nice to have network neutrality last longer than 2 decades on the internet, it is over.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by insaneirish on Monday April 28, 2014 @08:56PM
(#7664190)
> Netflix previous to this had considerable power to stop the tiered internet but they actually are defining the moment it separates. Netflix's history will include fueling the demise of network neutrality.
Hyperbole much? This is a peering agreement. It has nothing to do with "network neutrality"--a phrase that is vague and hollow enough to mean absolutely nothing.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by drawkbox on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @12:10AM
(#7664889)
This gives precedence and license to Comcast and Verizon to play more games. To think it won't greatly change their power and pricing behind the line is naive. This is just the beginning. It isn't about better service, it is about extortion.
Immediately after the Sept. ruling these Cogent connections seemingly started to downgrade in unison: http://knowmore.washingtonpost.com/2014/04/25/this-hilarious... They aren't providing faster service, they are providing the service levels they took away, the extortion is to get back to normal levels.
Netflix just made extortion part of the game behind the consumer line (of course Verizon and Comcast want that but Netflix just made their future much more murky). This will hit consumers in 2-3 years for sure. Tell me I am being hyperbolic in a year or two when your broadband/content services just doubled... in cost, while not doubling in speed or service. This also coincides with a Netflix rise in rates as proof already.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by davorak on Monday April 28, 2014 @09:56PM
(#7664455)
> It has nothing to do with "network neutrality"--a phrase that is vague and hollow enough to mean absolutely nothing.
The definition that google gives when searching for "define network neutrality" matched my understanding and does not seem vague:
"the principle that Internet service providers should enable access to all content and applications regardless of the source, and without favoring or blocking particular products or websites."
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by mbreese on Monday April 28, 2014 @10:37PM
(#7664573)
But note, it doesn't say that ISPs have to have the same size pipe to all peers. Which was the problem in this case... Comcast, et al. didn't want to upgrade their Cogent links to handle the required traffic from Netflix. Everyone sending Comcast traffic through Cogent was equally penalized during prime time hours. You can argue it's poor network management, but it is still "neutral".
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by davorak on Monday April 28, 2014 @11:08PM
(#7664696)
> Comcast, et al. didn't want to upgrade their Cogent links to handle the required traffic from Netflix. Everyone sending Comcast traffic through Cogent was equally penalized during prime time hours. You can argue it's poor network management, but it is still "neutral".
That is my understanding. My comment was just pointing out that "net neutrality" is not considered a vague term by a considerable number of people.
I do think it is unfortunate that Netflix is incentivized to make this type of deal rather then their ISP.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by insaneirish on Monday April 28, 2014 @11:36PM
(#7664785)
It doesn't matter that it has a definition. The so-called definition just adds to the ambiguity. The Internet is a very complicated thing and getting your packets from A to B is a technical and contractual miracle. What does it mean to treat all packets equally? If I have "equal" connectivity to content sources X and Y, but X sends 10 times the amount of traffic that can fit in its pipe, it's very "neutral" of me to do nothing about it. And then the experience sucks for everyone.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by davorak on Tuesday April 29, 2014 @01:03AM
(#7665065)
>What does it mean to treat all packets equally?
The definition that google gives and I quoted does not not contain that phrase.
> If I have "equal" connectivity to content sources X and Y, but X sends 10 times the amount of traffic that can fit in its pipe, it's very "neutral" of me to do nothing about it. And then the experience sucks for everyone.
The ISP has the option to charge more per packet until it makes economical sense. The increased revenue would allow the ISP to increase infrastructure and incentivizes heavy users to reduce their use. That is one of at least a few options ISPs have while remaining net neutral.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by necubi on Monday April 28, 2014 @08:06PM
(#7663980)
Note that these deals, while potentially objectionable, don't violate net neutrality as it's commonly understood. The key difference is that they involve the transit between Netflix and Verizon/Comcast, rather than within Verizon/Comcast.
It would be violating net neutrality if they were deliberately slowing down Netflix traffic within their networks, rather than offering to peer (provide a more direct or higher-bandwidth connection) with Netflix's transit partner.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by wmf on Monday April 28, 2014 @08:16PM
(#7664029)
It appears to me that Comcast was deliberately refusing to upgrade transit links to harm Netflix; whether it's within their network or on the edge seems like an irrelevant detail.
