Not by itself, no; the government can still get to you by getting access to the machine you host it on, or the switch the mail flows through on its way in and out from the outside world. Hosting your own just reduces the number of third parties the government can try to shake down to get access to your data.
In other words, what's the difference between buying email service from GoDaddy and renting a VPS from them to host it yourself?
Not being critical at all, just trying to understand if there's something fundamentally different about Mail in a Box that makes it more government-secure than other approaches. The description seems to list privacy from government snooping as the primary motivator. Is it truly effective at that? If so, why and how?
As I understand things the very idea of being secure from snooping is an illusion so long as your email is on a machine that you don't physically control in your home or office. And, even then, the best you can do is encrypt all traffic to make it more difficult --not impossible-- to capture your data.
Am I wrong?
In order to escape mass surveilance this is most likely enough. As all you have to do is to be different.
If you think you are actually "target" by a goverment youv'e got bigger problems. And you should probably stay away from email alltogether.
I do have a question:
Does hosting your own email truly isolate you from government surveillance?
If a million people use this to host their own email on AWS, what's to keep the NSA from ordering Amazon to tap into your data?
You almost have to host it on your own hardware in the garage in order to add a significant layer of isolation. Even with that in place there are ways to access your communications through your ISP. Harder, not impossible.
What's reality?