News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by cloudwalking on Friday April 25, 2014 @02:06PM (#7648101)
- Successful soft landing in the Atlantic

- Seas were too rough for a quick recovery

- Rocket subsequently destroyed by wave action

- Will attempt recovery of the next Falcon 9 launch

- A Falcon 9 recovered on land could be re-used the next day (!)

- SpaceX is lobbying to allow private competition for National Security launches (eg GPS satellites)

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by chidevguy on Friday April 25, 2014 @02:46PM (#7648349)
My jaw dropped reading that the rocket could be re-used the next day. That seems like an enormous leap forward for space flight.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by grinich on Friday April 25, 2014 @02:56PM (#7648401)
Rockets are built to be pretty durable machines (obviously). The environment they operate in outside of the atmosphere is harsher in many ways.

Two big issues with sea landing: transport (tug, crane, huge truck, etc.), and corrosion/contamination from saltwater.

They'll still need to verify all systems and components before a second launch, but that's way easier to do when the vehicle is sitting empty on the pad next to all your people and equipment.

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by mkempe on Friday April 25, 2014 @03:39PM (#7648616)
This was an experiment. The goal is to land on terra firma, not [mare incognitum].
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by mapt on Saturday April 26, 2014 @07:59PM (#7653245)
For Falcon 9 though, the first stage contributes so much of the dV that it is not particularly feasible to land it at the launch site - by the time it separates, it's moving at several kilometers per second away from the launch site towards the horizon. That opens up the question of where the launch/landing site pair is bound to be. A ship-based landing system, such as a semisubmersible oil drilling rig (only ~$1B used!) with a landing pad built onto it, would seem to be close to optimal for the F9 specifically.

The Falcon Heavy's 2 side boosters, on the other hand, will separate much earlier in the flight - they are likely to be much more practical to land at the launch site, particularly for direct geosynchronous payloads that allow a lot more vertical / near-vertical burn time in relation to horizontal.

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by grinich on Saturday April 26, 2014 @11:54PM (#7653887)
Citation? Usually the flight plan is to increase altitude (less atmospheric drag) before increasing angular velocity to full orbit.

Elon's been pretty explicit that F9 stage 1 will land back on the pad, or very close by.

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by mapt on Sunday April 27, 2014 @10:36PM (#7657963)
See this thread for estimates on the dV of the different stages of these launch platforms for a full-capacity payload: http://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=30685.0;all

It costs about 8km/s to get into low orbit from an atmosphere-less Earth. From our planet it costs about 9.4-1.0km/s because of aerodynamic and gravity losses. Those aerodynamic and gravity costs, and the Hohmann Transfer from groundlevel to orbit (trivial for LEO, more for GTO) are the only parts of the equation one can address while burning vertically to stay over the launch site.

Assuming 10, If the first stage only has to contribute 2km/s, it can address aerodynamic and gravity losses (while thrusting vertically), and then leave the second stage to boost for the horizon and achieve full orbit all on its own.

At 4-5km/s first stage contribution, it doesn't look like this is possible unless the payload is very undersized, leaving the second stage with enough dV to go from 'rising out of the upper atmosphere vertically' to 'circular orbit' all on its own.

The mass is a free variable, a greater vertical component is practical in GTO (and I don't have the modelling skills to say how much), and the second stage may launch fully fueled for F9R contra to the existing pattern, so I can't be 100% sure whether F9R will be a practical return-to-launchsite option for lightweight GTO payloads.

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by HarryHirsch on Friday April 25, 2014 @03:22PM (#7648529)
They'll still need to verify all systems and components before a second launch

That. You need to re-qualify the engine after each launch. The cost of labour far exceeds the cost of materials, you need to strip and re-build the thing, and you ask yourself just how much money you can save through re-using the first stage. I don't think it's much.

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by grinich on Friday April 25, 2014 @04:46PM (#7648949)
On traditional launch vehicles, yes. Shuttle was definitely this way. And I'm sure SpaceX will initially do a complete disassemble and inspection to gather more data about the wear and tear.

