News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by nailer on Friday April 25, 2014 @09:16AM (#7646199)
Social is a flavor enhancer, like salt. It's a great flavor enhancer, but you don't want to eat it on it's own.

Social + news = Facebook wall

Social + location = Foursquare

Social + YouTube = Better YouTube comments. Sorry, but it does

Social + Search = Knowing that when I search for a thing, I mean the one my friend likes, not the similarly named one he doesn't.

Social + Maps = Seeing that my friend goes to this restaurant and likes it.

Social + video calling = A phone directory and avatars.

FB Platform is the biggest thing FB produce. But their most widely end user app is wall, which sits on their platform.

As someone who never, ever, logs into plus.google.com, I still know I use gplus all the time from finding new cafes in London. It's a super great flavor enhancer.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by bruceboughton on Friday April 25, 2014 @09:44AM (#7646361)
>> Social + Search = Knowing that when I search for a thing, I mean the one my friend likes, not the similarly named one he doesn't.

This is where Google have gone wrong. I don't want my search results to be affected by signals from my friends. They don't search for the same things as me.

I want my search results to be ranked with signals from other relevant people... and I don't know who these people are.

Google got it right first time around. PageRank captures the link juice from these relevant people. C# bloggers linking to open source projects. F1 fans linking to interesting articles. Apple bloggers linking to rumours.

Google+ puts the onus on me to decide who is relevant and I don't know. Using this as signal for searching is making me do Google's job.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by watwut on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:21AM (#7646599)
Exactly. I'm not my friends and my friends are often very different then me. They often listen different music or play different games.

I do not even want search results and suggestions to be ranked by previous signals from me, especially as it was implemented on youtube. I use them to find new things and styles, not to close myself into some ghetto defined by whatever I searched for first few weeks. I got curious about, say, folk songs and spend a week searching and watching them. It was temporary thing, but youtube insisted on suggesting them even as I was watching trance video two weeks later.

When I want to see what I seen before, I search by name or use bookmarks. When I want to see what my friend like, I ask them or look at facebook. Search is for when I look for something new.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by bad_user on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:03AM (#7646488)
I wanted to say exactly that. My friends are not like me. Even the friends I have that are software developers are not interested in the same things. Heck, even the people I work directly with aren't interested in the same things.

> I want my search results to be ranked with signals from other relevant people... and I don't know who these people are.

This is were you're partially wrong. Personally I know many people that I'd like to be included in my search ranking as signals. The problem is - those people are only a subset of the people that I follow on Twitter or Google+.

The problem with "Follow" or "Add as Friend" or whatever these social networks are calling it - is that some people are more interesting than others. Some people I follow simply because they are my friends. While other people I follow because I'm interested in whatever they've got to say. And this is the problem that Google should solve.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by digisth on Friday April 25, 2014 @11:39AM (#7647151)
I wonder if adding an "authoritativeness/trust" rank to each user you follow would help with this. Whenever you'd add someone on a social network, you'd be asked to choose a number between 1-5 or something that tells the SN's recommendation system how much weight they should be given when choosing stories to show you or whatever.
Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by RivieraKid on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:00AM (#7646477)
> Social + Search

Yeah, I've never understood why Google was stressing social search so much, there's almost zero value in that.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by rokhayakebe on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:57AM (#7646886)
Every decision you make is affected by others; if not your friends & family, your colleagues, people who share a similar interest, etc... Perhaps no one has nailed it yet, but Search is Social.
Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by RivieraKid on Friday April 25, 2014 @12:22PM (#7647420)
> Every decision you make is affected by others

That's not true.

But every decision you make is affected by your mood. They should add an option to select your mood to the top right corner of every Google website.

> Search is Social

What does that even mean? This sounds like some stupid, mindless, PR crap.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by nailer on Friday April 25, 2014 @11:26AM (#7647075)
> This is where Google have gone wrong. I don't want my search results to be affected by signals from my friends. They don't search for the same things as me.

I get what you mean. But if I search for an solution for something StackOverflow-ish, it'd be be great to see JS results (98% of my coding friends) rather than, say .net results (only a handful of people).

A non-social search would merely show whatever answer had been around and popular enough to get the most pagerank.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by sp332 on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:05AM (#7646498)
You can turn it off if you don't use it that way.
Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by ithkuil on Friday April 25, 2014 @09:49AM (#7646409)
yep, it would be nice at least if you could decide which circles contain relevant people to your interests (including ∅)
Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by thaumasiotes on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:27AM (#7646644)
> Social + Maps = Seeing that my friend goes to this restaurant and likes it.

How would that be relevant to me? I want to know that someone who likes other restaurants I like goes to this restaurant and likes it. I don't care what restaurants my friend likes. We're not friends on the basis of liking the same restaurants.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by vidarh on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:43AM (#7646765)
While I agree with you that it's more interesting to get recommendation based on similar users, most people have a reasonable idea how their friends tastes in various things mesh with their own.

I know that a particular friend of mine is equally picky about his steaks as me, for example, and I'd trust a recommendation of steak houses from him.

Being able to attach a particular name to recommendations helps them attach a level of trust to the recommendation that regular users might be less inclined to attach to "anonymous" recommendations.

If they're smart, they'll also consider similarity in tastes when deciding which of your friends recommendations to emphasise (especially if more than one of your friends have clashing ratings of the same places).

Social recommendations also helps you "break out" of the filter bubble.

E.g. Amazon has a very specific view of what I like to read, and so on. But people who know me will occasionally be able to provide me with other impulses that leads me to try something entirely new that is very different from what Amazon will recommend to me based on what I've read in the past.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by unreal37 on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:50AM (#7646825)
What if all they did was mark the restaurants your friends have liked, not changed the search results order? So it's just an attribute. It could have SOME value.
Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by hagbardgroup on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:37AM (#7646729)
A lot of 'work' friends may have garbage taste in restaurants. Exactly.
Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by espadrine on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:39AM (#7646739)
Social + YouTube = comments. Whether they are good depends on the implementation and design.

In this particular case, the fact that G+ posts appeared as YouTube comments meant that every comment of a viral G+ video post showed up in YouTube as a series of introductions to the video, instead of… well… comments on it.

Here is a quick example, although it isn't by far the most striking; it is the first I had around.

http://i.imgur.com/LCMxwuN.png

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by m0nty on Friday April 25, 2014 @09:44AM (#7646360)
> like salt. It's a great flavor enhancer

I wish there were a way to get my food unsalted.

> Now that they have the platform they need, they're pushing social integration into all of their features, literally pushing people who know how to do social into every nook and cranny of Google

And "literally" pushing users into adopting it, regardless. I prefer the TechCrunch interpretation (G+ is dead) because for one brief moment, I had hope -- but I suspect OP is more correct.

Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by dfc on Friday April 25, 2014 @10:20AM (#7646594)

  video calling + Social = A phone directory and avatars.
  video calling - Social = Animated selfies
Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by paul_f on Friday April 25, 2014 @09:26AM (#7646258)
Essentially "social" is a feature, not a product.
Re:TechCrunch covered Vic Gundotra's departure badly by threeseed on Friday April 25, 2014 @09:49AM (#7646407)
Comments would be the feature. Social is just an adjective.