News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by twoodfin on Thursday April 17, 2014 @03:20PM (#7605727)
The debate over the nation’s budget deficit aside, government’s contribution to innovation is not financially rewarded. The benefits to government, it has always been argued, would be increases in tax revenues as companies grow based on its research. The fact that Apple avoids almost all taxes by international avoidance strategies, as do many other high-technology companies, shows such hypotheses to be largely bogus.

This sounds to me like a non sequitur. The government has collected massive tax revenue from a growing Apple, let alone the larger, more productive economy spurred by the internet as a whole. Income taxes on Apple's employees, capital gains taxes on AAPL stock transactions, sales taxes on Apple products...

If spending on basic research leads to even a tenth of a percent of higher annual GDP growth, it will almost certainly pay for itself as that compounds over time into a much larger tax base.

Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by beloch on Thursday April 17, 2014 @04:26PM (#7606071)
I don't understand why some feel the need to defend Apple on this count. They've evaded taxes to an outrageous degree and are sitting on a pile of cash so big it would take generations for the company to get anywhere near bankruptcy again. Had they been forced to pay the taxes any sane tax regime would say they owe, they'd still be the same company making the same products. They'd just have a smaller nest-egg.

Non sequitur or not, this actually cuts to the heart of the matter. Governments play a huge role in innovation, so we should stop using false claims to the contrary when rationalizing theft of revenues the government is owed for its work. Corporate tax evasion is a crime against innovation and theft from all of us who actually do pay our taxes.

Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by crusso on Thursday April 17, 2014 @04:46PM (#7606214)
They've evaded taxes

The government screws up the tax laws through utter dysfunction and you imply/say that Apple and other big companies are breaking the law?

To my knowledge, Apple is paying all of the taxes required by US law. The fact that the government wants a bigger chunk doesn't change the fact that they aren't legally entitled to it.

Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by gopher1 on Thursday April 17, 2014 @05:04PM (#7606338)
The government screws up the tax laws because they have been captured by the lobbying arms of large multi-national corporations, including Apple. It's no surprise then that those same corporations are the ones who get to pay 0% taxes while your average startup or mom & pop business has to pay the 35% corporate tax rate because they don't have a dozen tax lawyers on retainer to get them through the loopholes.

Why give the corporations who spend millions lobbying against tax reform a pass, just because they're "technically" lawful?

Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by crusso on Thursday April 17, 2014 @05:15PM (#7606428)
Why give the corporations who spend millions lobbying against tax reform a pass

Because unfair taxation is just a symptom of the core problem of too much trust in an institutionally corrupt government.

Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by gopher1 on Thursday April 17, 2014 @05:32PM (#7606543)
So even though you acknowledge that the taxation system is unfair, and that it's due to a corrupt system. Despite the fact that this corrupt crony-capitalist system involves two actors, corporations and government, for some reason, you only blame the government?

Just because there may be a better system that exists out there in the abstract, where government is less centralized, and thus potentially less vulnerable to corruption, it seems like quite a bizarre leap of logic to exonerate one of the two main actors in the existing corrupt system.

Can you explain your logic please?

Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by crusso on Thursday April 17, 2014 @06:04PM (#7606760)
The corporation is doing what it's supposed to do within the system. It's supposed to look out for its own interests, obey the law, and make money for its shareholders.

The government is fundamentally broken. It's trusted as the law maker and the enforcer of the system, but fails in its main supposed benefit of trustworthiness.

Blaming the corporations for lobbying and planning their taxes is like kicking a kitten for drinking out of a bowl of milk that you left on the floor.

Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by waps on Friday April 18, 2014 @08:52AM (#7608961)
I agree the point where purpose and incentives don't align isn't companies, it's government(s). However how can you fix that ? Democracy at least puts some limits on how far it can go, but doesn't seem to fix the problem.
Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by crusso on Friday April 18, 2014 @12:20PM (#7609805)
That's because people aren't smart enough to elect their own high quality leaders. Then after that, they aren't smart enough to assess the quality of the leaders they elected.

The Dunning-Kruger effect is a good example of why that is.

This is where capitalism is different from government. Money flows to success and tends to form feedback amplification. Smart people make more money than stupid ones. Smart people reward smart companies with their increased access to money.

The above is why I want to see government as small as reasonably possible. It should be limited to providing a basic framework, defense, maybe some basic research like for the Internet, Space exploration, etc. Only things that have a good track record of success. After that, though, the answers should typically come from the private sector where winners and losers get sorted out based more often upon merits than politics.

Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by nickff on Thursday April 17, 2014 @04:41PM (#7606172)
>"They've evaded taxes to an outrageous degree"

How did you arrive at this (normative) judgement? They are paying the minimum in taxes that they legally can, so that they can invest the money in research, buy back stocks, or hold it in reserve for some period of time; why is this bad? Do you have any evidence that the government's allocation of additional funds would be more productive than Apple's use of the money?

Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by scotty79 on Thursday April 17, 2014 @05:27PM (#7606507)
Why exploiting the flaws in your computer system to get access to things you intended to keep out of reach is bad?