But the Merlin engines have been designed from the start to be reusable and dependably reignitable, whether at sea level or upper atmosphere. They're pretty amazing-- essentially the pinnacle of +50 years of engine design. Tom Mueller is a huge badass. :) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merlin_(rocket_engine)

And check out that bad boy roar: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wkdReoxGHG8

I don't have a link on hand, but Elon has said multiple times that the majority cost of the Falcon-9 is the raw material. One of the reasons they've been able to drop the price significantly is by using more efficient manufacturing techniques, requiring less material and creating less waste. (e.g. stir-friction welding)

It's also worth noting that Falcon-9 can still complete a mission with one (and perhaps two?) engine failures, which gives quite a more comfortable margin of error. There's a big difference between "perfect" and "near perfect" when it comes to engineering these things. ;)

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by jessriedel on Friday April 25, 2014 @03:53PM (#7648686)
> I don't think it's much.

SpaceX disagrees. They expect to cut the cost of launch by 1 order of magnitude

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_reusable_launch_system_...

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by ef4 on Friday April 25, 2014 @05:11PM (#7649060)
> you need to strip and re-build the thing

That's how politically-designed boondoggles like the shuttle work. It's not inevitable, if you actually spend the engineering effort on reliability and repeatability.

If NASA operated an airline, they would probably be tearing down and rebuilding every jet engine after every flight, and a ticket would cost $100,000.

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by XorNot on Friday April 25, 2014 @05:49PM (#7649228)
I said this in another thread, but part of the issue is failure intolerance.

Sure - for human payloads I'd want to be damn sure my process is good, like, hundreds to thousands of missions deep before I trusted it.

But that's totally unnecessary for an unmanned payload! If the cost of launch drops enough, you can fully justify launching 2x the payloads if you expect maybe 1 in 10 failures due to the mode of launch.

I suspect it's possible to do a damn site better then that, but for NASA its never been an option. If it's reusable, they can't let a mission fail because they'll only get punished and funded according to the failures, even if they specced everything expecting 1 mission to possibly not go off right.

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by 001sky on Friday April 25, 2014 @06:25PM (#7649432)
This is true for a sub-set of unmanned payloads.

Space-X is great for the sub-set of things that don't require insurance, and don't therefore need to use corner-case mil-spec stuff with the corner case pricing.

For others, the cost of losing a $1-2B bird on top of a $100m/cheap rocket is shitty math. Nobody is going to insure the top of it, so ultimately the "waste" is akin to a form of insurance.

Everybody knows this already, so I'm not sure how sympathetic a hearing it is going to get. It will be great PR though to hopefully spurn <designs> that fit the new framework...and thus expand the market for space-x and hopefully limit the superflous use of corner-case technology for mundane/run-of the mill applications (at the tax payer's expense).

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by XorNot on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:35PM (#7650175)
Right, but part of the reason we launch hugely expensive satellites is because launching a rocket is hugely expensive.

That calculus changes if your rocket launches start to get cheaper. It changes by a lot if your rocket launches have reasonable but predictable failure modes - which is something you get from volume.

As it is, rocket launches are relatively infrequent and expensive - which means its impossible to figure out the amortization of costs, and its not worth building a 10m satellite if your launch costs 100m (since if you can raise the latter, you can almost certainly get more for a better satellite too).

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by 001sky on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:58PM (#7650246)
^^^ Yes, this is exactly the 'white space' for Space-X.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by ef4 on Sunday April 27, 2014 @11:18AM (#7655393)
The $2B satellite is equally absurd, and only costs that much for the same reasons that the launch costs $400M. Everything is bespoke and produced in the maximal number of congressional districts, with no meaningful competitive pressure to drive prices downward.

And the two expenses buoy each other: if launches were inexpensive, you could spend a lot less on fault-tolerance in the payloads, because you could just launch a lot more payloads or even support on-orbit repair infrastructure.

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by rjurney on Friday April 25, 2014 @09:15PM (#7650014)
You really think SpaceX loads aren't insured? This seems impossible.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by HarryHirsch on Friday April 25, 2014 @09:49PM (#7650083)
If you look at previous launches of new designs you will see that the first few flights are invariably not commercial, they carry research spacecraft. These are the qualification flights; until the vehicle has a good track record the satellite operator won't find anyone to insure their bird.

Now the Falcon 9 is an all-new design, and their track record isn't all that shiny - there is a history of missing the target orbit by a fairly significant margin. It's going to be downvoted, but it had to be said.

I wouldn't be surprised if this flight went without insurance.

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by mapt on Saturday April 26, 2014 @07:52PM (#7653221)
Missing the target orbit by a significant margin on all their 9 flights?

