News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by mark_l_watson on Monday April 28, 2014 @05:08AM (#7658931)
The HBR review, when I first read it, struck my as the establishment trying to downplay the importance of this book.

Krugman, who I sometimes do not agree with, but was right on in reviewing this book, rightly points out that the elites are freaking out over this book because the facts are against their position.

This is an important book depicting how bad income equality has become because of inherited capital.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by yummyfajitas on Monday April 28, 2014 @06:17AM (#7659060)
Could you explain what facts you believe Piketty conveys? What is the importance?

I'm about halfway through the book, but apart from a bunch of historical data ("wealth inequality was high, then low, then high", "really bad things like war and depression reduce inequality, while growth increases it"), I can't figure out what the actual point of the book is. Piketty certainly doesn't clearly state his theory in the first 400 or so pages.

If it's about inequality caused by inherited capital, Piketty only supports this claim in the historical era (Jane Austen/Balzac/etc). He says very little about the present.

He also seems unaware that there is a world outside of the US, UK and France (and maybe also Sweden+Germany). That's quite a strange omission given that the vast majority of inequality in the world is not within the west, but between the west and the rest.

(As I mentioned, I'm only halfway through, so feel free to correct me if the rest of the book is different.)

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by vanderZwan on Monday April 28, 2014 @06:32AM (#7659108)
> He also seems unaware that there is a world outside of the US, UK and France (and maybe also Sweden+Germany).

I'm not even halfway into the book, but he apologises for this at the beginning, especially the focus on France, and gives justifications for this. Simply put, he doesn't have data (yet) for most of the rest of the world. France gets extra attention because it is the country for which he has the most and oldest data, and has had less drastic changes compared to the US, which has grown two orders of magnitude in population in the same time.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by yummyfajitas on Monday April 28, 2014 @06:42AM (#7659124)
That's a perfectly valid reason for leaving Asia/Africa out of the 200-year long timeseries. Nevertheless, a discussion of inequality which doesn't even acknowledge the vast gaps between a Yank/Frenchy/Brit and an Indian/Chinese/Nigerian is woefully incomplete almost to the point of dishonesty.

(I say "almost" because I've met enough ignorant westerners to realize that dishonesty is not the only explanation for this. I don't understand it myself, but some people's vision truly does stop at the border. )

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by vanderZwan on Monday April 28, 2014 @06:53AM (#7659147)
Fair point, but I think we're drifting away from the issue that the book is trying to address, which is the consequence of capitalist economic policy on inequality. Not inequality in general. Of course countries that have different economic policies are very interesting for comparison and to find better ways of addressing the issues with capitalism, but they are not necessary to answer that question.
Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by yummyfajitas on Monday April 28, 2014 @07:17AM (#7659200)
The effect of capitalistic economic policy has been drastic reductions in global inequality as China/India/others have become wealthier. Immigration (at least in the short run [1]) has even larger effects.

[1] In the long run I'd be concerned about the damage immigrants might do in the voting booth, but that's a non-economic problem.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by chongli on Monday April 28, 2014 @08:59AM (#7659563)
capitalistic economic policy has been drastic reductions in global inequality

Do you have any data to support this claim?

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by mrow84 on Monday April 28, 2014 @06:39AM (#7659120)
I haven't got the book, but the hypothesis it claims to offer evidence for is given in the introduction, which is available online at [0]:

"When the rate of return on capital exceeds the rate of growth of output and income, as it did in the nineteenth century and seems quite likely to do again in the twenty-first, capitalism automatically generates arbitrary and unsustainable inequalities that radically undermine the meritocratic values on which democratic societies are based."

Indeed, you yourself wrote an interesting blog post essentially regarding technicalities of that point [1].

You note that he has (as far as you have read) said little about the present, so he may not have substantiated the conditions necessary for his hypothesis in the present day, but it's a little unfair to suggest that a hypothesis doesn't exist.

[0] http://www.hup.harvard.edu/features/capital-in-the-twenty-fi...

[1] http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2014/piketty_inequality_an...

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by yummyfajitas on Monday April 28, 2014 @06:54AM (#7659151)
If that is the claim of the book, he has not made any attempt whatsoever to support it as of the halfway point of the book. So far, all I've read from him is some assorted data suggesting r has historically been bigger than g except when it wasn't, and that inequality grows except when bad things happen.

