News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by psadauskas on Thursday August 13, 2009 @10:20AM (#760809)
I've been using Arch as my primary desktop for a couple years, after switching from Gentoo. It reminds me a lot of the early days of Gentoo, the wiki is great, and the community is helpful. There's been very little breakage from their rolling updates, and when there is, there's usually a warning on the news page about how to fix it, before the update is even released.
Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by JeremyChase on Thursday August 13, 2009 @10:03AM (#760773)
This link from the article was more interesting to me: http://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Arch_vs_Others
Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by _pi on Thursday August 13, 2009 @10:23AM (#760815)
Having been there and back again I laugh at the elitism on this page now.

"Arch doesn't offer such a facility as it goes against TheArchWay. SUSE, therefore, is widely regarded as more appropriate for less-experienced users, or those who want a more GUI-driven environment, autoconfiguration and expected functionality out of the box. "

Such an elegant way of saying SUSE IS 4 teh noobz and i use arch kuz i'm hardcore.

Having been there and back again I find myself on FC, because it's stable. I know that I can update the fucking thing whenever, or not even update for a year and it won't fuck up my install. Unlike Arch which if you don't update for 1-3 month's you're guaranteed a fuckup because you missed 2 critical updates and there's no way to get them unless you feel like manually finding the actual packages and installing them.

That page misses an important aspect, Arch sucks for stability, programming, and people who hate typing pacman -Syu every damn day. Arguably stability and programming are finer points for the SUSE distro because, it's got a plethora of development packages which are installable at various versions (yast/zypper is a bit of a bitch about this though), as well as the fact that SUSE handles concurrent versions way better than Arch.

"Fedora has a scheduled release cycle. Arch is a rolling-release system. The Arch design approach is geared more toward lightweight elegance and minimalism rather than automation/autoconfiguration."

I also love this perl of wisdom, no it's not. I can get a minimal FC11 install, or I can install CentOS and get the same damn minimalism and elegance and lightweightness. How do you judge how lightweight a distro is? I can remove every component from fedora and suse. I don't need their gui tools installed, nor do I need their commandline-ncurses tools installed. If Fedora decided to support kmod then it'd have more modular packages than Arch, so what is this mythical lightweightness? Is Gentoo more light weight than Arch? Or Is the opposite true, because Gentoo's ebuild directory can span anywhere from 700mb (generous) to 2 gb.

Here's the bottom line, most OS comparison is FUD. In most distros moving the ease of use up just makes the window of use bigger (a more inclusive user base, ie people who only use the gui or people who only use the cli or a mix).

Also I enjoyed the fact that Arch pretty much says, we break patent law freely because we don't have a backing company who one can get money out of with a lawsuit:

"Fedora famously doesn't attempt to support the MP3 media format due to perceived patent issues. Arch is more lenient in its disposition toward MP3 and other media."

Maybe I'm jaded from all the "ZOMG ARCH LINUX" crap on /r/linux, but Arch isn't as 'teh awesome' as people make it out to be. In fact when you use x64-bit distro all the speed ups (some more than others) that Arch used to tout with i686 packages disappear.

Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by psadauskas on Thursday August 13, 2009 @10:38AM (#760845)
I can't believe that you've actually used Arch. I had one server here that hadn't been updated in over a year, and `pacman -Syu` worked perfectly, no breakage at all.

As for development, its much better than debian- or redhat-based distros, because you don't ever have to install any -dev (or is it -devel?) packages, or go hunt down someone else's repo, because the version of a package you're using is obsolete and missing a feature you need, and won't be updated in mainline for another 4 months, if they even do it then.

Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by _pi on Thursday August 13, 2009 @10:50AM (#760872)
>I can't believe that you've actually used Arch. I had one server here that hadn't been updated in over a year, and `pacman -Syu` worked perfectly, no breakage at all.

Desktop packages are way more finicky, obviously you didn't use it when they switched from devfs to udev (Between 0.7 and 0.8 releases, I've used it on-n-off for 5+ mo at a time since 0.4) as other major infrastructure overhauls like the PAM overhaul 3. Then again it wasn't cool to use arch at that time.

Since Judd Left the team the releases have gotten a bit lazier, they used to come out every 4 months now it's every year if that.

>As for development, its much better than debian- or redhat-based distros, because you don't ever have to install any -dev (or is it -devel?) packages, or go hunt down someone else's repo, because the version of a package you're using is obsolete and missing a feature you need, and won't be updated in mainline for another 4 months, if they even do it then.

Enjoy working on something moderately complex then, when it automatically updates it for you it'll fuck up your entire code base, so this happens several times a year and you're fucked. So unless you want to do maintenance as you're trying to actually code something rolling release isn't for you unless you like pulling hair. Not only that but culling of features happens much more than addition.

Also your lack of understanding of -dev packages shows you've never really used other distros, SuSE, Fedora, and Debian support group installations of packages such as development packages, development tools, IDE's etc, as well as wildcards in their package managers. So that's a very very moot point.

Not only that but SUSE which is designed with the programmer in mind has several different repos which contain different versions and the most up to date versions of packages.

Oh and by the way, that whole ROlling vs Staged release thing only shows a difference when major architecture is overhauled the lines in reality between those two release styles are blurring, especially with the expansion of OSS and people who work with it. Example: FC11 has kde 4.3 in updates-testing (not rawhide), it originally shipped with 4.2.2, and right now 4.2.4-rsomething is stable. Also Arch isn't as bleeding edge as it lets on some updates have been withheld for months because the developers are too lazy to recompile stuff.