Or having their failsafe system activated after one of their engines blew up on a single mission, causing them to be in position to release the small secondary payload (which the customer did not particularly need in free flight apparently) slightly late, in a zone in which NASA had veto rights on due to proximity to the ISS. Rather than adjusting their orbit to deposit the secondary payload in the proper orbit, as is technologically feasible, NASA exercised their contractual veto and told them to drop it early.

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by lotsofmangos on Friday April 25, 2014 @08:12PM (#7649874)
SpaceX appear to have gone with failure tolerance. Their first stage is practically a raid array.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by sitkack on Friday April 25, 2014 @07:14PM (#7649673)
Teardown and rebuild doesn't increase your safety margins, they reduce it. If I rebuilt my Toyota every 10k miles I'd have a lot more breakdowns.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by cfreeman on Friday April 25, 2014 @04:28PM (#7648866)
The Merlin engine was designed from the beginning to be re-useable. They don't have to be "stripped and rebuilt" after each launch. They have already fired engines on the test stand for multiple mission durations with no problems.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by oh_sigh on Friday April 25, 2014 @04:46PM (#7648948)
So, have you done more analysis on this than SpaceX has?

You should send them this post of yours so they stop wasting all that money! I bet they never thought of what you said.

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by mikeash on Friday April 25, 2014 @04:01PM (#7648723)
Unlike NASA's adventures with the space shuttle, SpaceX is a for-profit business with a goal of making money. They wouldn't be pursuing reusability if they didn't think it would increase their ability to make a profit.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by smackfu on Friday April 25, 2014 @04:46PM (#7648953)
I would think inspecting, cleaning, and assembling the stack would take days. So next-day is probably Musk hyperbole.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by SoftwareMaven on Friday April 25, 2014 @06:33PM (#7649477)
People constantly say this about him, yet he consistently comes through on what he says. I tend to favor trusting what he says about things like this now.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by redthrowaway on Friday April 25, 2014 @02:25PM (#7648209)
Is "the ocean was wavy" really a justifiable reason for losing the rocket? Surely sea conditions are something they'd take into account when planning and executing the mission.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by lutusp on Friday April 25, 2014 @02:39PM (#7648300)
You clearly have not been at sea, close to the water. A cylindrical object, without a sea anchor, in moderately rough seas, would naturally turn sideways to the waves and be destroyed very quickly in the breaking waves.

I don't know whether SpaceX has fitted their boosters with sea anchors yet, but I wouldn't be surprised to see this addition after the present loss. In windy conditions, a sea anchor provides some drag and keeps the boat (or booster) pointed perpendicular to the waves, thereby minimizing the force expended on the object.

> Surely sea conditions are something they'd take into account when planning and executing the mission.

Ocean experts are constantly preparing for extreme conditions, then discovering they didn't prepare for conditions that were extreme enough.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rogue_wave

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by keehun on Friday April 25, 2014 @06:00PM (#7649282)
How much weight would be such an anchor to hold down something as large as a rocket? Wouldn't you have to launch that into space, too?
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by lutusp on Friday April 25, 2014 @07:30PM (#7649746)
A sea anchor is a pretty lightweight device whose purpose is to create some drag against the water when the wind blows. It can take the shape of a small parachute, but in the water, at the end of a long line. The idea is when the wind blows, endangering the booster, the sea anchor will force the booster to point directly into the wind, thus minimizing wave damage.

> Wouldn't you have to launch that into space, too?

Yes, which is definitely a drawback -- every ounce that isn't payload is regarded as a serious waste, because it all has to be launched at great cost (the ratio of payload to fuel is often greater than ten to one).

On the other hand, the SpaceX people report that the booster was destroyed, so this well-tested idea is very likely in their minds right now.

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by lmm on Friday April 25, 2014 @07:15PM (#7649680)
Sea anchor, i.e. something like a parachute that drags through the water, so it can be made of light materials.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by ericcumbee on Friday April 25, 2014 @11:58PM (#7650386)
Probably not going to happen since the ultimate goal is return to launch site.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by lutusp on Saturday April 26, 2014 @04:31AM (#7650782)
Yes, that's the goal, a descent to land instead of water. One hopes SpaceX will be granted permission to move ahead with that scheme instead of having to perform more tests into water.

I'm sure there are safety concerns that have prevented this until now. The successful retro-file to zero velocity over water may help resolve those concerns.

