News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself. by ygra on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @09:52AM (#7591776)
The six times figure is for 192kbps and 24 bit. The move from 16 to 24 bit alone would just result in an increase of 50 %.
Re:Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself. by joshstrange on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @10:03AM (#7591842)
Do you have a source for this? I was under the impression that:

    filesize(192kbps + 16bit) = 6*filesize(192kbps + 24bits)
Also the point of both articles is that: You can't hear the difference.

Look at MP3 vs WAV (or FLAC), MP3 won out (for consumers) because of it's filesize being so much smaller. Look at the compression differences:

>> Uncompressed audio as stored on an audio-CD has a bit rate of 1,411.2 kbit/s,[note 2] so the bitrates 128, 160 and 192 kbit/s represent compression ratios of approximately 11:1, 9:1 and 7:1 respectively. [0]

At the best quality listed here (192kbps) MP3 is 7 times smaller than it's WAV counterpart. I just don't see people paying for 6x the space for something they can't tell the difference between. If anything history has proven this not to be the case.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MP3#Bit_rate

Re:Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself. by ygra on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @10:06AM (#7591862)
Trivial arithmetic:

    192 ÷ 48   = 4
     24 ÷ 16   = 1.5
      4 ×  1.5 = 6
The six times is also on the wrong side of your equation, I guess.

But if you need a source, I can cite what you cited:

> Unfortunately, there is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz format. Its playback fidelity is slightly inferior to 16/44.1 or 16/48, and it takes up 6 times the space.

They were talking about both sampling rate and bit depth.

Oh, and just for the record, I do agree with the general idea that it's useless to ship audio to consumers as 192/24, for the same reason it's unwieldy to publish photos online as 20+ MiB raw files (even if browsers could display them). I was just noting that the size comparison included both sampling rate and bit depth and not just one of them.

Re:Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself. by harshreality on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @10:28AM (#7591981)
That equation is so wrong.

filesize(192kHz + 24bit) = 6 * filesize(48kHz + 16bit)

It also only applies directly to raw audio like pcm. Once you encode it (to, say, flac) some of that size increase could disappear depending on the waveform.

I don't know how mp3 is defined for higher dynamic range, but I know frequency range/sampling rate doesn't matter, because a 128kbps mp3 is 128kbps whether the frequency cutoff is 14kHz or 20kHz. Isn't a 192kbps mp3 from a 16/48 master the same size as a 192kbps mp3 from a 24/192 master?

Re:Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself. by ygra on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @10:29AM (#7591991)
All this isn't about MP3, but FLAC which is lossless, so even for the compressed version the same ratios should approximately hold.
Re:Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself. by harshreality on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @04:41PM (#7594151)
Approximately? Either it does or it doesn't. What I'm thinking is that a 4x increase in sampling rate doesn't necessarily lead to a 4x increase in waveform complexity except for certain types of random noise.

With the references to 192kbps and mistakes, it wasn't clear what parent was talking about.

Re:Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself. by DanBC on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @11:29AM (#7592312)
It's not even about file size or quality. People want mp3 because all their devices and software use mp3.

Betamax didn't lose to VHS because it was worse.