If he wants to show that r > g has any effect on inequality, he needs to do a LOT more than he's done. Historic timeseries of the sort he presents are completely incapable of demonstrating this point - you need longitudinal microdata for that, together with a far more detailed theory than "r > g". If you simply have r > g (ignoring volatility, as he's done so far), and treat capital as homogeneous (as he's mostly done so far), then this will explicitly NOT happen:

http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2014/piketty_inequality_an...

Maybe he does this in the rest of the book, but I'm far less hopeful as I read more. To paraphrase Eliezer Yudkowsky:

But the real cleverness is in how inequality was marketed. They left out the math.

http://lesswrong.com/lw/vv/logical_or_connectionist_ai/

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by saalweachter on Monday April 28, 2014 @08:15AM (#7659404)
> If he wants to show that r > g has any effect on inequality, he needs to do a LOT more than he's done.

I am not sure what you mean by this.

'r' is the rate of return of capital, 'g' is the rate of growth of the economy. If 'r' is greater than 'g', than money continuously invested with a rate of return of 'r' will grow faster than 'g', by definition.

Are you disputing the basic match? Are you disputing that 'r' is ever greater than 'g'? Are you disputing that a diversified portfolio will return at a rate of 'r' when the average rate of return of all capital investments is 'r'?

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by yummyfajitas on Monday April 28, 2014 @09:03AM (#7659582)
I mean exactly what I said - r > g does not have any intrinsic relationship with inequality. All it means is that (capital stock) / (yearly income) will grow.

There is no reason why a society with capital/income = 10 years has more or less inequality than one with capital/income=5 years.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by jgalt212 on Monday April 28, 2014 @03:15PM (#7662212)
I definitely think there is. The bigger the difference between r and g with r > g the more wealth gets concentrated in the hands of a few as time increases (as long as there is some variability in income levels at t0). If everyone earns the same exact money, it makes no difference what the return on capital is--everyone's income and wealth will be exactly the same for all t (as long as savings rates are equal).

I will attempt to google an answer for you

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by riffraff on Monday April 28, 2014 @05:07PM (#7663071)
it depends on how the r is distributed doesn't it? Suppose there is Alice who owns 1M in bonds and doesn't work while Barbara and Charlie own a 100K house and are blue collars.

If the houses price goes up ten times while the bonds pay only 110% than total inequality goes down even if Alice still hasn't worked a day.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by jgalt212 on Monday April 28, 2014 @05:58PM (#7663400)
yes, that's definitely true, but if there's only 1 r and all assets return r, I'd say the bigger r is relative to g, the higher the wealth concentration as t increases.

most of this math is above me (differential equations and finite difference methods), but the models are pretty easy to experiment with if you employ Monte Carlo methods.

In fact, that would be a nice side project: Piketty web app where the user can mess with various permutations of r and g and their distributions.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by danielweber on Monday April 28, 2014 @09:47AM (#7659881)
'r' is the rate of return of capital, 'g' is the rate of growth of the economy. If 'r' is greater than 'g', than money continuously invested with a rate of return of 'r' will grow faster than 'g', by definition.

Using these definitions of r and g,

How can the return on capital exceed the growth of the economy in the long term?

If the return on capital is so good, governments should invest their pension funds in the stock market and then sit back and relax while all the free money pours in.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by arethuza on Monday April 28, 2014 @07:12AM (#7659186)
I must say that, possibly because of my own background as a reformed AI researcher, that article on "Logical or Connectionist AI?" you refer to there is far more interesting than the original article!

[NB It was probably Drew McDermott's "A Critique of Pure Reason" that fatally damaged my interest in symbolic AI].

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by mrow84 on Monday April 28, 2014 @07:23AM (#7659227)
When you say that he gives "some assorted data suggesting r has historically been bigger than g except when it wasn't, and that inequality grows except when bad things happen", does he make no attempt to correlate his time series of (r - g) with inequality data? If such a correlation was found, that would obviously represent evidence to support his hypothesis.

His claim that I quoted is a causal one, however, as I am sure you are aware, it is very standard practice in all fields of inquiry to propose causal relationships from careful and qualified analyses of correlations. You are of course correct that demonstrating causality would require more than time series analysis, however a lack of causal analysis cannot be taken of itself to invalidate a well-identified correlation (I am of course assuming good faith and rigour on his part, which I am not in a position to attest to at the moment). Contrary data, or an explanation of a mechanism that would induce the identified correlation without the proposed causal relationship should now be sought to invalidate his claims, simply saying that he has only shown correlation is probably not enough.