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by DanielStraight on Friday April 25, 2014 @02:27PM (#7648227)
The mission was to launch the satellite they were being paid to launch. Recovery of the rocket was a test they were running on the side. The mission justifiably got priority.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by mikeash on Friday April 25, 2014 @03:00PM (#7648430)
It's strange how many people seem unable to understand this. SpaceX got a bunch of testing essentially for free. NASA was gracious to allow it. They could have easily said, "We're paying you to launch stuff to ISS, keep those crazy landing legs far away from our payload."

Sea conditions were too rough for recovery. Their options were to wait for better weather, annoying the customer and possibly losing the launch (they had one more launch window after the one they used before the payload went to another launch company), or go for it and still accomplish a great deal of testing even though they probably couldn't recover the rocket. Total no-brainer to choose the second option.

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by kristofferR on Friday April 25, 2014 @03:23PM (#7648536)
NASA isn't stupid, they know that if SpaceX manages to get rocket reusability they'll save a lot of money which would otherwise be spent on rocket launches.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by clarky07 on Saturday April 26, 2014 @01:22AM (#7650532)
On the other hand, it probably just means their budget will be cut by a similar amount. NASA isn't a for profit company. It's tax payer funded. No guarantees they really benefit much from saving money.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by mikeash on Friday April 25, 2014 @04:03PM (#7648734)
Of course. But in the short term, they have a bunch of cargo that needs to get to the ISS soon, and they weren't in a position to tolerate many more delays.

It goes beyond NASA as well. If SpaceX can demonstrate that their reusability testing doesn't impact the launch, that increases the odds that their other customers will allow it on their launches too.

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by jack-r-abbit on Friday April 25, 2014 @02:34PM (#7648269)
Is "recover an un-manned rocket" really a justifiable reason for potentially losing lives at sea?
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by lutusp on Friday April 25, 2014 @02:40PM (#7648312)
Not really. Which may explain why (according to one report) the Coast Guard refused to go out after the booster.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by venomsnake on Friday April 25, 2014 @02:29PM (#7648241)
Well Mashable said that the Coast Guard refused to go out. So it was probably wavy slightly above it is awesome for surfing.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by derekp7 on Friday April 25, 2014 @05:15PM (#7649082)
Just to be clear, it is not their goal to reuse rockets that are soft-landed in the ocean. This particular attempt was to prove that they could make the rocket slow to zero meters/sec at the surface of the ocean, with it upright. Which they did.

Their next attempt will be to target a smaller radius, to prove their aiming accuracy. Finally, after a couple more ocean landings (with possible recovery for analysis purposes), they will attempt to land on dry ground. To do this, they need to prove they can set down within a 1-mile radius. But they believe they should have the same precision of a helicopter.

After this, they are aiming for same-day reusability.

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by syncsynchalt on Friday April 25, 2014 @06:31PM (#7649465)
Rockets are surprisingly fragile when empty. Most of their strength is compressive, and only in one direction, and only when filled with compressed gas.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by robryk on Friday April 25, 2014 @07:50PM (#7649811)
I'm not sure about strength being mostly compressive -- for example, Apollo 9's Saturn V withstood a longitudinal oscillation with an amplitude of 12g[1] and it wasn't deemed to be dangerous enough to cause an abort.

I'd expect maintaining pressure in the tanks not to be a significant problem, though it would need to be addressed -- pressure needs to be maintained reasonably constant during the whole burn, and it's done by admitting helium from compressed helium tanks. If the fuel/oxidizer tanks don't leak too much, the same mechanism could be used after the rocket has landed.

[1] http://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/2008001...

Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by freehunter on Friday April 25, 2014 @02:29PM (#7648242)
It's certainly possible that they have a level of wave action that they can handle, and this landing's wave conditions exceeded that. I'd imagine it's hard to predict what the ocean will be like far enough in advance to design a rocket from the ground up to support heavier wave action. They were on NASA's timeline for the launch, not their own.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by lotsofmangos on Friday April 25, 2014 @02:44PM (#7648342)
The launch window was being dictated by factors other than the landing weather and storms in the Atlantic are a justifiable reason for losing pretty much anything you care to put in them.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by beachstartup on Friday April 25, 2014 @02:39PM (#7648305)
hmm, an armchair rocket scientist... don't think i've seen that one before.
Re:SpaceX Successfully Soft-Landed Booster Rocket in the Atl... by freehunter on Friday April 25, 2014 @03:26PM (#7648551)
How many thousands (millions?) of people play Kerbal Space Program? Obviously that qualifies as a rocket scientist/