News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Heartleech: Automated OpenSSL private key extraction tool... by eli on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @09:23AM (#7591627)
I would imagine the motivation is less about money and more about having fun breaking stuff (and bragging rights).

I agree though. Hard to argue that this particular security issue needed any extra attention in order to get it fixed.

Re:Heartleech: Automated OpenSSL private key extraction tool... by makomk on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @09:51AM (#7591774)
It's quite easy to argue that actually. People pointed out that those Snort and other IDS rules were inadequate as soon as they were released, yet it hasn't stopped vendors from claiming they offer protection.
Re:Heartleech: Automated OpenSSL private key extraction tool... by clogston on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @03:33PM (#7593836)
"yet it hasn't stopped vendors from claiming they offer protection"

100% true. The argument Dan and others are trying to make is there are a lot of people caught in the cross-fire who have nothing to do with IDS-vendors claims.

Re:Heartleech: Automated OpenSSL private key extraction tool... by danielweber on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @12:05PM (#7592580)
I totally understand the desire to tweak the IDS vendors. Having spent a lot of time working for vendors in that space, they often need tweaking.

But I don't get the leap from "IDS vendors suck" to "I made a command-line tool so any idiot can suck down private keys from a server." If the idea was to show that the IDS rules sucked, then just release a slightly different version of the previous heartbleed testers that gets around it.

But that's not as much fun.

Re:Heartleech: Automated OpenSSL private key extraction tool... by danielweber on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @09:45AM (#7591743)
One of the biggest root causes of problems in the security industry is that often the only way to make a name for yourself is to cause pain to others. (It's not too hard to convince yourself that those others deserved it.)

If you went back in time two years and fixed the Heartbleed bug, no one would be writing newspaper articles about you.

Re:Heartleech: Automated OpenSSL private key extraction tool... by robertgraham on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @04:02PM (#7593962)
Nobody is writing articles at Neel Mehta, the guy who discovered the bug. They should, he's a god.
Re:Heartleech: Automated OpenSSL private key extraction tool... by nitrogen on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @02:22PM (#7593434)
If you invented time travel people would definitely be writing about it.
Re:Heartleech: Automated OpenSSL private key extraction tool... by vezzy-fnord on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @03:22PM (#7593780)
If you went back in time two years and fixed the Heartbleed bug, no one would be writing newspaper articles about you.

This is hardly something isolated to the security industry. It's human nature. Some person sealing a hole is nowhere near as attention-gathering as a hole leading to a catastrophic flood due to no one realizing that it needs to be sealed.

The potential for something bad to happen doesn't raise anywhere near as much eyebrows as the bad thing actually happening, especially for something as invisible to the average person as a software vulnerability.