http://mozakai.blogspot.co.at/2013/05/the-elusive-universal-...
I'm even getting worse startup times for a "cold start" for the same code compiled to native OSX then for starting the same demo as emscripten version, (presumably because the native version first needs to load a lot of DLLs).
I can take PNaCL today and deploy it on alternative stacks, irrespective of the web stack. I can inter-operate cleanly with alternative libraries and environments, I can adopt efficient host platform ABIs, I can run it with a sandbox or without. I could even use it as a generic cross-platform sandboxed in-kernel driver layer.
Moreover, should NaCL/PNaCL be successful, there exists the possibility for optimization on the silicon-level via the introduction of new instruction sets that optimize for in-process sandboxing of untrusted code, much in the same way that trap-and-emulate VMs led to much higher performing silicon-implementations of the same ideas.
Issues of performance can be solved given a well-designed system that applies only as much complexity as is needed, at the level that it is needed. asm.js is a hack inserted at an inappropriate layer of the technology stack; NaCL/PNaCL is a coherent compositionally-sane design that opens the door to later optimizations and significant improvements of the underlying technologies on which it rests.
Shoe horning technologies into roles they weren't intended for could describe the entire scope of why the Web sucks (e.g.: HTML mixing presentation with semantics).
Now-a-days that "thing" is "javascript" and it has implementation nuances that depend on browser/runtime environment.
In theory you could use Javascript as that thing, but it wouldn't be very efficient. On the other hand, what you could do is create a compiler that compiles to both bytecode and Javascript, and then give the Javascript to older browsers that don't support bytecode yet.