My Dad was recently complaining that his prescription coverage was cut, so he was now paying about $100/mo for his prescriptions. I asked how much the pills would cost with no coverage, and he dug out the bills and determined they would cost about $600/mo. This sounds outrageous I suppose, until you realize that he pays about $1100/mo for insurance. Granted, that is for more than just drugs, but if insurance was really for unaffordable things, it wouldn't cost that much. My dad is still paying for his monthly prescriptions... just in a roundabout way.
Anecdotes aside, the article points this out too. Would you expect your fire insurance to cover the cost of batteries for a smoke detector? Of course not. But if it did, the batteries would most likely cost more, since instead of having to sell to millions of battery buyers in Wal-mart, battery makers would be selling to mere dozens of fire insurance companies, who would pass on the costs to those buying the insurance, and hence have no incentive to control battery costs. Even worse, the administrative costs of having people constantly file battery-replacement claims would dwarf the cost of the battery itself. So people would suddenly be paying $25 more a month to avoid buying $2 worth of batteries.
Sounds absurd I'm sure, but that is exactly how our comprehensive health insurance works today.
If people actually used health insurance for things that are equivalent to a house burning down, it would function more like other insurance, and get cheaper. I'm 26, and my most expensive health expense to date was my birth. The next closest thing was probably when I had my adenoids out when I was 7. After that, when I broke my big toe ($900). None of those are akin to having a house burn down or getting in a car wreck. The first two were predictable and all three could be payable with credit or HSAs. It makes no sense to pay thousands of dollars a month so you can go to the doctor for free when it would only cost $150 anyway.
My point, though, is that multiple competing private health care providers create administrative overhead without delivering the benefits of competition because sick people are a captive market, and thus normal market forces are unable to operate properly. If you look into the history of private fire companies you'll see problems which are echoed in today's health care system.
Furthermore, there are many free markets in which consumers cannot be fully informed which work just fine. I know very little about the design of video cards, the maintainence of automobiles, how to remodel a house, what makes a good lawyer, whether my glasses are good for my vision, or myriad other things I pay others for on a regular basis. Nonetheless, I am able to navigate these markets just fine and make tradeoffs according to my personal values. The combined effect of consumer reports, public opinion, and paid personal advocates seems to get me there okay.
I submit that in a free market, most would have no more difficulty shopping for a docter than they do for a mechanic.
And while patients cannot choose when or how to fall ill, they can choose what to treat, what to treat well, what to invest in preventing, and what to simply tough out. The dire necessity of my owning a car does not prevent competition between car dealerships.
OK, I am not being entirely serious here. but I think market solutions don't work that well when it comes to healthcare because patients can neither be fully informed consumers (without a medical degree) nor can they exercise a free choice about when they plan to fall ill. Consider: having your house burn down is also a bit unpredictable, so you buy insurance for that. And indeed, the costs of a home fire can run into the hundreds of thousands, not incomparable to the cost of health problems. And yet, fire insurance is way, way cheaper than health insurance. Why?
Hint: it's not due to competing fire departments. We used to have those, but we got rid of them for a reason.