It came out afterwards that Deeds' son, who had been diagnosed in the past with bipolar disorder, had undergone a psychiatric evaluation the day before the attack, and as a result of that evaluation had been placed under an emergency custody order. But Virginia law only gives mental health authorities six hours to find a bed to put the patient into in such cases; and in this case no bed could be found in that time, so Austin Deeds was sent home. [2]
This has naturally provoked a great deal of concern in these parts, both about how so little resources are available for mental health patients that a potentially violent one could be turned away for lack of an available bed, and about the ridiculously short 6-hour limit on how long such patients can be held. And rightly so -- if help had been available for Austin Deeds when he needed it, he might still be alive today, and his father might never have suffered such a horrific experience.
Deeds has recovered now, and upon his return to the legislature announced that he would be pushing hard for mental health reform in the state, garnering wide support. But it's telling that the issue had to strike at a political leader for anyone in the political class to care about it overmuch. One wonders how many other families in Virginia have suffered their own horror stories, their own tragedies, in total silence -- just because, since they weren't rich or powerful, nobody in a position to fix things could be bothered to care.
[1] http://www.washingtonpost.com/local/crime/virginia-state-sen...
[2] http://www.nbcwashington.com/news/local/Va-Senator-Recalls-S...
That advocacy was driven by the horrific conditions that became common. Google Willowbrook.
The health insurance situation only exacerbates that: there might be 5 facilities in the area that can take people, but only 1 that can take the uninsured. Florida is one of the states that "wisely" chose not to do a Medicaid expansion, and so if you're poor but without a diagnosed, processed, shortlisted disability, you're uninsured. Hilariously federal subsidies for buying coverage only kick in if you're making some high percentage of the poverty line, which people with mental health issues often have trouble reaching a fraction of that.
Oh and to add to that for the one available facility they used the Room 101 description from Orwell's 1984 as inspiration. No windows. Smoothed concrete floors. Echoing cries and screams. Blood. Food barely fit for animal consumption. And of course nothing helpful like any sort of talk therapy. Psychiatrist in residence once a day for 30 minutes, allotting on average 30 seconds per patient. Sleeping in cots on the floor. Sitting against the wall for hours with nothing to do but stare. If you've never experienced it before it becomes pretty clear pretty quick how much meaningful care is provided to unprivileged people suffering from mental health issues in this country.
Someone fairly close to me is affected by the illness, and I've discovered it's not something you can just talk about. If someone close to you has heart disease, you'll get sympathy. If someone close to you has schizophrenia, it's almost shameful to talk about. It just doesn't get the same amount of sympathy.
http://sandiegohomelesssurvivalguide.blogspot.com/
I also speak out here and on Metafilter. My diagnosis is not a mental health issue, it is medical, but it is clear to me that it impacts my mental functioning. My answer for me is a) preserve as much agency for myself as possible and b) get my body well.
I have a cystic fibrosis. People accuse me of being mentally ill for thinking I can get well. I have been told that is not possible. It is possible. I have made ongoing forward progress for 13 years.
Unfortunately, most people do not believe me and the social fallout from that is pretty crazy-making.
Just because the answer is not easy or quick does not mean there is none. There are lots of ways to work on issues like homelessness and the mental health of other people. Each piece of the puzzle matters.
It's not so much no power, it has been the lack of advocates because of the shame associated with all mental illnesses. A person with cancer can do the noble stand. A person with schizophrenia is much less capable of doing the needed advocacy. Things are changing as more people are pushing and not keeping quiet.
From a advocacy view, we better start putting this and brain problems in general front and center since we are living long enough that we need the understanding of treating the brain to use our longer lives well.
IMO, finding real treatments for mental illness is probably the most important part of longevity research as a healthy body and a decayed mind is in some ways little different than a dead body.
23.5% of schizophrenia sufferers is a minuscule quantity. What percentage of people over 40 develop schizophrenia? Over 60? What percentage of people over 60 develop one of "cancer or heart disease"?
> a healthy body and a decayed mind is in some ways little different than a dead body.
I don't disagree at all.
> finding real treatments for mental illness is probably the most important part of longevity research
No, the most important part of longevity research is getting the body to last. A dead body with a "healthy mind" (not clear what that would mean) doesn't qualify as longevous by any standard. Someone who won't go senile for 150 years is pointless if he dies at 82 like a normal person, and while that scenario is admittedly a kind of progress it (a) is undetectable, which makes research difficult, and (b) has no application at all until we can get the guy to live longer. Longer lifespans are more fundamental, are immediately visible, and have immediate application; they can take advantage of natural variation in the onset of mental failure.
A person has heart disease or cancer. A person is schizophrenic, or bipolar, or manic, or psychopathic, or depressed.
It's like the aphorism "you have a body, you are a soul".
A person with cancer or heart disease may be concerned and occupied by the disease or condition, but it's not who they are.
I've had my own encounters with people suffering from various psychological conditions, and ultimately, it's simply very trying to be with them in many cases. It's worse if you're not aware of the condition at all. In several cases the information emerged later, with a very strong sense of "well, that explains a lot".
Worse is when the person turns on you, whether emotionally, physically, or by other means. And yes, I've had that happen as well.
I do have a great deal of sympathy for those suffering from such conditions, but my own self-preservation (and sanity-preservation) instincts also kick in after a time.
Much excellent discussion here, I might add, thanks all.
It's perfectly rational for a disease that can strike anyone to generate more fear (therefore funding) than one which everybody believes they're immune to.