I don't understand why the definition of net neutrality should be frozen, leaving companies free to invent new loopholes.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by necubi on Monday April 28, 2014 @09:15PM
(#7664270)
Netflix always has another recourse in this situation: they could use a transit provider (like L3) that Comcast already peers with. Evidently they've decided that paying Comcast is cheaper than paying L3. If Comcast were deliberately slowing down their traffic there would be nothing they could do besides paying.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by dublinben on Monday April 28, 2014 @11:31PM
(#7664769)
It seems like pretty much all of Comcast's interconnects are full or nearly full. Netflix could not send their traffic through any (or all) transit providers even if they wanted to. Comcast is playing hardball to force content providers to make these kind of direct (paid) arrangements.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by cheald on Monday April 28, 2014 @08:19PM
(#7664042)
That requires a rather short view of history. Comcast was refusing to upgrade its transit links because it's been in dispute with Cogent over the terms of their peering. Verizon, likewise, has been in dispute with Cogent over similar terms. Cogent has been in disputes with a bunch of other people over the past 15 years or so, as well, over more or less the same thing.
This is not new or unique to Netflix. Netflix is just the most visible casualty because their total traffic load is such a substantial chunk of the total.
Re:Verizon inks paid peering deal with Netflix
by lemoninthebox on Monday April 28, 2014 @10:47PM
(#7664609)
AT&T is fixing to do a similar deal too from the looks of it. I have to say, I see some very, very bitter irony in them doing this while publicly shaming Comcast over their paid peering arrangement.
I can't wait to see people freak out about and completely misunderstand this one, too, though.
It's interesting that Netflix is continuing to ink these deals while waging a PR war against the people they're contracting with, rather than just backing Cogent's play. If they're really concerned about this kind of thing, then it kinda seems like inking the deal and then complaining about it puts them in a really morally indefensible position, unless they're just counting on public hatred of the telecoms to carry them to an advantageous position.
It may be non-intuitive, but this kind of 'tax' is actually to Netflix's benefit. From now on, it'll be much more expensive and difficult for any other competitors to enter the on-demand video market. Regulation/taxes often help solidify the status-quo. Look at the healthcare/finance/education industries...
This move doesn't raise rates for competitors, but it certainly goes give Netflix an financial advantage that a non-established player wouldn't be able to gain.
That's been one of my primary issues with Netflix's behavior in this whole thing. They've presented this false dichotemy of "we pay the ISPs protection money, or we can't deliver our bits to you :(", and it's just...not true.
Here's a list of everyone that peers with Comcast. You might notice that the list is larger than "Cogent and Netflix": http://bgp.he.net/AS7922#_peers
https://peering.google.com/about/
https://www.techpolicyinstitute.org/files/amkinternetpeering...
"Some of the largest content providers have, in effect, created networks equivalent to those of Tier-1 ISPs. Google has the most extensive set of peering points, covering every continent, but Microsoft, Yahoo, Amazon and Facebook also have extensive peering. TeleGeography, citing Arbor Networks, indicates that “Google has boosted its share of traffic exchanged via peering links from 40 percent in 2008 to 60 percent in 2010.”
If deals like the Netflix/Comcast deal were made illegal, this would only tilt things further in favor of the existing big players, because if you have the kind of scale available that you can build out your own peering networks (like Google), then you can deliver your content for pennies on the dollar as compared to your competition. Transit is expensive. Paid peering allows companies like Netflix - miniscule compared to someone like Google - to achieve effective transit rates that are much closer to what Google can achieve than they could otherwise.
In general, in a world where the only choices are transit or free peering, smaller players could buy CDN services from CDNs that are large enough to qualify for free peering and multiple competing CDNs would drive prices down. It has already been observed that CDN pricing is about the same as transit pricing even though CDNs add value through locality.
In terms of financial resources? Not even close. Google utterly dwarfs them in terms of capability to build out and maintain networks.
I would love some info on CDN vs transit pricing. In particular, it seems somewhat apples-to-oranges, since CDN pricing is generally per GB delivered, whereas transit pricing is generally per Mbit of capacity. You can approximate a conversion between the two, but you'd have to be careful when comparing them that the comparison is valid.
I have to disagree here. I'm buying in the tens of Gb/second of transit (1 year terms), and its under $1/Mb. I define that as fairly inexpensive.
