News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself. by joshstrange on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @09:50AM (#7591768)
>> Wastes space? In an age where we stream gigabyte movies? Do we need to remind the author that we're no longer in 1982 and that we have evolved beyond floppy disks?

Clever way of leaving out just how much space it takes up (takes up 6 times the space [0][1]) also as both this author and Xiph concluded you can't really hear the difference. When we stream HD (As you put it "Gigabyte movies") we are getting a clearly superior product. I can easily see the difference between 480/720/1080 whereas I seriously doubt I can hear the difference between 16 and 24bit audio. Yes space is cheaper than it used to be but it's neither free nor unlimited, not to mention the primary way people listen to music nowadays is probably on mobile devices where space is still at a premium or they enjoy their music via a streaming service a la Spotify/Rdio/Google Music where bandwidth is at a premium (And storage factors in here as well due to either being able to store less songs locally or in cache due to larger file size).

[0] http://people.xiph.org/~xiphmont/demo/neil-young.html

[1] http://blog.beatunes.com/2014/04/does-24-bit-audio-matter.ht...

Re:Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself. by ygra on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @09:52AM (#7591776)
The six times figure is for 192kbps and 24 bit. The move from 16 to 24 bit alone would just result in an increase of 50 %.
Re:Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself. by joshstrange on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @10:03AM (#7591842)
Do you have a source for this? I was under the impression that:

    filesize(192kbps + 16bit) = 6*filesize(192kbps + 24bits)
Also the point of both articles is that: You can't hear the difference.

Look at MP3 vs WAV (or FLAC), MP3 won out (for consumers) because of it's filesize being so much smaller. Look at the compression differences:

>> Uncompressed audio as stored on an audio-CD has a bit rate of 1,411.2 kbit/s,[note 2] so the bitrates 128, 160 and 192 kbit/s represent compression ratios of approximately 11:1, 9:1 and 7:1 respectively. [0]

At the best quality listed here (192kbps) MP3 is 7 times smaller than it's WAV counterpart. I just don't see people paying for 6x the space for something they can't tell the difference between. If anything history has proven this not to be the case.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MP3#Bit_rate

Re:Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself. by ygra on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @10:06AM (#7591862)
Trivial arithmetic:

    192 ÷ 48   = 4
     24 ÷ 16   = 1.5
      4 ×  1.5 = 6
The six times is also on the wrong side of your equation, I guess.

But if you need a source, I can cite what you cited:

> Unfortunately, there is no point to distributing music in 24-bit/192kHz format. Its playback fidelity is slightly inferior to 16/44.1 or 16/48, and it takes up 6 times the space.

They were talking about both sampling rate and bit depth.

Oh, and just for the record, I do agree with the general idea that it's useless to ship audio to consumers as 192/24, for the same reason it's unwieldy to publish photos online as 20+ MiB raw files (even if browsers could display them). I was just noting that the size comparison included both sampling rate and bit depth and not just one of them.

Re:Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself. by harshreality on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @10:28AM (#7591981)
That equation is so wrong.

filesize(192kHz + 24bit) = 6 * filesize(48kHz + 16bit)

It also only applies directly to raw audio like pcm. Once you encode it (to, say, flac) some of that size increase could disappear depending on the waveform.

I don't know how mp3 is defined for higher dynamic range, but I know frequency range/sampling rate doesn't matter, because a 128kbps mp3 is 128kbps whether the frequency cutoff is 14kHz or 20kHz. Isn't a 192kbps mp3 from a 16/48 master the same size as a 192kbps mp3 from a 24/192 master?

Re:Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself. by ygra on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @10:29AM (#7591991)
All this isn't about MP3, but FLAC which is lossless, so even for the compressed version the same ratios should approximately hold.
Re:Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself. by harshreality on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @04:41PM (#7594151)
Approximately? Either it does or it doesn't. What I'm thinking is that a 4x increase in sampling rate doesn't necessarily lead to a 4x increase in waveform complexity except for certain types of random noise.

With the references to 192kbps and mistakes, it wasn't clear what parent was talking about.

Re:Does pono's 24-bit audio matter? Hear for yourself. by DanBC on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @11:29AM (#7592312)
It's not even about file size or quality. People want mp3 because all their devices and software use mp3.

Betamax didn't lose to VHS because it was worse.