News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Xkcd is wrong about "free speech" by jessaustin on Friday April 18, 2014 @10:13PM (#7612298)
The Citizens' Councils used economic tactics against African Americans whom they considered as supportive of desegregation and voting rights, or for belonging to the NAACP; the tactics included "calling in" their mortgages, denying loans and business credit, and boycotting black-owned businesses. In some cities, the Councils published lists of names of NAACP supporters and signers of anti-segregation petitions in local newspapers in order to encourage economic retaliation. For instance, in Yazoo City, Mississippi in 1955, the Citizens' Council arranged for the names of 53 signers of a petition for school integration to appear in a local paper. Soon afterward, the petitioners lost their jobs and had their credit cut off.

-- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_Citizens%27_Councils

Re:Xkcd is wrong about "free speech" by dfc on Friday April 18, 2014 @10:42PM (#7612391)
What is your point?
Re:Xkcd is wrong about "free speech" by BrandonMarc on Saturday April 19, 2014 @01:13AM (#7612660)
I believe the point is the actions above "smell like" attacks on a certain group of people's right to speech and assembly ... even though it wasn't the government doing these things, and even though these things were legal at the time (I assume).

It may be legal for me to harass, intimidate or silence my opponents, since I am not the government ... but it's certainly not in the spirit of promoting free discourse on ideas, which free-speech-loving Americans are all generally in favor of. (or think they are)

Re:Xkcd is wrong about "free speech" by dfc on Saturday April 19, 2014 @01:52AM (#7612713)
So essentially "Here is an arbitrary selection of evil in the pre-CRA'64 south." With such a long list of shameful events I guess I was expecting "This event is particularly relevant to the discussion because..."
Re:Xkcd is wrong about "free speech" by makomk on Saturday April 19, 2014 @06:37AM (#7613118)
It's relevant in the sense it demonstrates who benefits and loses out as the result of this narrow view of "free speech". Taking "free speech" to mean only freedom from government restrictions and and making it the norm not to criticise non-government restrictions on speech benefits the powerful at the expense of the less powerful. Constitutionally, those African Americans had just as much right to carry out economic retaliation against racists as vice-versa, but in practice they were in no position to do so.

This doesn't just apply to evil in the pre-CRA south either. A less dramatic example of this is online feminist communities - all the popular ones have systematically excluded women of colour, trans women, etc, often deleting any criticism of the fact they've done so. (This is also why the hover text is frankly offensive. It doesn't matter how good your arguments are if no-one hears them - many did have arguments other than "free speech", but as far as the rest of the community knew they didn't because the community owners said they didn't.) It took until the rise of so-called "Twitter feminism" that wasn't controlled by a particular community owner before those women could get their voices heard online, and even now I think there's some pressure on Twitter to shut them up again.