Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell
by yummyfajitas on Monday April 28, 2014 @06:42AM
(#7659124)
That's a perfectly valid reason for leaving Asia/Africa out of the 200-year long timeseries. Nevertheless, a discussion of inequality which doesn't even acknowledge the vast gaps between a Yank/Frenchy/Brit and an Indian/Chinese/Nigerian is woefully incomplete almost to the point of dishonesty.
(I say "almost" because I've met enough ignorant westerners to realize that dishonesty is not the only explanation for this. I don't understand it myself, but some people's vision truly does stop at the border. )
Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell
by vanderZwan on Monday April 28, 2014 @06:53AM
(#7659147)
Fair point, but I think we're drifting away from the issue that the book is trying to address, which is the consequence of capitalist economic policy on inequality. Not inequality in general. Of course countries that have different economic policies are very interesting for comparison and to find better ways of addressing the issues with capitalism, but they are not necessary to answer that question.
Re:Piketty’s Capital in a Nutshell
by yummyfajitas on Monday April 28, 2014 @07:17AM
(#7659200)
The effect of capitalistic economic policy has been drastic reductions in global inequality as China/India/others have become wealthier. Immigration (at least in the short run [1]) has even larger effects.
[1] In the long run I'd be concerned about the damage immigrants might do in the voting booth, but that's a non-economic problem.
I'm not even halfway into the book, but he apologises for this at the beginning, especially the focus on France, and gives justifications for this. Simply put, he doesn't have data (yet) for most of the rest of the world. France gets extra attention because it is the country for which he has the most and oldest data, and has had less drastic changes compared to the US, which has grown two orders of magnitude in population in the same time.