Finally, could you just explain this a bit more, I didn't quite get it: "If you simply have r > g (ignoring volatility, as he's done so far), and treat capital as homogeneous (as he's mostly done so far), then this will explicitly NOT happen: ..."

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by yummyfajitas on Monday April 28, 2014 @07:46AM (#7659310)
There is no careful analysis. The graphs have basically 3 features: high inequality until the great depression, then low inequality, then inequality rises again. He doesn't have much in the way of graphs of r-g.

Rather than explaining why you need more than just a correlation, I'll link to the Lucas Critique: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucas_critique

Finally, could you just explain this a bit more

Not sure I can explain better than the comment I linked to. If your capital and mine grow at the same rate, we'll have the same ratio of capital forever. I.e., my wealth will be X exp(rt), yours will be Y exp(rt).

This seems to be Piketty's implicit model in most of the book, though once or twice he calls it unrealistic. But he never actually states explicitly what his model is, so it's a bit hard for me to be sure.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by mrow84 on Monday April 28, 2014 @09:02AM (#7659577)
I hadn't heard of the Lucas Critique before, but it seems to be constrained to policy advice that operates on economic variables over which market actors have control, and I'm not sure that applies here - I'll have to think some more.

> Not sure I can explain better than the comment I linked to. ...

Thanks for the clarification, I'm not feeling very switched on at the moment. I would question your analysis though. It is certainly correct on its own terms, however it conflates wealth with capital (which is something I've seen people saying Piketty does - does he?). To me it seems to be vital to include both major sources of income, capital and labour. If you do that, then you can calculate the quantity

(Xl exp(gt) + Xc exp(rt)) / ((Xl + Yl) exp(gt) + (Xc + Yc) exp(rt))

Where Xl and Yl are the labour "holding" for X and Y, and Xc and Yc are the capital holding. Here I'm taking r as the return on capital, and g as the return on labour, which seems abusive but I think it captures the point. This quantity tends to the capital ratio where r > g, and the labour ratio where r < g. Whilst it ends up at the same limit as your model (for r > g), it shows that there is a shift of wealth from labour to capital over time, so the inequality between capital holders and labour "holders" increases over time, as the returns on labour are dominated by the returns on capital.

edit: Just thinking about it a bit more, this implies that we definitely do want g > r, because then in the limit wealth is proportional to labour, i.e. productivity, not to capital bequeathment. One can still make returns on capital, but in the limit your wealth will be proportional to your effort. Surely that is the goal of a meritocratic society?

edit edit: To clarify, I have broader views on the value of pure meritocracy, in my first edit I was just trying to relate the implications of the wealth ratio given above to meritocratic goals.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by yummyfajitas on Monday April 28, 2014 @10:58AM (#7660333)
The Lucas Critique basically just says that if you want to use broad correlations, you should make sure that the microfoundations which drive those correlations still apply.

Unfortunately the relation of r to g tells us very little about meritocratic goals. Suppose that the growth rate r is driven entirely by startup founders building gigantic companies (or lotteries, which would be mathematically equivalent), which cease growing after the founder dies. Then you could have r be huge, inequality would be huge, and everything would be entirely meritocratic.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by mrow84 on Monday April 28, 2014 @11:35AM (#7660631)
I think that the quantity I offered suggests why there might be a correlation between inequality growth and (r - g), independent of the mechanisms that underlie the returns on capital and labour, and inequality. In words, when r > g, the income distribution tends towards the capital distribution, and when r < g the income distribution tends towards the labour distribution.

