News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by dang on Sunday April 27, 2014 @12:47PM (#7655765)
The story is being flagged by users as well as a relatively mild moderation penalty. The penalty makes it go slightly further down the front page; most of the action is by the user flags (edit: which have now buried the story altogether).

This story is a good example—almost a litmus test—of what pg called "shallowly interesting" [1] and what davidw called "articles that get you riled up, but really don't lead to any productive or interesting discussions" [2]. I'm as shocked by the story as anyone, but it's essentially celebrity gossip (for some sort of "celebrity"), and that is off topic for Hacker News. This person is of little importance to this community (how many of us had heard of him before? surely very few), nor do the threads reveal insight into underlying phenomena. They're mostly about what a horrible person he is. So in terms of HN moderation practices, this doesn't seem like a borderline call.

This is not to deny the obvious importance of the story to the people—most importantly the victim—affected by it.

1. http://ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html

2. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7495446

Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by swombat on Sunday April 27, 2014 @12:56PM (#7655812)
Fair enough. Thank you very, very much for your effort at transparency. The above makes sense.
Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by danso on Sunday April 27, 2014 @01:02PM (#7655834)
I think the underlying phenomena is pretty interesting and evident here. Part of the reason why this has blown up, besides the alleged abuse and his eventual guilty plea of course, is an entrepreneur who is drunk on his own Kool-Aid. How else could you explain his ill-informed decision to rant about this, in public, without even a proofreader, even though he's retained the services of high profile PR firms? This is an entrepreneur whose prominence and success was accelerated by the current dynamic in the tech industry, and his rise would be quite admired by most HNers here, especially at his young age, and he's apparently thought that makes him immune to the laws of public outreach and image.

Besides this being a good lesson of how being an asshole is not the ideal way to success...it's also a good example of the machinations of our justice system. Wonder why the rich seem to have better outcomes than the poor? This guy's legal team did great wonders for him. If only his PR team was a bit better, he may be still CEO (deservedly or not).

Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by dang on Sunday April 27, 2014 @01:31PM (#7655940)
I didn't say there weren't interesting underlying phenomena, only that the HN threads don't reveal insight into them—and if I may, I think your attempt here, though well-intentioned, mostly reinforces that. Every sentence strikes me as projecting way beyond the available information.
Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by pbreit on Sunday April 27, 2014 @01:29PM (#7655932)
I disagree with most of the points made in the second paragraph.

I also think moderation should be used more in moderation.

Re:CEO Gurbaskh Chahal Fired by RadiumOne Board by buro9 on Sunday April 27, 2014 @01:46PM (#7656001)
> The story is being flagged by users as well as a relatively mild moderation penalty.

This is fine.

I don't necessarily agree with the 2nd paragraph as this is merely an update to an ongoing story that does have some importance given it's context within the current efforts to have the startup world and programming be a more equal place.

I know that comment points have been hidden, and largely I think that works really well, but is there any chance that the stories could have some indication made public when they become subject to a moderation penalty.

Simply, if you could let people know why things appear to change place wildly outside of the params of the position algorithm then people would know that this was a result of community intent rather than any kind of interference. A bit like Slashdot's comment level "-5 Offtopic", but for stories.