Oh and if you don't have a package you do what you do in Arch, you either make a spec file for it and compile it yourself or go to 3rd party repos (Arch has like 1 actual 3rd party repo I think, unlike the 5-6 for Fedora).

Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by psadauskas on Thursday August 13, 2009 @12:34PM (#761127)
Yes, I've developed on both, and find the redhat ones to be much, much worse. Perhaps its a different development area, I do mostly Ruby and other dynamic languages. The -dev is a PITA when I want to install the mysql ruby gem, but I can't because it can't find the headers, so I have to go hunt down if I want mysql-client-dev, mysql-devel, or something else. With Arch, if I have mysql installed, I have the headers. Done.

I find the 1 3rd party repo to be a far better situation. I've never even needed it, everything is in the main pacman repos, or AUR. If I need the latest git, I have to decide if I need Dag, or EPEL, or some other one. And compiling your own is trivial in Arch, a ~10-line description file vs the nightmare that is rpmbuild. I don't have any experience building .deb, so I can't comment on that.

Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by _pi on Thursday August 13, 2009 @12:52PM (#761182)
Then you install packages the wrong way.

IE, yum install mysql* ruby* gem* will get you everything

> And compiling your own is trivial in Arch, a ~10-line description file vs the nightmare that is rpmbuild.

Now you're just trolling.

Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by sho on Thursday August 13, 2009 @03:35PM (#761525)
"when I want to install the mysql ruby gem, but I can't because it can't find the headers, so I have to go hunt down if I want mysql-client-dev, mysql-devel, or something else."

While I'm sympathetic to your issues with RH (I recently left it - again) what you describe there is ridiculous.

  yum install mysql mysql-server mysql-devel
.. that's it. Now if you'd complained about the version of mysql that installed then I would heartily endorse your criticism but c'mon - there is nothing wrong with the above command.

And having to remember weird flags for pacman ("-Syu" to update? wtf?) is far worse. In fact, when I saw that it pretty much made me lose interest in playing with Arch at all. I love unix but pointless arcanity is stupid and user-hostile. "yum update" (or "apt-get upgrade") are much easier to remember, with no loss in functionality, and seeing complexity for complexity's sake like that in Arch is a bad sign to me.

Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by bhrgunatha on Thursday August 13, 2009 @10:11AM (#760789)
I'm planning on switching to Arch the next time I rebuild my machine.

I've been using Ubuntu for about 18 months now, but I've become disenchanted with certain things. After playing around with Arch in a virtual machine for a few weeks now, I'm really happy with how much I've learned about how things work, I've also been using KDE so the news about splitting into smaller packages has finally sealed the deal.

The documentation on their wiki is also another big plus.

Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by Legion on Thursday August 13, 2009 @12:08PM (#761062)
I used to use Slackware and then Gentoo, but have been on Ubuntu for a while now.

I gave Arch a shot a few weeks ago, and I struggled to find a real advantage to using it.

What I did find instead, however, were a ton of broken packages because Arch had moved on to libjpeg7, but the packages hadn't.

Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by Confusion on Thursday August 13, 2009 @12:24PM (#761096)
Oh joy, a distro advertisement: nice fuel for a flamewar. Considering the username: double advertisement.
Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by tom_b on Thursday August 13, 2009 @10:13AM (#760794)
For those interested, I have enjoyed using Arch Linux on an old T23 Thinkpad with limited (512MB) memory. With one of the light-weight windows managers, it kept the machine nicely usable as a dev/fun environment.
Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by JeremyChase on Thursday August 13, 2009 @10:28AM (#760826)
For what it's worth any of the Linux/GNU or BSD's will run on older hardware; provided you don't go overboard with X. If you forgo Gnome or KDE in favor of FVWM2 or XFCE the system will run very well on less than 256Megs of ram.

Unfortunately, if you are forced to run Firefox the system resources immediately become a problem. Seamonkey is a viable alternative, but is dated. Chrome may be the way to go, but that is yet to be proven.

Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by dtf on Thursday August 13, 2009 @11:17AM (#760944)
Chromium dev builds are working great on my older laptop. Plugins aren't that stable but you'd probably want to avoid them anyway. The Arora browser (also WebKit) is worth a look too.
Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by steiger on Thursday August 13, 2009 @11:44PM (#762311)
Sure, but some (Ubuntu, for example) are just undesirable as a distro to run on an old hardware. Some don't even support old hardware, say the 586 archtecture (Pentium).

More important so, distros have different goals and mentalities. I don't think it would make sense, for example, to strip Ubuntu, for example, to make it run on a very old hardware. So, it's not _any_ distribution that you _can_ or _should_ run on older hardware. Some just don't suit.

Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by thunk on Thursday August 13, 2009 @10:05AM (#760778)
... with the most perfectly named package manager ever. Period.
Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by locopati on Thursday August 13, 2009 @10:14AM (#760798)
Period.Period.Period.BIG PERIOD.Ghost.Chomp.
Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by gaia-forming on Thursday August 13, 2009 @12:43PM (#761161)
Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by steiger on Thursday August 13, 2009 @11:10PM (#762268)
Screenshots just tell absolutelly nothing about a linux distro.
Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by Raphael on Thursday August 13, 2009 @02:35PM (#761408)
It's not a question of eye candy. I'm afraid the packages are just not bleeding edge.
Re:Arch Linux: The Simple, Flexible (and Fast) Distro by c00p3r on Thursday August 13, 2009 @02:04PM (#761327)
It's all done. Redhat wins enterprise (server) market, while Ubuntu "just works" on desktop.