The relationship between this point and meritocracy is that average returns on capital are approximately "unearned" - you can get close to the market rate of return with minimal effort, whereas returns on labour are positively earned, by your labour. So when r < g the limiting case is for income to match labour, i.e. effort. Note that this by no means inhibits the possibility of greater returns to intelligent capital investment (something that you definitely want to keep) - the point is that you control average returns to stop capital domination fostering inequality.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by foobarqux on Monday April 28, 2014 @08:56AM (#7659546)
Putting aside the fact that limiting processes thousands of years into the future are probably less interesting from an economic perspective than a mathematical one, can you explain why you think r and g must converge?
Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by newblahbl4hblah on Monday April 28, 2014 @07:40AM (#7659284)
It's clear that you dislike the implications of "r > g"...maybe you could explain why?
Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by yummyfajitas on Monday April 28, 2014 @07:51AM (#7659325)
Not sure what to explain. What implications do you believe I dislike?
Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by mseebach on Monday April 28, 2014 @07:17AM (#7659202)
> struck my as the establishment trying to downplay the importance of this book

> the elites are freaking out

It's a good thing we have things like science and open discourse then. Then we can stop "freaking out" over peoples ulterior motives and consider their arguments and the evidence they present supporting their arguments. We can even be open about our motives and ideology driving this, because it's the evidence that counts.

If you discount evidence leveraged against the conclusions of the book because you mistrust the motivation behind giving the evidence, the corollary is that you accept the conclusion of the book, not on the back of the evidence but because you agree with the (supposed) motivation behind reaching those conclusions.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by wonderzombie on Monday April 28, 2014 @12:13PM (#7660881)
If you discount evidence ...

That's reductive. Not everyone has the bandwidth to sort through every iota of evidence. And the fact is that there's no shortage of people who have little in arguing in good faith. So people resort to heuristics such as reputation, credibility, what other "reputable" people say, etc.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by vixin on Monday April 28, 2014 @05:25AM (#7658965)
Your 2nd paragraph: merely your assertion ('freaking out' suggests you're not dispassionate about this). Plenty of rebuttals. A short one to be going on with here: http://www.adamsmith.org/blog/economics/thomas-pikettys-late...
Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by vanderZwan on Monday April 28, 2014 @05:45AM (#7659001)
> Ah, but that story doesn't work. For look at what Piketty is actually saying: the reduction in inequality wasn't as a result of unions, taxation, minimum wages or redistribution. It was simply that growth was faster than the increase in old wealth.

This asserts that these two are entirely unrelated, which is jumping to conclusions at best. Also, a reduction in inequality is a redistribution of wealth by definition, something Piketty points out at the very beginning of his book.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by davidw on Monday April 28, 2014 @05:31AM (#7658974)
Here's another one:

http://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/141218/tyler-cowen/ca...

Ultimately a very political subject though, so I flagged it.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by mjn on Monday April 28, 2014 @05:57AM (#7659027)
While we're at it, another (moderately detailed) critical review, from someone with the opposite political preferences:

http://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/kapital-for-the-twent...

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by DanielBMarkham on Monday April 28, 2014 @05:35AM (#7658982)
Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by _delirium on Monday April 28, 2014 @05:31AM (#7658973)
In what sense is the post you linked a rebuttal? It hints in one parenthetical sentence that the post author has some skepticism about the book's main conclusions (suggesting that Piketty looked insufficiently at consumption inequality), but the author doesn't provide any details.
Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by mattmanser on Monday April 28, 2014 @05:44AM (#7658999)
I'm not sure it's ever worth reading something that contains something along the lines of:

    [author] has a habit of [baseless insult]
It shows the blogger isn't professional and it's pointless reading it.
Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by zo1 on Monday April 28, 2014 @07:40AM (#7659283)
"Piketty has a habit of not looking at consumption inequality which is the thing we might actually be worried about" The actual quote from the article. So people reading your [misleading comment] know that the author didn't actually put a [baseless insult] where you claim he did.
Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by mattmanser on Monday April 28, 2014 @09:14AM (#7659645)
I'm not misleading, it's an accusation of incompetence, every single one of those kind of phrases is attempting to convey just one thing:

hurr, durr, [attack_target]'s too stoopid/misleading you so everything he says is wrong.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by zo1 on Monday April 28, 2014 @04:13PM (#7662648)
So let me get this straight... According to you, having someone analyze and criticize your work, and state so is in fact actually saying "hurr, durr, [attack_target]'s too stoopid"?

And yes, you are misleading. Because if I didn't actually go read that article and find the part you were complaining about I would have assumed an actual insult was where you claimed it was. Whereas, in fact, I found criticism, which the author attempts to justify/backup in the rest of the article. But you'd have us believe that that was all that was in the whole article. That's called misleading people; pretty much general dishonesty on your part.

Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell by adamnemecek on Monday April 28, 2014 @05:53AM (#7659016)
The name of the blog itself suggests that the blog will not be impartial.