On formatting, gofmt is awesome. There's an IDE called LiteIDE which automatically calls gofmt for you, or you can just run it yourself whenever. Additionally, because there's deliberately no room to customize gofmt, you don't have to spend time in pointless meetings when "that guy" decides it's time to rewrite your company eclipse templates and argue over all the minutiae.
As far as refactoring, nobody's built an IDE integration that comes close to eclipse/IDEA for that as far as I know. It's totally doable in Go, in a way that it wouldn't be for Python (yay types), but I don't think anyone's done it. On the upside, doing it manually is less painful than it would be in typical Java code, due to type inference and having less code to begin with.
[1] https://github.com/DisposaBoy/GoSublime
The reformatting is actually quite aggressive (it will add/remove blanks and move braces and bits of code around), and so does a good job of keeping everybody's code looking consistent. The Visual Studio text editing functionality only occasionally reaches even the lofty heights of "pretty good", but I do think the document reformatting actually even exceeds that.
(Shame the settings are are per-user rather than per-project, but there you go. It wouldn't be Visual Studio if they didn't manage to fuck something up at the last moment.)
For example,
or on emacs, if you use the packaged go-mode.el, you can run gofmt on the "before-save-hook" to do that for you...
Of those, I only see comprehensions as something that's severely lacking, though I am not a Python guru by any measure. Dynamic typing: Go has duck typing, which gives some of the same benefits. Different refactoring strategies that take advantage of duck typing over other things you'd do with dynamic languages (like just substituting an object of a different type willy-nilly) will probably make up for the rest. I don't see strong support for literal data as a big productivity gain. Go also does a rather good job of treating user defined types like the built-ins and vice-versa, with a few exceptions like maps.
I didn't experience the claims of "Go is just as good as Python for prototyping", as someone with a fair amount of Python experience.
A lot of your competence with Python for prototyping probably has to do with your competence with Python. A lot of the advantage of Go is what it doesn't have. It's a much simpler system, so it's easier to design around, especially as one needs to get closer to the metal.
Python just hands you back a dict of lists, and you pull out the information you want, no type declarations needed.
The "user-defined types like built-ins" lets you build libraries where you can use the basic language structures on the data structure itself, without having to convert to an intermediate form. For example, the Python bindings to Amazon S3 let you access files through dictionary notation. BeautifulSoup lets you iterate over child nodes with a for loop, or access attributes as a dict. NumPy lets you use standard arithmetic operators on matrices. Judicious use of this in libraries makes the resulting code much briefer.
> I was decoding a large JSON data structure that could
> easily have thousands of different fields nested 10+
> levels deep. Go's standard json library usually
> recommends that you define a struct type to hold the
> result of the decode, tagging field names with the
> `json` annotation. This obviously doesn't work when you
> only care about a few dozen of the several thousand
> possible fields.
Sure it does! type Response struct {
LevelOne map[string]struct{
LevelTwo map[int]struct{
Value string `json:"eventual_value"`
} `json:"level_two"`
} `json:"level_one"`
}
The response can have way more fields than just the ones you declare in your struct. response['level_one']['level_two']['eventual_value']
?I did ignore fields that I wasn't interested in; however, you do at least have to declare all the intermediate structs in the tree. With 10-ish levels of nesting, that's a lot of boilerplate; even in your example with 3 levels, you've still got 6 lines of code for what's a one-liner in Python.
It wouldn't be as much of a problem for a production system where you define your data structures once and then expect to amortize them over many, many changes. But I was prototyping, and the point of prototyping is to not spend time on boilerplate that isn't necessary to prove out your concept. A few hundred lines of type declarations just so I could decode JSON isn't exactly convenient.
But, at your insistence, we can keep digging. It's easy to write a polymorphic function that arbitrarily picks out values from a Go `interface{}` value.
func lookup(v interface{}, keys ...string) interface{} {
switch len(keys) {
case 0: return v
default:
dict, ok := v.(map[string]interface{})
if !ok {
panic(fmt.Sprintf("%T is not a dictionary", v))
}
return lookup(dict[keys[0]], keys[1:]...)
}
}
And then we can use it like you would in Python: lookup(response, "level_one", "level_two", "eventual_value")
This doesn't completely remove the burden of type asserting (unfortunate), but it at least makes nested lookups much easier. Arguably, the nested lookups are probably where the type asserts hurt the most.Full example: http://play.golang.org/p/4tWtqGRgU6
Yeah, prototyping with JSON is one place where dynamic languages are more nimble.
For example, the Python bindings to Amazon S3 let you access files through dictionary notation. BeautifulSoup lets you iterate over child nodes with a for loop, or access attributes as a dict. NumPy lets you use standard arithmetic operators on matrices. Judicious use of this in libraries makes the resulting code much briefer.
Yes, this is another specific area where dynamic languages do prototyping better and can produce shorter code. I did an exercise where someone implemented a routine in Clojure that I had written in Python. The Python was shorter! In part, this was due to list comprehensions. In part, it was due to an excellent library. What you describe is what many Smalltalkers did as well: create your own control structures and DSLs.
I've sometimes wondered what could be done with a dynamic superset language of Go, such that one could mostly add type definitions and compile to Go.
It should be simple enough to implement a dynamic JSON parsing DSL in Go. It would be slower and memory inefficient, but much more convenient for rapid development.
Go doesn't have a REPL and that is objectively a serious dent on effective prototyping.
Gofmt is actually one of my favorite parts about go and I feel that it, along with the simple documentation system and godoc.org save me a ton of time making my code ready for others to read/use.
The code base behind gofmt and gofix can also be used for other tools, i haven't felt the need for a powerful refactoring tool but I'm sure one will show up eventually.
I do miss list comprehensions and operator overloading but I understand the dev's arguments against those.
It's slightly annoying to setup, but absolutely worth it.
One thing I really missed when I abandoned the Java world and went to C++/Python was the refactoring and formatting tools available in the IDE. I could set it up so it'd auto-format my code on save, so that I could rename methods with a single keystroke, so that I could pull out classes or add getters/setters, so that I could add parameters, etc. I know Go supports some of that through gofmt and go fix, but I'm curious if anyone is both an experienced Java dev and an experienced Go dev and can compare the continued maintenance costs of the two.
BTW, I would put the productivity premium of Go over Python at about 50%-2x, not 10%. I did a mid-size (~6 man-months, though much of that time went into interactions with other teams) green-field prototype in Go at Google, and found myself really missing constructs like list comprehensions, dynamic typing, strong support for literal data, ability to treat user-defined types just like the built-ins, etc. I do think you'll make some of that back in continued maintenance - I actually really enjoyed working with Go - but I didn't experience the claims of "Go is just as good as Python for prototyping", as someone with a fair amount of Python experience.