The point of having taxes is for government to extract money from companies that collect lots of money from their clients. If you are using technicalities of the system to go against this goal you are only as bad as a hacker that uses technicalities of system you built and maintain to get access to things that were supposed to be protected.

Don't get me wrong. I don't see nothing intrinsically wrong in using law or any other system to full extent. What makes it wrong or not are additional circumstances. Evading taxes in badly managed country to fund basic research or education is much less bad than putting this money right in the pockets of various wealthy people so they can buy yahts.

Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by gopher1 on Thursday April 17, 2014 @04:57PM (#7606284)
It's bad because it's unfair.

If everyone, including small businesses, got to pay 0% tax, then you might have a good argument. But as it stands, we have a 35% corporate tax rate for everyone except large multi-national companies who have the means to take advantage of the loopholes. Regular Joe Business does not have those means.

And of course, these same large companies are spending millions lobbying the government to not reform the code.

Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by tzs on Thursday April 17, 2014 @07:56PM (#7607267)
Apple's income taxes in the US were $13.1 billion on $50.2 billion in earnings, for an effective income tax rate of 26.2% [1].

I don't know why so many people think Apple pays little or no tax. They are in fact the 3rd largest income tax payer in the US.

[1] http://finance.yahoo.com/news/companies-paying-most-taxes-17...

Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by liber8 on Thursday April 17, 2014 @07:28PM (#7607174)
This doesn't take away from your point, but from a practical perspective, small businesses pay 0% corporate tax. When you have just a few shareholders, as nearly all small businesses do, all profits get paid out as salary. If small businesses didn't do this, their owners would be taxed twice (first at the corporate level and then again individually).

The companies that get squeezed are not the Regular Joe Businesses but the midsize businesses that can't get away with paying out all profits as salary (because they have third party shareholders who don't work for the business) and yet can't afford to set up the necessary bureaucracy to take advantage of things like a Double Irish With a Dutch Sandwich.

Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by djschnei on Thursday April 17, 2014 @05:00PM (#7606306)
Do you actively avoid legal tax breaks because you feel the need to pay your "fair share"? I would bet not. Why should Apple act any differently? They don't evade taxes... They actively seek to pay as little as legally obligated. Anything else would be a disservice to every Apple employee, consumer and financial backer (the only people that should matter to Apple). They're a for profit organization, not a charity...
Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by gopher1 on Thursday April 17, 2014 @05:07PM (#7606353)
He probably avoids paying as much tax as he can, but he also probably doesn't spend millions lobbying politicians. The same can't be said for Apple.
Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by djschnei on Thursday April 17, 2014 @09:02PM (#7607460)
Yea, how dare they spend their money trying to protect their interests.
Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by erehweb on Thursday April 17, 2014 @06:56PM (#7607037)
The terms of art may be important here. Tax evasion is literally a crime, and different from tax avoidance, which is reducing your taxes by legal means. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_evasion
Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by eli_gottlieb on Thursday April 17, 2014 @03:53PM (#7605896)
>This sounds to me like a non sequitur. The government has collected massive tax revenue from a growing Apple, let alone the larger, more productive economy spurred by the internet as a whole. Income taxes on Apple's employees, capital gains taxes on AAPL stock transactions, sales taxes on Apple products...

Compare the real taxes reaped by the state from companies that make use of publicly-funded research versus the alternative: the government holds all intellectual-property rights to publicly-funded discoveries and licenses them for a profit to commercial firms.

Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by twoodfin on Thursday April 17, 2014 @04:18PM (#7606029)
The government's goal isn't to turn a profit: It's to bring a better life to its citizens, improve its ability to defend itself, etc. Basic research being financially self-sustaining is a benefit, but it's not necessary or sufficient for the success of the programs.

But putting that aside, if the government owns the basic research that it funds, why would any (self-interested) researcher or institution choose to work for the government vs. private industry, which can offer a share of future revenue? How does the government set prices for its licensing? Don't we benefit that Jobs and Wozniak didn't have to have a large amount of capital to invest in licensing in order to take advantage of all that basic research?

Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by sanderjd on Thursday April 17, 2014 @05:21PM (#7606474)
> why would any (self-interested) researcher or institution choose to work for the government vs. private industry

For the same reason researchers choose to do so now: the government pays for a lot more fundamental research than private industry does.

Re:Innovation: The Government Was Crucial After All by eli_gottlieb on Thursday April 17, 2014 @08:50PM (#7607420)
I'm not talking about whether the research is self-sustaining or not. I'm talking about whether the economic value of basic research is treated as a positive externality (current situation) or captured by some actor at a market price (my counterfactual).

Why ask that question? Because, quite interestingly, without the value of basic research being captured as revenue with a market price, we don't have numbers to perform a direct comparison between research costs and research revenues to compute the profitability of basic research. We don't actually know right now whether basic research is financially self-sustaining - in which case the apparent "expense" is actually a state subsidy to technological industries - or whether basic research is a financial net-negative. We also don't actually know what lengths of time are necessary to realize the final economic result of basic research.

So we kinda sorta feel pretty sure that basic research eventually helps the economy, but nobody's accounting ledgers actually get forced to reflect that or pay for it.