News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by technotony on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @06:21PM (#7594691)
Thanks for the really great advice. I'm interested in the unequal equity. We have a 60-40 split which seemed fair as I'd worked full time on the company and raised a significant Kickstarter funding before my co-founder committed 100%. Could you comment more on issues you see this brings down the line and how this plays out? Also, does this conflict a little with your next point about clear leadership?
Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by hga on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @06:53PM (#7594832)
Are you interested in some abstract concept of "fairness", or in your company being successful over the next handful of years?

Unless your co-founder is strongly in the direction of a saint, there's a good chance you can choose only one. In the scheme of things, if your venture is successful over the coming years, the details of the original starting positions of the two of you isn't all that big since you're now both 100%; you say so yourself, 60-40....

Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by technotony on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @07:12PM (#7594904)
Obviously want to optimize for success. What I'd really like to know is what are the pitfalls that non-even equity split can bring, so that I can watch to see if that's happening and potentially mitigate.
Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by tptacek on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @08:34PM (#7595236)
Unequal splits are an invitation to resentment and the degraded communication and problem solving that comes with resentment. If you've done a bunch of startups, you've probably had the experience of having a harrowing argument with cofounders, and the realization of how easily your company can disintegrate based on nothing more than silly interpersonal conflicts. Some people, myself included, take from this the lesson that you should rig your startup to minimize these issues as much as possible.

Another reason to avoid unequal splits is that they often presume you can see into the future. Who's to say that whatever you did to "earn" an extra 10% of the company isn't going to be more than offset by something your cofounder does later?

Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by hga on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @07:15PM (#7594921)
"Obviously want to optimize for success."

No, you're optimizing for "fairness" as you see it, for yourself. This split will do nothing good going forward ... unless, of course, you will internally burn at the idea of your cofounder getting more than what you view as his fair share. Which should tell you something, and brings me to:

The pitfalls are inside people's heads and hearts, so I think you'll find that strategy to be particularly difficult to execute.

The cofounder should be obvious; others who, especially down the road when the starting details are lost in time, will ideally see you two working just as hard as each other, and wonder why the split is so uneven. I don't see anything good that can come from that.

Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by technotony on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @08:26PM (#7595209)
This data somewhat contradicts that however, as it says unequal shares are correlated with higher initial funding valuations (obviously that's not a perfect metric) http://siepr.stanford.edu/system/files/shared/pubs/hellmann%...

I'd really like to see the data which suggests equal shares lead to better success outcomes (maybe YC has this?).

Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by tptacek on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @08:46PM (#7595296)
My guess is that the numbers would swing sharply in the other direction if the study accounted for survivorship bias.
Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by jl on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @12:42AM (#7596163)
This article was of course a distilled version of a much longer conversation. The uneven equity split that causes problems is usually along the lines of 75% vs. 25%-- or worse, when one founder gets 10% or less. We see this happen quite often (and advise against it if we're not too late). The founder with 10% often becomes resentful and doesn't feel properly incentivized when he/she is working just as hard as the founder with 85%. A startup is so much about execution-- usually over a long period of time that the argument of "it was my idea" isn't very compelling. (60/40 is usually totally reasonable though, especially in a situation like yours.)
Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by orky56 on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @01:43AM (#7596316)
Should the majority equity holder be the "clear leader" who is the final decision maker?
Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by johnrob on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @08:13PM (#7595155)
I'd give yourself a gift for getting the company off the ground. 5% seems right, but I suppose 10% is not out of the question. Then split the remainder with your co-founder. This process would lead to 52.5/47.5 and 55/45 splits respectively. 60/40 is a 20% gift; I think that's a little high but it could be justified if significant progress has been made. Also, your vesting should of course have an earlier start date.
Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by apinstein on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @08:15AM (#7597243)
My 2c as a founder who's done both 50/50 and non-50/50 startups.

1. The gift need not be equity; cold, hard cash to solve this problem.

I had a side project that I decided to turn into a business when a co-founder became available. We wanted to do a 50-50 split and achieved this by "selling" the IP I had created to a new entity which had the 50-50 split. The cash can stay on the books as an Owner's Contribution (for LLC) or as a liability.

2. My first startup was 65/20/15. My current one is 50/50. The psychological implications of both are very interesting. When I had 65% control, I could ultimately make all the decisions, but the others definitely felt some resentment or maybe a better way to explain it was they thought well he's gonna ultimately do whatever he wants so there's no need to fight too hard about everything. It never felt like it too much convincing to discuss big decisions (nor did I necessarily get tons of input). These were very good friends and we managed it, but anytime there's an obvious veto power, it changes the character of any deliberations.

What 50-50 does besides the "feeling" of fairness is that it forces you to convince the other person that it a certain way. Knowing you cannot just trump someone, you must persuade someone else of the way to go. Both of us understand that there has to be a decision made, and we can never know 100% the right way to go, and sometimes we let one person "win" and vice-versa. It does add a lot of confidence that when we finally do move forward with a direction, everyone is 100% on-board. I would add it helps a lot if you and your co-founder have complementary roles (CTO/CEO) as that can create clear delineation on who gets to "trump" in certain cases. Always better to let the person who has to execute the decision make it!

Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by tptacek on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @08:30PM (#7595223)
5% is an enormous amount of equity to grant for anything. Recruited executives might get 5%. First technical hire often gets that.
Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by 7Figures2Commas on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @11:58PM (#7596023)
> 5% is an enormous amount of equity to grant for anything.

No, it isn't. At a company that has raised capital or generates revenue, 5% might be enormous, or it might not be. It all depends on the company's valuation.

The fundamental problem many early-stage startups run in to is that they haven't raised capital, don't have revenue and they try to use equity as an alternative to monetary compensation.

In these situations, "sweat equity" is almost always a poor alternative because the math rarely makes sense for the recipient. For instance, if you're an experienced developer who can make $125,000/year and a friend wants you to become a co-founder of his business, forgoing salary until some future date or event, how much equity in a business worth $0 today do you need to make up for your salary? It's a trick question, and the answer is not 5%.

Equity can be a very complex matter, but it's also very simple when someone suggests that it be used as a substitute for cash. If somebody wants to pay you for your services using equity, forget percentages. Determine what it's reasonably worth in dollars, if anything, today. If you are willing to accept less than the dollar value of your services, you're being generous to the company, not the other way around.

Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by tptacek on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @09:45AM (#7597676)
5% is a gigantic grant for an employee.

I don't actually disagree with you about employees asked to work on equity-only and deferred salary. It's just that I call those people "cofounders".

Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by 7Figures2Commas on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @12:09PM (#7598617)
While you probably won't receive a 5% grant as a non-executive hire at a venture-backed startup, my point still stands for salaried employees. If you can make $125,000/year, a company offers you $80,000/year and suggests that it's making up the difference in equity, you should still run the numbers. For 5% to compensate you for your sacrifice in this scenario, the company would need to be worth $900,000.

One of the problems employees face in Silicon Valley is that the valuations on angel and venture-backed startups are exorbitant, so the equity is overpriced. Seed stage startups with no traction (and sometimes no launched product) can still sport million-plus valuations. As an employee, it takes a leap of faith to believe in these valuations and use them as the basis for valuing your equity. Fortunately for these startups, enough individuals are willing to take that leap of faith.

Re:Early Stage Startups: The Biggest Killers by golergka on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @05:43AM (#7596847)
There's no such thing as an "objective" fairness, and if it would exist, it wouldn't matter anyway. It only matters if your partner sincerely thinks if it's fair or not, and whether he will think so in the future.