Comcast isn't specifically throttling Netflix, they're just not providing sufficient link capacity for primetime delivery of traffic (including Netflix) via some routes. Netflix could provide traffic across alternate (or multiple alternate) routes; as those saturate (particularly with the emergence of 4k streaming), Comcast's service as a whole would suffer. Anyone who was delivering traffic via Cogent to Comcast could attest to how awful their delivery was during primetime; if that were happening on multiple links, it wouldn't just be Netflix and a few other services that were slow, it would be the entire internet, from the perspective of the Comcast customer. This would serve to exert pressure on Comcast to upgrade those links.
It's not a pretty solution, but the issue isn't "Netflix is throttled", the issue is "Comcast is a shitty ISP", and Netflix peering with them directly does nothing to solve that. Degrading multiple routes will exert more pressure on Comcast to improve than just about anything short of Google Fiber moving in next door.
Google Fiber could move in next door and Comcast would still do nothing to improve.
They may be evil, but they aren't stupid.
Pretty much. They've made plain their envisioned future, and now they're haggling over the price. Netflix as a company doesn't actually need or want net neutrality, because free communications based on alternative protocols will undermine their lucrative position as the new hip entertainment provider. If you're giving Netflix money then you are responsible for helping to centralize (and thus destroy) the Internet.
http://knowmore.washingtonpost.com/2014/04/25/this-hilarious...
It's really a shame Netflix just gave up instead of fighting them, though.
Looking at those graphs, I notice two interesting things. First, Comcast, Verizon, and AT&T all experience downward trends starting around Q4 2013...which is right around when Netflix rolled out SuperHD to everyone (which would have increased throughput, and exacerbated saturated links.) Their trends roughly track each other...and the remaining ones tick upward when Netflix started routing directly to Comcast. Now that's curious (anyone care to traceroute Netflix's streaming edges from an ATT uverse connection?)
Second, there are two ISPs on that chart which don't have throughput issues. Cox delivers Netflix via XO, I don't know about Cablevision. Did they just miss the Evil Memo or something? Or perhaps there is a fundamentally different issue at play here other than thugs demanding protection money?
Fool me once...
At their stage, they are taking advantage of their place in the short term and this benefits them heavily while playing the PR side against it. But in the end they may have figured their own downfall when they don't own their own network and can't compete with comcast, verizon, cox, etc's own streaming networks which will have all the cable channels as well as other content.
They could have changed law with only lobbying the consumer, now it will cost them and everyone. It might be hard to imagine but the moment someone streams live sports and hbo the game changes dramatically. Would have been nice to have network neutrality last longer than 2 decades on the internet, it is over.
Hyperbole much? This is a peering agreement. It has nothing to do with "network neutrality"--a phrase that is vague and hollow enough to mean absolutely nothing.
Immediately after the Sept. ruling these Cogent connections seemingly started to downgrade in unison: http://knowmore.washingtonpost.com/2014/04/25/this-hilarious... They aren't providing faster service, they are providing the service levels they took away, the extortion is to get back to normal levels.
Netflix just made extortion part of the game behind the consumer line (of course Verizon and Comcast want that but Netflix just made their future much more murky). This will hit consumers in 2-3 years for sure. Tell me I am being hyperbolic in a year or two when your broadband/content services just doubled... in cost, while not doubling in speed or service. This also coincides with a Netflix rise in rates as proof already.
The definition that google gives when searching for "define network neutrality" matched my understanding and does not seem vague:
"the principle that Internet service providers should enable access to all content and applications regardless of the source, and without favoring or blocking particular products or websites."
That is my understanding. My comment was just pointing out that "net neutrality" is not considered a vague term by a considerable number of people.
I do think it is unfortunate that Netflix is incentivized to make this type of deal rather then their ISP.
The definition that google gives and I quoted does not not contain that phrase.
> If I have "equal" connectivity to content sources X and Y, but X sends 10 times the amount of traffic that can fit in its pipe, it's very "neutral" of me to do nothing about it. And then the experience sucks for everyone.
The ISP has the option to charge more per packet until it makes economical sense. The increased revenue would allow the ISP to increase infrastructure and incentivizes heavy users to reduce their use. That is one of at least a few options ISPs have while remaining net neutral.
It would be violating net neutrality if they were deliberately slowing down Netflix traffic within their networks, rather than offering to peer (provide a more direct or higher-bandwidth connection) with Netflix's transit partner.
I don't understand why the definition of net neutrality should be frozen, leaving companies free to invent new loopholes.
This is not new or unique to Netflix. Netflix is just the most visible casualty because their total traffic load is such a substantial chunk of the total.
So which ISP is next?